14 ms·
Zoom Rolling Out End-to-End Encryption Offering
- zucked 6y ago>Enabling this version of Zoom’s E2EE in your meetings disables certain features, including join before host, cloud recording, streaming, live transcription, Breakout Rooms, polling, 1:1 private chat, and meeting reactions. So, it disables all the parts of video conferencing that make it a somewhat suitable stand-in for in-person meetings?
- pulse7 6y agoAsk HN: Who of the readers here believe this is a true E2E encryption - so that even government can not see the content?
- MikeKusold 6y agoThey acquired the Keybase team to implement this. If there is a backdoor, I'd expect a mass exodus of the team.
- taxcoder 6y agoInteresting. I just added Keybase to my "look at this later" Firefox bookmarks. I wonder if the acquisition will harm Keybase?
- jamesboehmer 6y agoCommits dropped off in April/May of this year, and users in keybase forums elsewhere have been discussing the lack of activity and communication from the team. It's unclear whether they plan to come back to it, fold it into Zoom somehow, or just abandon it. https://github.com/keybase/client/graphs/commit-activity https://github.com/keybase/client/graphs/commit-activity
- taxcoder 6y agoThanks. I just saw the link that was added to this thread and read the HN discussion from after the announcement.
- joncrane 6y ago> I wonder if the acquisition will harm Keybase? There were many discussions about it when the "Zoom acquires Keybase" story was on the front page of HN, and the overwhelming sentiment was "yes."
- FullyFunctional 6y agoI’m very dependent on Keybase and use it all day. The acquisition is major concern but so far the service has remains stable and responsive. Crossing my fingers.
- edm0nd 6y agoI expect them (Zoom) to clean up and surge some Keybase teams eventually. All of the top teams are related to crypto currency, hentai/porn, and 3d printing firearms. Not very "corporate" or family friendly subjects.
- FullyFunctional 6y ago(purge?) I only use private teams for friends and colleagues but I use the encrypted cloud storage and have lots of git repos. I wasn’t even aware of public teams but between HN, Twitter, and Discord I don’t need more distraction. I’d even gladly pay a monthly subscription if it would guarantee the continued existence.
- jbyers 6y agoThe author of the blog post is one of the founders of Keybase (and also a member of Hn, maxtaco).
- criddell 6y agoWhat do you mean by backdoor? For example, say they have the capability to add a law enforcement key to the list of keys being used to encrypt the channel to allow eavesdropping. I wouldn't call that a backdoor.
- beervirus 6y agoIf that's not a backdoor, what in the world is?
- criddell 6y agoI like Dr. Roberts (Stanford) definition, so I'll just paste it: > A "backdoor" in computing is a method of bypassing the normal method of authentication. Backdoors are usually inserted into a program or algorithm before it is distributed widely. They are often hidden in part of the design of the program or algorithm. In cryptography specifically, a backdoor would allow an intruder to access the encrypted information without having the correct credentials. The backdoor would either a) allow the intruder to guess the access key based on the context of the message or b) allow the intruder to present a skeleton key that will always grant him access. Probably the most famous backdoor is the Dual_EC_DRBG which I believe had a weakness in the random number generator that leaked its internal state.
- merelydev 6y agoNoob question here: is it difficult to implement E2E encryption one would think Zoom has all the resources required to build such a system?
- throwaway373438 6y agoKind of. The real problem is that E2E means losing all server-side videoconferencing features - very few people actually want E2E. It's not an add-on feature. The ramifications are a completely different way of shuttling the data between endpoints.
- richardwhiuk 6y agoHence: > Do I have access to all the features of a regular Zoom meeting? > Not right now. Enabling this version of Zoom’s E2EE in your meetings disables certain features, including join before host, cloud recording, streaming, live transcription, Breakout Rooms, polling, 1:1 private chat, and meeting reactions. Some of those features they can bring back, some they might not be able to.
- proactivesvcs 6y agoWell they previously claimed their service was E2E, then there was a furore when it was discovered that was not true, after which they claimed their service was E2E, when it still was not. Considering their growth throughout, why would they waste their time implementing it fully and correctly?
- user5994461 6y agoI think you're asking the wrong question. E2E is actively harmful to videoconference beyond two participants. A waste of time is an euphemism, I bet you that it would actively hurt many metrics/teams if done and these would push to have it reverted. A videoconference has to be able to adjust audio and video quality in real time between participants. E2E is a technical barrier to that because the streams are encrypted and harder to work with, it is possible to have E2E but it's hard work and it's resource intensive and it affects reliability.
- andruby 6y agoI haven't read this before that E2E is a barrier to adaptive audio & video quality. Would you care to elaborate or is there a source I could read up on?
- pimterry 6y agoWithout E2EE, the server can directly access and manage how the video and audio streams are sent to each client. It can downgrade video for participants who are struggling, prioritize throughput of audio data for certain clients, prioritize higher res video only for the user who's currently speaking, drop individual frames for clients that are getting behind, etc etc. With E2EE, by definition, the server becomes a dumb relay, and all control moves into the clients. Depending on how E2EE is implemented, you then lose the ability to do some or all of these optimizations. There are potential workarounds, but each comes with further tradeoffs in turn, in performance, privacy & complexity. That's not to say that it's completely impossible to optimize given E2EE, as you can move many optimizations to each client, or try to have clients expose just enough data for servers to optimize traffic without being able to read the contents (e.g. by splitting the audio & video streams so the server can manage them independently, or having each client upload separate high & low res video of their own video stream). It definitely makes many optimizations dramatically harder though, creates some serious engineering problems, and in practice rules out some optimizations completely.
- upofadown 6y agoIt appears to tick all the boxes other than verifiable client binaries... So ahead of things like iMessage. About the same as stuff like Whatsapp. Behind things like Signal, Telegram, PGP and the like.
- vngzs 6y agoPGP can be considered "worse" than some of the other systems because it lacks perfect forward secrecy. If you steal the key, you can decrypt past messages, which is not the case in Signal or others. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Ratchet_Algorithm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Ratchet_Algorithm
- upofadown 6y agoOK, but that has nothing to do with how end to end the encryption is. PGP pretty much set the standard for the concept. BTW, in practice few people get any benefit out of forward secrecy when used for E2EE messaging as they tend to keep their old messages. Forward secrecy protects against the disclosure of the private key used in such systems. If the attacker can get at your private key then they pretty much for sure get your saved messages. I talked about this in a series of PGP advocacy articles I recently did: * https://articles.59.ca/doku.php?id=pgpfan:forward_secrecy https://articles.59.ca/doku.php?id=pgpfan:forward_secrecy
- aborsy 6y agoIt’s like saying that LUKS is bad because it doesn’t offer forward secrecy, or it’s more “cumbersome”; signal protocol is better. There are different applications with different solutions.
- cataflam 6y agoDoes Telegram have E2EE for group discussions yet or is it still only for 1:1 ? Honest question, I haven't checked recently.
- lozf 6y agoUnfortunately still only 1:1 And on mobile only. E2EE is not available in group chats or on the desktop client.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- WilTimSon 6y agoHonestly, I know they hired a good team to do it and stand to lose everything if they didn't implement it properly... but they lied about it once and that was so brazen that I won't believe it until it's confirmed by at least a few independent experts. Zoom, in my mind, is synonymous with invaded privacy, poor security and lies.
- a1369209993 6y ago> Who of the readers here believe this is a true E2E encryption - so that even government can not see the content? Pfahahahahahaha. More seriously, my understanding is that Zoom uses automatic updates, so it can never be secure even in the unlikely event the code that's on your machine this week actually does correctly implement end-to-end encryption. Also, if you're trusting Zoom's servers to give you the encryption keys you have a MitM attack waiting to happen.
- morpheuskafka 6y agoI think it won't be designed with a built-in backdoor, but probably also not designed very well. Like WhatsApp instead of Signal. Closed source, edge cases not covered well, etc. Not going to be anyone's go to for high-assurance protection from state actors.
- jb775 6y agoIt's kind of a moot point since the government already has backdoors built into operating systems, hardware chips, browsers (therefore can enable screen-sharing + other hardware settings remotely), etc. "True" E2E encryption doesn't really exist nowadays, at least in the context of being spied on by governments. Edit: Direct sources don't really exist for obvious reasons. Google it, and there's plenty of articles to help you read between the lines. If you think the govt isn't capable or interested in this, you're being naive.
- mynameisvlad 6y agoDo you have a source on that? That's a mighty big claim. Edit: Cool, so no sources then. Now it's a mighty big unverified claim based on what the governments might be capable and willing to do.
- rimliu 6y agoDon't forget the chips injected with vaccines! /s, obviously.
- mrstubbs 6y agoWith a closed-source client, how do we know Zoom does not add itself as a un-anounced participant in a meeting?? I assume there will be analysis done in the near future by third parties, but even that analysis is not sufficient to protect against a future change or a one-off, court-mandated targeted "switch" to join a un-announced participant to a meeting. The client can be designed to be 'dumb' in this regard.
- aneutron 6y agoI'm curious about what they call "enhanced AES-GCM encryption". Because to me that smells like "roll your own crypto" kind of deal, where "moar perf" quickly ends up being "moar sidechannels" (whether willingly or not). It does sound very intriguing to me at least.
- jhardy54 6y agoI'm also very curious about this. AES-GCM satisfies my threat model, "enhanced" does not.
- blakesterz 6y agoI'm curious about your threat model, only because this doesn't concern me much. Why does this not satisfy yours, I'm afraid I'm a missing something.
- TrainedMonkey 6y agoI believe parent infers that 'enhanced' means they modified crypto stack and broke prime directive: "Never roll your own crypto".
- jhardy54 6y agoThe word 'enhanced' in the context of cryptography just means 'modified', and modifications to security-critical algorithms are considered unsafe unless proven safe. AES-GCM refers to a specific set of trade-offs. How do those trade-offs differ with the changes that Zoom has made?
- fsflover 6y agoNot sure how a closed code can satisfy a threat model depending on the encryption details. If you trust the company to implement AES-GCM in secrecy, why not also trust with the "enhanced" part?
- Rebelgecko 6y ago
- hartator 6y agoIs it true end to end or end to China to end kind of thing?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dheera 6y agoZoom is not a Chinese company. They are based in San Jose, California. While they may have shut down activist accounts in China before that is more likely because they want to maintain their unblocked status in China for business reasons. It is also possible that Zoom must cooperate with Chinese authorities in providing local user information to maintain their unblocked status, that is true about all Microsoft and Apple products as well and true about several other countries besides China as well. Your information shouldn't be touching servers in China unless you are communicating to or from China. That said, personally, I don't fully trust anyone's end-to-end claims unless the client is open source OR protocol is open for third-party clients.
- president 6y ago> Zoom is not a Chinese company. They are based in San Jose, California. What does it matter where they are based if their operations in the US are beholden to Chinese government coercion?
- dheera 6y agoA. Chinese government coercion typically only extends to users who are physically in China. They mostly just want to suppress organized political behavior. So they don't usually care about what users are talking about outside their borders. B. By not being based in China, they can publicly say something about IF it it happens to be the case otherwise, and also have the choice to exit China if they wish. If they were based in China they may be forced to keep quiet. (That said, there is also US government coercion, so it's about which evil you think is worse, I guess. I'd honestly rather they were based in Sweden or some other place.)
- preinheimer 6y agoI wonder if their acquisition of keybase has been done long enough for it to have been helpful here. Zoom acquires Keybase: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23102430 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23102430
- guepe 6y agoIMHO, the acquisition was mainly for two reasons: - signaling, to its customers and the market that they are taking this issue seriously - management "cover-my-ass": if somehow the overhaul is taking longer than expected, someone can claim "we tried everything we could" There are secondary benefits, the acquisition did bring some probably-helpful talent around encryption/infosec, but as you said the rollout seems really fast vs acquisition time for a product that size.
- cataflam 6y agoProbably, the blog post itself is signed by Max Krohn, Keybase.io co-founder.
- Avamander 6y agoHelpful there, but gutted a really nice existing product. There isn't a viable alternative still and it makes me rather sad.
- anm89 6y agoThe cognitive dissonance here is amazing. How do you claim you are offering E2E as an upgrade on a product you have already claimed is E2E?
- neltnerb 6y agoI'm not sure it's still really cognitive dissonance when they admitted their error in marketing it that way, announced they were working on exactly this to provide what their claims said, and now they're saying it's done? Sounds like they got a sudden spike in interest, realized that their customers were angry, admitted the error, bought keybase, and provided what their customers asked them for.
- ignoramous 6y ago> error in marketing it that way... There's an ashtonishing lack of ethics in our industry. A marketing error here, a software bug there [1], a misleading opt-out here [2], a preinstalled malware there [3][4][5], a little violation of privacy of here [6][7], a little lack of respect there [8][9]... It's all happening all at once. We shouldn't be lapping it up. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24514433 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24514433 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22531087 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22531087 [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9072424 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9072424 [4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17145204 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17145204 [5] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3298205 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3298205 [6] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19031055 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19031055 [7] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23929044 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23929044 [8] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4936561 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4936561 [9] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14384187 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14384187
- stingraycharles 6y agoI hate to be that guy, but you can hardly blame them when there are hardly any consequences. I really hate what they’re doing, but the worst they get is a slap on the wrist.
- desilentio 6y agoIsn't the whole point of end-to-end encryption -- not to have to trust any third party -- undermined by secret source? If one does not trust Zoom not to snoop on content passing unencrypted through their servers, why should one trust them to provide true end-to-end encryption? And, if one does trust them to provide true end-to-end encryption, why might one not as well trust them not to snoop on unencrypted content?
- hunter2_ 6y agoI agree. But I suppose it does have a slight benefit that if you trust the individuals at Zoom who implemented the encryption, now you no longer need to also trust the individuals at Zoom who have access to network traffic and/or server-side code but not client application code. This slight benefit is fairly silly, because we have no reason to give greater credibility (regarding ethics) to one set over another. At least it's a smaller set, though.
- rsa25519 6y agoDidn't Zoom hire Keybase to do their encryption? > This slight benefit is fairly silly, because we have no reason to give greater credibility (regarding ethics) to one set over another. At least it's a smaller set, though. Well, before we had to trust simply that people with networking access were non-malicious. Now, we can simply trust that at least one of [crypto, network] people are non-malicious. That seems like an improvement to me.
- kelnos 6y agoFor me, hiring the Keybase team did not increase my trust in Zoom; it sadly lowered my opinion of the Keybase team (which had already taken a hit due to their integration of cryptocurrency into the Keybase platform).
- sonicggg 6y agoThey are not opening their source code, as far as I know, so who is auditing this supposed end-to-end encryption?
- kevincox 6y agoIt doesn't say if this works on the web client or not. I prefer to keep Zoom inside the sandbox of my web browser. However since they claim that it is only the key acquisition that is changing it seems likely that it will work.
- donpark 6y agoE2EE uses WebRTC Insertable Streams feature which is enabled by default on latest stable Chrome (v86) so web client support is at least possible now.
- nemonemo 6y ago> In a meeting with E2EE enabled, nobody except each participant – not even Zoom’s servers – has access to the encryption keys being used to encrypt the meeting. > Zoom’s end-to-end encryption (E2EE) offering will be available as a technical preview, which means we’re proactively soliciting feedback from users for the first 30 days. It is a commendable step forward, but I wonder what their concerns are about this feature with such a careful rollout schedule. The difference seems only about who generates/manages the key, so unless they were decrypting the packets in transit, they should not be concerned about this.
- donor20 6y agoThey made their entire business work because people could easily call into these conference calls - they have on click call ins in the invite. And before the whole meeting password stuff, it was really easy. So ease of use was priority. Existing solutions are out there for folks with high security needs (that are in some cases darn hard to use with bigger non tech groups). Your POTS phone call to a bridge is not e2e to all the other recipients. The phone system doesn't have support for E2E in many cases. And zoom still has people using phones to connect. Additionally, they have in the past done mixing and other things on the server for very large broadcast type events. Ie, instead of doing 10 streams to 4,000 people (40,000 streams) you do 10 streams, mix, then one stream to 4,000 people.
- nemonemo 6y agoSo there's trade-off between the security and the conference call quality, and this option weighs toward more security. That sounds great for customers in general. I'd wish they choose the E2E option to be the default for small meetings and non-E2E to be the default for larger meetings with some clear notification for attendees.
- dancemethis 6y agoAnd people will not only believe it, but defend it.
- newbie578 6y agoZoom continues to astound me. I am constantly dumbfounded when I see articles about Zoom breaking records, and even more shocked when I see their market valuation. A market cap of $129 billion (with a B) with annual revenues of 600 million? I feel like this is a crazy gone bad joke, how in the world do they expect to justify that kind of valuation? Can someone please explain what is their current business plan, and what is their future one? They don't have ad space to generate revenue, they don't have a viable subscription based model, they are not a real B2B product, and they are not going to keep adding users forever. This was once in a lifetime situation where a majority of people were using it, and they still weren't able to capitalize on them in a way of monetizing them. I feel like they hit their peak without reaping the milestones and achievements along the way (except getting out like a bandit from the stock market). Am I taking crazy pills or?
- russli1993 6y agoI think for us techy people, we image a future where people interact with each other virtually. Today in video calls, tomorrow will be in ever realistic virtual reality. Maybe at some point we will be so good at mimicking reality and also so good at creating new scenarios where it is not possible in reality. But after this experiencing this pandemic, staying home for more than half of the year, interacting people remotely, at least for me, I can't wait for the time to finally able to meet people face to face. Even though a lot of companies have offered forever working from home, I don't think I will take that offer. Its just feels so much better to talk to people, see people in person. Whether its the body language, people's emotions, or physical interactions, and the in the moment and immediateness of everything. I don't think computers, VR and AR will ever going to replace that experience. For zoom though, I think that they will continue to find ways to extract more revenue per users. I think what will increase in the future is more and more economy will be digital economy, and people will be more willing to pay for and do commerce in a virtual platform. And companies will find ever more commerce opportunities with digital technologies. So I think they will continue to increase their revenue.
- paxys 6y agoZoom has quarterly revenue of $600 million, not annual.
- mtgx 6y agoDo they also use confidential computing to ensure regular employees can't mess with the encryption? Anyways, if this is real and not other lie like when they first lied about E2EE in Zoom, then kudos to them for listening to their users and common sense. It's weird to see the "leader" reacting so much to user feedback, when companies like Google who are playing catch-up with Meet are just starting to give up on E2EE from Duo. Same with Skype, where Microsoft killed any chance of Skype using secure communications ever again (how else would they please the government with its secret data request orders?)
- spiznnx 6y agoThe ephemeral key is regenerated when a participant leaves right?
- dwighttk 6y agoCan I join an e2e conference through my browser or are they going to finally force me to download their crappy app?
- intricatedetail 6y agoYou can never trust that your connection is end to end encrypted unless you run encryption yourself. Someone who could come up with a way to asymetrically encrypt video before it goes to any app would certainly make a lot of money and probably put a target on his or hers back for upset governments as they will have no way to decrypt it (now they can ask provider for the tap, but if you encrypt yourself it won't work).
- Barrin92 6y ago>You can never trust that your connection is end to end encrypted unless you run encryption yourself I also can't trust that the meat I buy in the supermarket actually has in it what it says on the packaging technically speaking unless I slaughter a pig myself. Obviously this isn't a reasonable standard to treat anything by. When a company goes out of their way to actually sell you E2E encryption and the company actually is fairly known and thus liable I can at the very least assume, for practical purposes that they're not lying to me until proven otherwise because they're risking their entire reputation and probably a very costly legal battle. Do-it-yourself encryption isn't really realistic because it's not going to be used by ~99% of people.
- intricatedetail 6y agoThere is no incentive to put bad meat in your shopping basket, but there is huge incentive to acquire information.
- Barrin92 6y agoThere's plenty of incentive to skip quality somewhere in the supply chain, which is why we get these nasty scandals[1] on occasion. However virtually nobody concludes that it means you need to process your own meat, or check if someone diluted your booze at the store or whatever. Only when it comes to encryption or digital stuff people go full tinfoil [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_horse_meat_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_horse_meat_scandal
- mdavidn 6y ago
- gonational 6y agoDoes anybody know if this means that zoom will be using WebRTC for browser-based E2EE calls?
- TedShiller 6y agoDidn't they claim this before, when it was just fake end-to-end encryption? How do we know it's real this time?
- kamyarg 6y agoIIRC they even were marketing their usage of SSL as e2ee in their website for some time.
- Tepix 6y agoOne problem with closed source end-to-end encryption is the trust you have to put into the vendor. The encryption implementation may be excellent, but what's to stop them from adding a "upload private key" function for lawful interception, perhaps at a later time? It's the same issue with WhatsApp. I hear rumors that law enforcement can access WhatsApp messages so i guess there must be a backdoor like this.
- jbirer 6y agoZoom is not a solution. We need WebRTC based End-to-End encrypted solutions. I am a Node developer who is pondering on starting such a thing. Reply to me if you want to get involved.
- rimliu 6y agoThe good news: you will learn a lot. The bad news you will figure out yourself (as stated in the good news).