3 ms·
The problem is that what you are saying is false, and the links you provide don’t back up your assertion in the slightest. Perhaps some of these companies ‘joi
by zepto 6y ago
The problem is that what you are saying is false, and the links you provide don’t back up your assertion in the slightest.
Perhaps some of these companies ‘joined’ prism willingly, but Google and Apple both deny having done so.
The dates you quote are from slides indicating when prism started to acquire data from these companies. They have nothing to do with membership or joining.
Data was obtained from these companies without their particpation, and they have taken measures to harden their systems since this was made public, for example in Google’s case prism obtained data by intercepting their underground fiber optic cables. Data was previously sent unencrypted between data centers along these, but after the intrusion was discovered, Google moved to encrypting this traffic.
If you can find evidence that either of these companies willingly became members of prism, then please present it.
Otherwise, you are repeating false claims.
- fsflover 6y ago> Perhaps some of these companies ‘joined’ prism willingly, but Google and Apple both deny having done so. And you of course trust them.
- zepto 6y agoNo, but not trusting them doesn’t mean that I accept any old bullshit people want to say about them without supporting evidence.
- fsflover 6y agoPractically everything that Snowden leaked turned out to be true. I would not call that bullshit.
- zepto 6y agoI am not calling Snowden’s leaks bullshit either. Nothing Snowden leaked actually corroborates DocPangloss’s claims. Snowden showed that these orgs were compromised by prism, not that they willingly joined. That’s the point.
- fsflover 6y ago> Snowden showed that these orgs were compromised by prism, not that they willingly joined. Not true. Snowden showed that Apple and Google were "commercial partners" with PRISM: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_surveillance_disclosures_(2013%E2%80%93present)#Global_surveillance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_surveillance_disclosure....
- zepto 6y agoThat doesn’t mean they willingly joined PRISM, knew that they had joined, or knew what data the NSA was taking. As has been discussed elsewhere there are legitimate and legal reasons for them to cooperate with the NSA in certain ways. Those two words change nothing more than that there was a partnership of some kind. No evidence has ever been produced of these companies knowingly participating in the kind of bulk data collection that PRISM is asserted to be. I’m not claiming to be certain they didn’t participate. I am claiming that the evidence clearly doesn’t not support that claim yet.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ksk 6y agoI think you're correct in general (in terms of standards of evidence), but if we are to accept Google's claims at face value, then why would you not also accept the leaked emails as evidence of collaboration? Specifically, this[1] email exchange: NSA Director (Keith Alexander) to Google's CEO :- "It was good seeing you recently after the meeting earlier this month" "Google’s participation in refinement, engineering and deployment of the solutions will be essential." Make of that what you will.. [1] : https://www.huffpost.com/entry/nsa-google_n_5273437 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/nsa-google_n_5273437
- zepto 6y agoThey are evidence of some kind of collaboration. The problem is that evidence of collaboration doesn’t substantiate anything at all about participation in prism or any other illegal or underhanded scheme. We know that Google does have portals to service lawful government information requests. It’s also entirely possible that Google participated in some kind of analytics development based on their web indexing and nothing to do with private user data. Either of these would be at least plausible explanations for these comments as “they joined prism and handed over all data to the NSA”. Innuendo is not evidence.
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoYou are correct that parent is wrong (and horribly wrong, to the point of downright fabrication beyond anything Snowden has ever said), but actually you are also wrong. Under PRISM, data cannot be taken without participation. The simple reason for that is that “participation in PRISM” more or less means you respond to court orders. You are confusing it with other programs. The one you are referring to was reported as a joint operation with GCHQ called MUSCULAR. Google and Apple’s denials of PRISM participation are kind of semantic. One, they do not refer to it by any NSA codename, so they can truthfully say they don’t participate in something called PRISM, whatever PRISM supposedly is. Second, PRISM was incorrectly described as direct server access without approval. Both companies can truthfully claim that they do not participate in such a program, whether that program is PRISM or not. The truth is that they do “participate”, but that isn’t what PRISM actually enables. That’s the best denial they can give due to the nature of the gag order. From trumancenter.org: If the NSA’s descriptions are accurate, the NSA’s PRISM program allows them to seek electronic data on non-U.S. Persons under FISA warrants applied to foreign electronic traffic travelling through U.S. servers with filters and controls to prohibit use of data of U.S. Persons that may get caught up in the dragnet. The expressly prohibits the use of FISA warrants toward U.S. Persons, but it is not as clear as to what happens to data on U.S. Persons that get picked up in large dragnets aimed at non-U.S. Persons. Much of the accuracy of claims depend on the certified disclosures to Congress by the Attorney General that such safeguards exist and are in place. So, “participation” means you respond to FISA warrants, which isn’t optional.
- zepto 6y agoI’m not wrong. We know they respond to fisa warrants. Nobody claims otherwise. But - also know from Snowden we know that that PRISM is not just an aggregation of responses to fisa warrants. PRISM also involved intercepting Google’s bulk traffic from their fiber without Google’s knowledge, and various other kind of interception. If you equate PRISM with aggregating fisa warrants responses, then what you say is true. However it is not actually accurate to make that equation. And even if court ordered data was aggregated as part of PRISM, that doesn’t constitute ‘participating’ in PRISM in any by the most semantically stretched way, since they didn’t know about it. If you are going to argue like this, you may as well say that the end users ‘participated’ in prism, by giving their data to these companies. In a way that’s true. But it’s not true in the common understanding of what it means to participate.
- aborsy 6y agoBut the NSA doesn’t need willingness. If you operate in the United States, you must obey the US laws, among which are the espionage programs (claimed to be national security measures).
- zepto 6y agoSure, but that’s irrelevant. Not only do we not have evidence of willingness. We don’t have evidence they even knowingly participated, whether willing or not.