4 ms·

Funny, for me it would be the reverse. I recommend Lost, even without a strong ending. GoT I believe it’s not worth to anyone due to its horrible last season.

by soneca 6y ago

bryanrasmussen 6y ago
I think it depends on your personality, are you a person who likes things to hang together coherently and think that when a narrative implies something will be resolved it should be resolved (that is to say if you see Chekhov's gun, they keep talking about it, and it never goes off - do you get really upset?) well, if you're that kind of person you will be pissed off about Lost. You might also dislike GoT (can't say haven't seen, but I'm that kind of person and not going to risk it) If you feel characterization is the most important thing, and the emotional connection to characters or having highly evocative emotional moments in the narrative is what makes it worthwhile then you will probably like Lost quite a bit, but you might hate GoT (given my understanding that the last season fucked up major characters for shock value - I can't speak directly to it as I haven't watched it) So based on that my wife still talks about how great Lost was, and if it gets brought up the first words out of my mouth will not be complimentary.
ekianjo 6y ago
It's not just the last season which is weak in GOT, it's been weak for 2 seasons before already. If anyone did not notice they seriously need to go back and rewatch the first few seasons to compare.
- soneca 6y ago
  I agree. It was getting worse, but still an ok show in my opinion. The last season was just terrible. An awesome show becoming an ok show and then ending as a terrible show is not worth recommending for anyone. For me Lost, was a great show, with highs and lows, with fairly good last season, with a very disappointing and confusing last episode. Still worth the ride in my opinion.
  - ekianjo 6y ago
    I agree except on your comment on Lost. Lost was just smoke and mirrors all along, with absolutely no pay-off to the unlimited amount of questions they raised year after year. They really thought the audience had no memories at all.

Funny, for me it would be the reverse. I recommend Lost, even without a strong ending. GoT I believe it’s not worth to anyone due to its horrible last season.

by soneca 6y ago

Funny, for me it would be the reverse. I recommend Lost, even without a strong ending. GoT I believe it’s not worth to anyone due to its horrible last season.

bryanrasmussen 6y ago

I think it depends on your personality, are you a person who likes things to hang together coherently and think that when a narrative implies something will be resolved it should be resolved (that is to say if you see Chekhov's gun, they keep talking about it, and it never goes off - do you get really upset?) well, if you're that kind of person you will be pissed off about Lost. You might also dislike GoT (can't say haven't seen, but I'm that kind of person and not going to risk it) If you feel characterization is the most important thing, and the emotional connection to characters or having highly evocative emotional moments in the narrative is what makes it worthwhile then you will probably like Lost quite a bit, but you might hate GoT (given my understanding that the last season fucked up major characters for shock value - I can't speak directly to it as I haven't watched it) So based on that my wife still talks about how great Lost was, and if it gets brought up the first words out of my mouth will not be complimentary.

ekianjo 6y ago

It's not just the last season which is weak in GOT, it's been weak for 2 seasons before already. If anyone did not notice they seriously need to go back and rewatch the first few seasons to compare.

soneca 6y ago
I agree. It was getting worse, but still an ok show in my opinion. The last season was just terrible. An awesome show becoming an ok show and then ending as a terrible show is not worth recommending for anyone. For me Lost, was a great show, with highs and lows, with fairly good last season, with a very disappointing and confusing last episode. Still worth the ride in my opinion.
- ekianjo 6y ago
  I agree except on your comment on Lost. Lost was just smoke and mirrors all along, with absolutely no pay-off to the unlimited amount of questions they raised year after year. They really thought the audience had no memories at all.