3 ms·
> I don’t understand how engineers can read the actual text of the Question and think this is a good idea... Because engineers are generally capable of underst
by mindslight 6y ago
> I don’t understand how engineers can read the actual text of the Question and think this is a good idea...
Because engineers are generally capable of understanding that law is law, and not a computer program.
> Remember this is a legal requirement, not a spec
Yes, this is a basic principle of how laws are written. You've supplied the rebuttal to the rest of your comment. All the terms that you singled out and put scare quotes around are meant to be applied by the courts to ongoing industry practices - the point is to avoid needing future revision based on details. If the lack of specificity offends your engineer sensibilities, then you need to work on developing other modes of thinking.
- zaroth 6y agoIt's not a lack of specificity that I'm worried about - quite the opposite, I think this text is far too over-specified while managing to use fluff terms that are mostly meaningless. Meaning a court will have to somehow divine meaning from all those scare-quoted terms when the inevitable lawsuits commence.