3 ms·
Why anyone treats seriously argument "I don't know therefore 50-50"? If there are actually two possibilities and they are mutually exclusive one has exactly 10
by scotty79 6y ago
Why anyone treats seriously argument "I don't know therefore 50-50"?
If there are actually two possibilities and they are mutually exclusive one has exactly 100% chance of being true and the other has exactly 0%.
Knowing nothing doesn't let you just take the average.
Even if you picked one, you wouldn't have 50% probability of being right. You'd have 0% probability if you picked the wrong one.
Only if you picked one at random you'd have 50% probability of being right. You can see that the 50% comes from the process you used to pick the answer not from how the answer relates to reality.
Imagine you are tossing a coin to choose what you are going to believe in about whether we live in a simulation or not.
Before you toss a coin you have 50% of holding the correct belief. But after you tossed it you have either 100% probability that you hold correct belief or 0% depending on how coin toss aligned with reality.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoThe Bayesian view of probability is that the 50% comes from the information you have. If the only thing you know is that there are two mutually-exclusive possibilities, then you'll give both a 50% estimate of being true. The more you learn about the world, the more refined your estimate becomes. But it's important to remember that the "I don't know therefore 50-50" describes your state of mind, not reality.