3 ms·
I'll copy parts of my response to the dear Doctor when (initial draft of?) it was posted on Mastodon: 1: Propaganda is not (no longer?) limited to centralized
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
I'll copy parts of my response to the dear Doctor when (initial draft of?) it was posted on Mastodon:
1:
Propaganda is not (no longer?) limited to centralized control. Advertising is an example of fully decentralized propaganda, where the actors don't have any kind of real central control, but if their goals align, they'll amplify a single message to the level much larger than a monopoly ever could.
Perhaps we could call it mob-style propaganda. Mobaganda?
2:
The way I feel it, propaganda is about making a large group of people believe things that aren't true, but benefit some other group of people. Said beneficiaries of the propaganda may be the original source of the message - but even historically, propaganda only works if some of the audience believes it and starts convincing/socially pressuring others into believing it too.
So the core operational element here is just a meme that spreads. Centralization is orthogonal.
--
Basically, I feel that old school propaganda was just a way to forcefully spread a selected meme. It happened in an era where most media was unidirectional - from a small group of people operating newspapers, radio and television, to a large group of people who could only view it and perhaps comment between each other, but their response wasn't broadcast to a wide audience. These days, with our hyperconnected social media where everyone is a publisher of thoughts, memes can spread without much effort. You don't need force of a central power anymore for an idea to travel; memes amplify themselves now, as they spread through our bidirectional media.
And this means not only that propaganda isn't restricted to a central power, but also that it doesn't have to have any intent behind it. All it takes is for someone to accidentally craft a meme that resonates with people, and it'll get amplified. If it incidentally benefits a group of people, that group will ensure it gets amplified further.
The problem is, said meme doesn't have to be in any way correct, reasonable, or corresponding to observable reality.
- eeZah7Ux 6y ago> Advertising is an example of fully decentralized propaganda Not at all. Centralization is absolutely crucial to deliver advertising. Getting a bigger audience to attract larger advertisers is what pushed newspapers, radios, television channels and finally web services to become behemoths.
- Nasrudith 6y agoWhile there are certainly economies of scale that may allow others to do better anyone can engage in some sort of advertising, guerilla marketing is definetly a decentralized advertising tactic. If monopoly is defined solely in terms of dominance it is ironically possible for there to be a decentralized monopoly as technically anyone can enter by any means but there is one big fish in the pond. I dislike that definition of monopoly personally because a monopoly with no concrete barriers to entry feels like an absurd abuse of the term.
- dredmorbius 6y agoAnd from my response there: The distinction between macro- and micro-propaganda gets to a few elements: - Mass propaganda, let's call it Goebbellian propaganda, relies on targeting the same message to a very large audience. Often a Big Lie, but always simple, clear, and heavily repeated. - Targeted propaganda pits individuals (or identifiable, but small, market segments, against an extensive data store (past behaviours, activities, and behavioural models), and machine intelligence. The individual is pitted against trillion-dollar corporations or state actors, yottabyte-sized data stores, and predictive and AI behavioural models. With macropropaganda at least the message is publicly evident. With micropropaganda it may be impossible to determine what is or isn't manipulation as well as what manipulations are targeted as which individuals or groups. The targeting element of micropropaganda still pressumes some sort of targeting. To take an example, Cambridge Analytica would have been much less successful if it had to, say, pull data from 100s of individual ISPs' personal home pages, email and chat logs, and inconsistent data formats and standards. Facebook's one-stop shopping of users, activity logs, data standards, and integrated activity across a wide range of services and third-party site integration, created CA's opportunity. The messaging may not be centralised, but the enabling infrastructure must be. https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/105024594626128707 https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/105024594626128707 Adding to that: The observation that medium shapes messaging isn't new (see McLuhan), but is worthwhile. Network topology, scale, directedness, and other characteristics, drive and dictate possible interactions. It's not accidental that radio pioneers borrowed both the name and business model of farmers; broad-casting seeds into a fertile medium and harvesting the returns through bulk and undifferentiated mechanical processes. As I've noted elsewhere, the specific defining property of propaganda is intent serving a cause. Accidental memes are viral, but unless coopted, not themselves propagantistic. In Dawkins' conception, such memes selfishly serve only themselves.