4 ms·
Here's my rough impression of what we may expect to see if the collision happens. Note that the collision isn't going to be perfectly heads-on, and is statistic
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
Here's my rough impression of what we may expect to see if the collision happens. Note that the collision isn't going to be perfectly heads-on, and is statistically unlikely for the centers of mass to collide.
BEFORE:
^ /
| |
| o - CZ-4C R/B
| /
| |
| /
|/
|
*
/|
| |
/ |
/ o - COSMOS 2004
| |
/ |
v |
AFTER:
aaa^ /
aaaa |
aaaa |
aa /
b aa b b
bb b bb b b
ccc b b
ccccc b b
b ccccc b b
b b ccc
b b b b b
b a |
aa |
aaa |
aaa |
aaa |
Legend:
a - Shattered fragments of the parts of satellites that weren't involved in direct hypervelocity collision, but got torn off and spun. Essentially like a shotgun discharge, but in space. These will carry most of their original kinetic energy and follow close to their satellite's original trajectory, slowly spreading over time and becoming untrackable. These will stay around the longest.
b - Pieces that were close to or directly involved in the collision, retaining enough orbital velocity to stay in space. May be on highly eccentric orbits. Should decay faster than pieces labeled "a" (I think, I'm not sure).
c - Pieces that lost enough velocity to fall either straight down, or fly upwards and then fall straight down. These may cause some damage on their way down to ground, but should disappear quickly.
For reference, here are some (much prettier) diagrams of the 2009 collision, that happened at close to 90 degree angle: http://celestrak.com/events/collision/ http://celestrak.com/events/collision/.
- saagarjha 6y agoIt’s interesting to see how much debris remained confined to the original orbit-although it makes sense because any fragments that go sideways would need to happen to pick up a fairly high tangential velocity as a result of the collision. Not impossible, but fairly unlikely for any given part I’d guess.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIt's not easy to change the inclination. The best way to get a feel for what a tangential component would do is to boot up KSP and start playing with the maneuver node tool in-game. I can't find any equivalent tool on-line, but there are some animated GIFs here: https://t-neumann.github.io/space/OrbitalManeuvers/ https://t-neumann.github.io/space/OrbitalManeuvers/ Scroll down to "Normal and anti-normal maneuvers". Basically, adding sideways velocity will change inclination a little bit, but also make it more eccentric - as you're not cancelling your original velocity, so the speed along the new orbital direction is greater than it was for your current altitude.
- numpad0 6y agoNot easy for satellites but not necessarily hard for small fragments
- beervirus 6y agoAdding sideways velocity shouldn't change your eccentricity, because it doesn't change the kinetic or potential energy of the orbit.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoBut it does! Your orbit is defined by where your velocity vector is pointing at the moment. If you add a sideways component, you're a) increasing the magnitude, and b) rotating the vector.
- beervirus 6y agoNope, but I see now why we're disagreeing. It's because the animation you linked to is misleading. Work is the dot product of force and velocity. If the thrust is always orthogonal to the velocity, then the burn does no work on the rocket, and so it can't increase the magnitude of the velocity. In the animation you linked, it's plotting out what would happen if you continue to burn due north for some period of time as your velocity vector changes. But you wouldn't do that--if you're trying to change your inclination, you burn perpendicular to your velocity, and as the direction of velocity changes, the direction of the burn changes too, such that it's always orthogonal. It's easy to watch this happen in the game if you don't use the maneuver node, but just use SAS to burn in the normal direction. The direction of "normal" changes during the course of the burn, and (except for small errors), your apoapsis and periapsis stay constant.
- flexie 6y agoQuestion: This was posted half a day ago and was estimated to happen (or not) in less than 1.5 days from now. Now, or later today, when there is less time to the collision, can't they calculate with far more accuracy, whether the objects will collide?
- SethTro 6y agoOnly if one of the two objects has passed over one of their tracker stations (and they got a good scan of it)
- LoSboccacc 6y agoa 0.001% uncertainty in speed is about 7km uncertainty in position after a day
- flexie 6y agoThen how can they say 1-20% risk of collision?
- LoSboccacc 6y agoprob they can measure speed at a higher accuracy than one mm/s, also orbit have a relatively low inclination difference and objects have a size, so that the impact area is not a point but a larger ellipses of varying overlap between bodies.
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoAnyone else tired of seeing this windbag shit up comment sections with his kneejerk low IQ hot takes? Should someone with 76,000 karma even be allowed to post anymore? You’ve clearly overdone it by that point and it’s time to shut the fuck up and let others be heard. Look at all the other comments that are pushed down the page due to this guy’s terrible mess of a comment being here.
- shmageggy 6y agoIs this based on anything or just random musings and ascii-art?
- quelsolaar 6y agoDon't disparage ASCII art. The very internet you used to make this comment has most of its protocol's defined in ASCII art (See RFCs). Its the back-of-the-napkin of the engineers who created the internet age. ;-)
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIt's based on what happened in 2009 (pictures linked in the comment), some familiarity with orbital mechanics, as well as the rest of discussion in this thread. There are a bunch of subthreads here that show people have a hard time imagining how a head-on collision in space would play out; this is an attempt to put it in a more visual form.
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoNo, it’s based on you never shutting the fuck up.
- jcims 6y agoSimulation of collision from 2009, i think you're pretty spot on https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BiHY5dR5Jsg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BiHY5dR5Jsg