5 ms·
Author. I'm noodling on notions, and some recent commentary by Cory Doctorow sparked much of this, or rather, gave cause to expand a recent HN comment. This i
by dredmorbius 6y ago
Author.
I'm noodling on notions, and some recent commentary by Cory Doctorow sparked much of this, or rather, gave cause to expand a recent HN comment.
This is quite possibly wrong in parts or whole. Critiques welcomed.
Though it seems fairly clear that the ills dominating recent discussions of the Internet and media aren't merely incidental to monopoly but integral to it. And that monopoly itself is a control structure.
The question's been raised in discussion elsewhere about whether or not smaller / cloistered discussions might also give rise to propaganda. My thinking is "possibly, but likely to a lesser degree'.
See, e.g.,
https://rollenspiel.social/@ArneBab/105027882621910913 https://rollenspiel.social/@ArneBab/105027882621910913
And Rhysy's comment on the linked article, "I think diversity is necessary but not sufficient": https://joindiaspora.com/posts/7bfcf170eefc013863fa002590d8e506#794da060ef5f01388a1d005056264835 https://joindiaspora.com/posts/7bfcf170eefc013863fa002590d8e...
- clairity 6y agoi'd suggest some more fleshing out to be meaty and coherent enough to comment substantially. but a general critique would be that the term "monopoly control" seems constraining, when what you seem to be talking about more generally is centralization (vs. decentralization). the connection to the economic concept of monopoly (which, for that one commenter who will otherwise insist, is not one company crowding out all others in a market, but rather a company having effective control of a market regardless of relative size) seems tenuous at best. how is propaganda, censorship, and surveillance inherent properties of an entity controlling the friend social network market (i.e., facebook) rather than an inherent property of the centralization of social networks (for instance)?
- dredmorbius 6y agoCan you think of an example of monopoly which does not entail centralisation? For regulatory purposes in the US, "monopoly" does not match either your definition nor the one I was taught in my intermediate microeconomics coursework. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20625775 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20625775 Courts do not require a literal monopoly before applying rules for single firm conduct; that term is used as shorthand for a firm with significant and durable market power — that is, the long term ability to raise price or exclude competitors. That is how that term is used here: a "monopolist" is a firm with significant and durable market power. https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/single-firm-conduct/monopolization-defined https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-guidance/guide-a... Propaganda, censorsship, and surveillance are not the only concerns regarding monopoly. But within the media and communications domain, it seems that the problems and market-power structure are inherently linked. If there are any other points needing addressing I'd be happy to hear them.
- rmrfstar 6y agoIs it propaganda if I repeat propaganda that managed to convince me? Does propaganda depend on the subjective intent of the speaker? If not, then any information system with a few powerful broadcast nodes is indistinguishable from a propaganda machine. Hence monopoly == propaganda. I like [1],[2]. It is sometimes interesting to think about how systems look when edges have different meanings. [1] https://www.linuxjournal.com/files/linuxjournal.com/ufiles/imagecache/large-550px-centered/u1000009/12076f1.gif https://www.linuxjournal.com/files/linuxjournal.com/ufiles/i... [2] https://www.linuxjournal.com/content/new-mental-model-computers-and-networks https://www.linuxjournal.com/content/new-mental-model-comput...
- dredmorbius 6y agoPropaganda entails intent serving a cause. There are useful ... tools ...though other terms are often employed. https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/105028944477718237 https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/105028944477718237
- zaarn 6y agoPropaganda is not dependent on the speaker. If you look at historic propaganda of the german third reich, it's still propaganda, despite it possibly being a digital copy in a school book. Propaganda is information or media that is purposefully designed to mislead, misinform or misdirect the reader and/or cause them to spread it to more readers, willfully.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoNot all propaganda is misleading though; have a browse of https://www.reddit.com/r/PropagandaPosters/ https://www.reddit.com/r/PropagandaPosters/, you'll see anti-war/racism/capitalism posters, PSAs, etc. Your definition is too narrow (it's almost like it's propaganda against propaganda, very meta). The ones I've seen are often one political ideology being positioned against another.
- pritovido 6y ago>you'll see anti-war/racism/capitalism posters, PSAs, etc. Just because you like the misleading message, does not make it less misleading. Just because you are anti something that you consider bad, does not make you good, and more important than that, does not make you better than what you denounce. Hitler was anti-comunist and Stalin anti-fascism. They used the anti "something horrible" as an excuse to grab all power without supervision. I collect propaganda posters, and have lots of Russian communist ones. I study those. Communist has always been experts on propaganda and giving misleading messages.
- jancsika 6y ago> The question's been raised in discussion elsewhere about whether or not smaller / cloistered discussions might also give rise to propaganda. My thinking is "possibly, but likely to a lesser degree'. I'm convinced that if some developer had sought to replace svn by thinking directly in your terms-- i.e., how can I seek to decentralize this thing-- they would have ended up with a complicated mess of a system which would be even worse at handling issues of data integrity for the end user. I don't understand the fetish for decentralization. Why isn't the focus instead on finding the low hanging fruit of simple, centralized software which can be easily tested and quickly deployed to defend against the dark patterns we know are used to manipulate people online? With all the (duplicated) effort to build decentralized systems that necessarily rely on gold being found at the end of open research rainbows, we could instead already have a deep set of contingencies for, say, the impending milestone when Google finally defeats the ad blockers that keep HN in its cush little bubble.
- rmrfstar 6y agoI think most people agree with you. The problem is lock-in. I want to have some agility wrt the central nodes I use. Why cant you migrate your social graph off of Facebook, or route messages from your preferred node to someone who uses Facebook?
- paulryanrogers 6y agoBecause the money is in the network effect and service mobility undermines that
- Waterluvian 6y agoMaybe I’m saying obvious things among people smarter than me, but I think the best world we can aim for is a federated solution. The benefits of centralization and the benefits of openness and competition.
- dredmorbius 6y agoI don't understand the fetish for decentralization. I have a love-hate relationship with the centralisation-decentralisation debate. Much radical decentralisation advocacy seems to embody little more than wishful thinking. Centralisation affords efficiencies, but at a cost of resilience, as has been widely realised of late, and of power control, if my notions here are accurate. One possible resolution is to accept necessary, or inevitable, network control points / monopolies, but to ensure that control is shared, distributed, democratic, and/or principled. Public utlities, multiple stakeholders, public input, and the like. Capture, corruption, apathy, mismanagement, incentives alignment, and the like, remain risks.
- an_opabinia 6y agoIt would have been a lot more fun if capital M Monopoly as you wrote it actually meant the game Monopoly. Anyway all I can really offer is to flame and stress less, if there’s something exciting about economics and journalism to you just focus on that. Don’t shoehorn the wonky excitement into something sideways-adjacent to FAAMG companies.
- dredmorbius 6y agoWill you accept my humble offering of Thomas Forsythe's The Landlord's Game? https://landlordsgame.info https://landlordsgame.info
- an_opabinia 6y agoYes, because it's great.
- bo1024 6y agoFor me, your site gives > This website requires JavaScript to function properly. If you disabled JavaScript, please enable it and refresh this page. Please consider making your site accessible to people not using it? Javascript is a control structure and surveillance tool.
- dredmorbius 6y agoI'm aware. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22039943 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22039943 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22041243 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22041243
- ssivark 6y agoI agree with the core thesis, and have had multiple discussions/debates about the importance of decentralization for promoting robustness through diversity (avoiding monocultures). A common complaint against federated structures (whenever I’m involved in this debate) is the claim that it’s much harder to fight spam & malicious actors than centralized systems operating at scale (which can afford to devote resources to this problem). I find that claim quite unconvincing, and believe that the problem is manufactured by the existence of centralized systems. In decentralized systems, effects of malicious action (be it spam or misinformation of any kind) are localized and controlled — and cannot scale to have large impact (thus also providing some disincentives for malicious action).
- dredmorbius 6y agoThe abuse-countermeasures argument is fairly persuasive, but possibly not entirely so. Not the least because scale also seems to greatly amplify that problems themselves. Most forms of communications/informational abuse also seem to follow the propaganda / censorship / surveillance framework. Certainly spam, various forms of devoicing, and targeted harassment (bullying, brigading, doxxing, swatting). Countermeasures fall into what I term hygiene factors, and much of my current thinking runs very strongly along epidemiological lines (and did so well before our recent viral symbiote emerged): addressing breeding reservoirs, transmission vectors, surveillance (of dysfunctional/toxic behaviours), susceptibility, treatment, isolation, and the like. Distributed and decentralised approaches can work, and there are examples of these. From the world of spam: DNSBLs, SpamHaus, IronPort, pg's own Bayesian classifiers, and the like. How much added gain GD AI ML offers, and how much that relies of exclusive data monopolies, I'm not sure. One further point that's going to be lost here, but what the hell: it's not entirely necessary of even possible to dismantle all informational (or other) monopolies. My key point has been to join the three ills which seem to be the subject of much present discussion as having a common enabling factor. And that discussing the issues separately or without consideration of etiology has little value. Sometimes the answer will be dismantling sometimes it will be to modify governance, ensuring public, social, and or commonweal orientation; sometimes to create counterveilling power blocs to balance forces.
- dredmorbius 6y agoTim Wu beat me to the punch on the surveillance connection by at least 7 years: Why Monopolies Make Spying Easier (2013); https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/why-monopolies-make-spying-easier https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/why-mono... Well worth reading, similar logic, excellent examples.