3 ms·
It’s a double edged escape hatch. In practice the vast majority of voters know little to nothing about what’s being decided. On the other hand many third rail
by Retric 6y ago
It’s a double edged escape hatch. In practice the vast majority of voters know little to nothing about what’s being decided.
On the other hand many third rail political views have a great deal of popular support. So, IMO the trick is to require a very large number of signatures to get on the ballot.
- JoshTriplett 6y ago> It’s a double edged escape hatch. In practice the vast majority of voters know little to nothing about what’s being decided. Neither does the legislature, in many cases. On balance I'd rather have direct democracy for the majority of things. It has worked quite well in Oregon, which has an initiative system.
- hpkuarg 6y agoDirect democracy also leads to dumpster fires of a policy choice like Proposition 13 for your southern neighbors. No guarantees it wouldn't have passed through regular legislative channels, I suppose...
- JoshTriplett 6y agoGiven that it's also a third-rail for politicians to try to touch, it sounds like it worked precisely as it should, and gave people what they wanted and voted for. Oregon passed something similar, albeit weaker; I wish we'd passed something much stronger. Not because I'm anti-taxation, but because funding anything via property taxes is an incredibly bad idea and leads to funding and service quality that's correlated with property values.
- kazagistar 6y agoIf it were redistributive instead of local that wouldn't be a problem, and excluding primary lived in properties gets rid of any moral hazard.
- JoshTriplett 6y agoBoth of those would be a substantial improvement, yes. At that point, you'd just have an unusual, specialized wealth tax. If you're going to change property taxes that much, though, you might as well go all the way to a land-value tax, which would also reduce problems with assessment and improvement.
- ISL 6y agoAgreed. It is useful to pass things that a legislature may never pass, like term-limits for legislators. In Washington State, the initiatives frequently yield legislation that has conflicts/dependency problems with the existing law, something that happens far less-often with bills from within the legislature. Also agreed that a high signature-number bar is one of the simplest/expedient ways to limit ballot-initiative spam. We have a person who has successfully made it their personal mission/job/source-of-notoriety to place some sort of small-government initiative on the ballot every year.
- msds 6y agoAnd steal office chairs/break campaign finance laws, but I'm not sure if he does that for the notoriety or just can't help himself...
- kazagistar 6y agoYeah, on the ballot in our state is a law that supposedly prohibits the enforcement of local gun regulation, only allowing state regulation. Except its so poorly worded its unclear to judges and police and such what it even means.