3 ms·
The logical fallacy of "begging the question" is essentially "A because A" although the two propositions are usually worded in a way that obfuscates their ident
by jcranmer 6y ago
The logical fallacy of "begging the question" is essentially "A because A" although the two propositions are usually worded in a way that obfuscates their identity. For example "opium makes you sleep because it's soporific," where "soporific" is a fancy way of saying "makes you sleep."
In colloquial speech, the phrase "begging the question" is often not used to refer to the logical fallacy but rather the more literal translation of "makes you ask."
- thaumasiotes 6y agoIn that particular case, I think the traditional explanation is that opium makes you sleep because of its "dormitive virtue". https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/dormitive_virtue https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/dormitive_virtue
- hoseja 6y agoI still can't quite wrap my head around how the 'correct' meaning makes sense. Who is begging what? Why?
- srtjstjsj 6y agoThe prober is begging that the proposition (question) be granted for free, without a valid proof.
- ewzimm 6y agoIn the traditional relationship, the student is begging the teacher. In general, the person making an argument is begging you to accept their point instead of arguing it. The question is the point of contention. If we are arguing about Windows or Linux and I say that Linux is better designed because it has a clearly superior architecture, I'm begging the question because I'm just asking you to accept it instead of supporting my argument. Also, I wonder if the misunderstanding of the term has prompted many people to start looking into formal logic. In our linked world, I could imagine people looking something like that up after they hear it's misused and finding information about a lot of related issues around logic.
- hoseja 6y agoThanks, what convoluted logic.