4 ms·
An alternative telling: Allende's form of socialism was distinct from the centrally planned soviet style economy, focusing on responding to problems and creati
by monocasa 6y ago
An alternative telling:
Allende's form of socialism was distinct from the centrally planned soviet style economy, focusing on responding to problems and creating high level economic goals, but otherwise focusing on a self organizing, bottom up, worker led economy extremely distinct from the Soviet system.
This idea started actually working, and the United States fearing, in the CIA's own words, "a successful socialist experiment" tried everything they could to remove Allende and push the country away from socialism. They even looked at the idea of invading the country, but couldn't because of the public opinion of how poorly Vietnam was going. The most successful intervention was, in the United States government's own words again, "making the economy scream". However despite this Allende still kept being elected clearly in elections that no one has disputed the validity of.
So enough being enough, the US government backed one of the most brutal dictators ever, Pinochet, to illegitimately take over the government, killing Allende in cold blood and beginning a reign of terror. Theyd do stuff like rape your wife and children to death in front of you, so that when they took you out to sea on a "helicopter ride" to dump you at sea still alive, you welcomed death. We as the United States trained his staff in torture in the School of the Americas at Fort Benning, and provided an immense amount of funding. Over 10,000 people were killed.
To rebuild the economy after the intervention, they brought in the Chicago Boys, a set of Chicago school economists, to "unleash the economy" from the socialist practices of Allende, but it didn't really work. Chile's growth trailed the rest of South America's until those practices were rolled back.
And even now the scars of all this still exist in Chile, with the massive protests that have been going on for over a year focusing on demands to replace the terrible Pinochet era constitution, and state security forces openly killing protestors.
- AndrewBissell 6y agoHere's the point where the frame of the discussion is shifted from "Chilean socialism was bad" to "well both sides are morally inscrutable." A "fun" excerpt from the School of the Americas training manual: https://twitter.com/LLinecook/status/1314164836427857921 https://twitter.com/LLinecook/status/1314164836427857921
- blueline 6y ago> killing Allende in cold blood people unfamiliar with the story might find it interesting that the exact manner of his death is somewhat disputed. obviously he wouldn't have died then if it weren't for the coup, so it's not like what you wrote is really a stretch. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Salvador_Allende https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Salvador_Allende
- monocasa 6y agoWell, the Pinochet government's own internal documentation found that it was an assassination. http://archive.boston.com/news/science/articles/2011/05/31/chile_tv_secret_report_suggests_allende_murdered/ http://archive.boston.com/news/science/articles/2011/05/31/c...
- drran 6y agoNope. It says that he was shot with AK into the head after his death. It doesn't look like assassination.
- monocasa 6y ago> citing a reference in the initial military autopsy to a small bullet hole in the back of Allende's skull that he alleges is inconsistent with an AK-47 fired from below the chin through the top of his head.
- young_unixer 6y agoYou're not mentioning the fact that Allende's government did not respect the laws and was declared unconstitutional by congress[1]. [1] https://obtienearchivo.bcn.cl/obtienearchivo?id=documentos/10221.1/13377/1/mj_00061.pdf https://obtienearchivo.bcn.cl/obtienearchivo?id=documentos/1...
- monocasa 6y agoHis political opponents sent him a letter telling him his acts were unlawful, yes. The Chilean Supreme Court who would be the body who could issue such a declaration with any legal standing did not.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoNo, it was the congress by a substantial majority vote, not just "his political opponents". They also sent a letter to the armed forces so they enforce the constitution.
- monocasa 6y agoBut once again, they weren't the legal body capable of making such a determination. Also, going to throw out there that the ones screaming about how unconstitutional Allende's actions simply wholesale replaced the constitution as Pinochet took power.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoI much rather prefer the events of our current timeline than a continuation of Allende's happy soviet time drunkocracy that would have meant war against neighbors and potentially a superpower. The death of millions not only 3,000. Allende believed in an armed revolution and his house had a large stash of Soviet-made weapons. He destabilized the country because he wanted his revolution at any cost. And there was a revolution, just of another flavor that he didn't like.
- 6y ago
- flobosg 6y agoA referendum determining whether said constitution will be changed is taking place in a few weeks.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoMost brutal dictators ever? that is a very egregious mischaracterization. Not because Pinochet was not brutal, of course he was... he killed 3,000 people in brutal ways for 17 years. Sure... But add 2 zeroes to that death count and multiply the regime length by 3 and you get Fidel Castro. The Chilean armed forces (navy, army, air force, police) intervened when they saw an imminent civil war, combined with a likely Argentinean invasion. That would be effectively the end of Chile. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beagle_conflict https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beagle_conflict https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Soberanía https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Soberanía And Allende's regime was very far from suceeding. He had inspiring speeches but in practice he was a failure as a leader. Allende was a demagogue on the KGB's payroll with drinking issues, his administration was undistinguishable from anarchy.
- monocasa 6y agoI'm sorry, but under what calculus did Castro's government kill 300,000 people? Not even the extremely biased "victims of communism" calculus comes within orders of magnitude of that. And the Chilean military would have been part of that civil war. "There would have been a civil war because we would have attempted to overthrow the democratically elected government and they would have fought back, so we took american money and 'advisors' to move so quickly that there was no chance of the legitimate government fighting back" doesn't really hold moral water with me. Also, the Beagle Conflict was five years into Pinochet's reign so not really sure how that's a reason to overthrow Allende. > Allende was a demagogue on the KGB's payroll with drinking issues The KGB hated the shit out of Allende. Their bottom up socialism stood to be an alternative that would have taken away the KGB's legitimacy even with die hard communists at the time.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoNope. The Beagle conflict had already begun decades earlier and there was an unsuccessful arbritration with the help of the UK in 1971, during Allende's presidency. If Chile had a civil war, that would have accelerated Argentina's invasion plan. In addition to that, Bolivia has manifested territorial ambitions over their former territories, something that is even in their constitution. A civil war followed by an invasion by at least 2 countries, or a Cuba/Chile/Soviet union alliance were all excellent reasons to remove Allende. He failed, his ideas were bad, his execution was bad. Beautiful speeches, but a failure nevertheless. Next time some Mr. Che Guevara t-shirt guy tries to sell you the Communist miracle, go to Cuba and see how they live there, and tell me if you would like to raise your kids in a place like that. Or go to Venezuela, another "miracle". Technically they have equality because most people (except for the regime and party members of course) are equally poor. Fidel was such as charismatic leader he would only eat food from his own personal garden out of fear of being poisoned, he also lived a life of excess and lived in an oppulent mansion unlike most Cubans.
- hoistbypetard 6y ago> We as the United States trained his staff in torture in the School of the Americas at Fort Benning While the School of the Americas would eventually move to Fort Benning, it was in Panama (in the US controlled canal zone) when this was happening. I don't think it was moved to Columbus until some time in the mid-1980s, about a decade after Pinochet's rise to power.