3 ms·
I see the House as a faster-changing, populous body (which is generally a good thing) and the Senate as a much slower-changing balance against the worst of what
by sokoloff 6y ago
I see the House as a faster-changing, populous body (which is generally a good thing) and the Senate as a much slower-changing balance against the worst of what a fast-changing, populous body could wreak on the country.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoOk, so why not a bicameral system where the Senate also has proportional representation while keeping 6 year terms? There wouldn't have to be a 1:1 ratio of senators to representatives. Maybe there would be something like 1 senator/2 representatives? Or, if we kept the same 2 senators/state maybe we split high population states into smaller states so that we don't have huge gap between number or residents/senator? Personally, I think we should probably move in the unicameral direction. I don't think that "fast-changing" adaptability is a negative in this modern world.
- sokoloff 6y agoUnicameral systems seem to prevent beneficial compromises. I’d personally hate to see the country gyrate between policy extremes as the composition of that singular body changed. Even when going extremely “my way”, as an engineer I’d hate it. I find a lot of people spend time thinking “how much more progress could we make if we didn’t have to compromise with those assholes?” Far fewer think “how much more damage could those assholes do if they didn’t have to compromise with us?”