4 ms·
The AGPL was a good defensive extension of the GPL, but the landscape has shifted and it's falling behind. We need an AGPL++. AGPL tries to target hosted servi
by echelon 6y ago
The AGPL was a good defensive extension of the GPL, but the landscape has shifted and it's falling behind. We need an AGPL++.
AGPL tries to target hosted services, preventing cloud companies from taking open source components without contributing anything back.
But you know what the AGPL misses? Our data.
We need open source licenses that require the systems that make use of them to provide data export and the right to be forgotten. We should encode the GDPR into our licenses. This would prevent Facebook from taking open source and using it to lock away our data.
We should also fight back against embrace, extend, extinguish. Apple is trying to take over computing and prevent us from running our own software on our own devices. We should prevent them and anyone else trying to do this from using our software.
No right to compute on your platform? Fine. No rights to open source software.
We have to defend computing and open source, otherwise we'll all wind up using thin clients to access walled silos. And we'll be renting the access, too.
- chaosite 6y agoI agree with you that this is a problem, but I don't see how you can fix that with licensing. I mean, I guess you can add a clause that says "you can't use this software if you do things that the author doesn't like with it", but the point of the FSF software licenses is that they don't limit what you do with the software in any way, just how you can distribute the software itself. This is like trying to stop child porn using the license for encryption software.
- BuildTheRobots 6y agoThe GPL is all about protecting user freedoms. AGPL extended this to not just count for devices in your possession but to systems you remotely interact with. Adding a clause that says you must allow users their own data as well as a copy of the source code doesn't seem like a completely out there extension of those protections.
- chaosite 6y agoThe GPL is all about protecting a users freedom to use their software in any way they'd like, and correctly notes that users require access to source code in order to do that. Quoting verbatim from the preamble, "the GNU General Public License is intended to guarantee your freedom to share and change all versions of a program--to make sure it remains free software for all its users." It doesn't really discuss other sorts of freedom. I'd also note that RMS is famed for having (and sharing) many opinions, many of them specifically on the sorts of freedom we're discussing now, yet no such language has ever appeared in the FSF's licenses.
- BuildTheRobots 6y ago> The GPL is all about protecting a users freedom to use their software in any way they'd like, and correctly notes that users require access to source code in order to do that. I'm still tempted to argue that if I want to run the software in whatever way I like - in this case mimicking someone else's production system, then I'm going to need access to both the source code as well as _my_ user-data so I can use the software to host my own user data.
- m463 6y agoBut you know what the AGPL misses? Our data. But if you care about your data the AGPL gives you the ability to run the software and keep your own data.
- ryukafalz 6y ago>We should also fight back against embrace, extend, extinguish. Apple is trying to take over computing and prevent us from running our own software on our own devices. We should prevent them and anyone else trying to do this from using our software. This is precisely what GPLv3 is for. If you distribute a GPLv3 program, its users must be able to modify it and run their modified versions. I'd imagine this is why Apple is allergic to GPLv3, but you know what... that's fine, I wouldn't want them to distribute software I write if its users aren't going to be allowed to change that. The issue so far is there's not enough GPLv3 software out there for them to care. If more people use it, that could change!