5 ms·
What really interests me is that, looking at an all-cause mortality graph [0] the coronavirus is clearly detectable but ultimately the numbers are pretty much b
by roenxi 6y ago
What really interests me is that, looking at an all-cause mortality graph [0] the coronavirus is clearly detectable but ultimately the numbers are pretty much business as usual. Although there are more deaths than is routine, going purely by deaths the situation is mostly normal.
It'll be fun when the dust settles to going back to look at alternative approaches to estimate how effective the lockdowns were.
[0] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm - "Weekly number of deaths (from all causes)"
- fuckyah 6y agoLockdowns cause 26% excess deaths. Influenza vaccine only adverts 16% of deaths... do you see what’s going on?
- HatchedLake721 6y agoAren’t the numbers “business as usual” because of the actions governments took worldwide? I’m not sure about others, but Italy peaked to extreme when there were not enough beds and ventilators in some places, which is what every country is trying to avoid.
- arethuza 6y agoThey are definitely noticeable in the UK graphs: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthandsocialcare/conditionsanddiseases/articles/coronaviruscovid19in10charts/2020-09-24 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthan...
- cheschire 6y agoThe peak period of 35.6 - 40.4 percent excess is not "business as usual". Even the September 19 period which looks relatively low shows a 4.2 to 8 percent excess.
- luu 6y ago> the numbers are pretty much business as usual . . . going purely by deaths the situation is mostly normal The article notes that, through July 25, there were 235,610 excess U.S. deaths. The link you gave shows that excess deaths started March 28th, for a period of ~119 days. Wikipedia says that the U.S. had 291,557 combat deaths during WWII, which was over a ~1366 day period of U.S. combat involvement if we count the period from Pearl Harbor until the end of the war. The U.S. is about 2.46 more populous now, so adjusting for that, the ratio of the rate of excess death over the period studied vs. U.S. combat deaths in WWII is (235610 / (119 * 2.46)) / (291557 / 1366) = 3.77. Since you're calling 3.77x the population-adjusted rate of WWII combat deaths "mostly normal", I would be curious to know what rate of death you would consider abnormal. On a non-population-adjusted basis, which is arguably the correct measure if we want to think about waging a war that's the equivalent of WWII, the death rate over the period studied would've been equivalent to the U.S. combat deaths from waging 9.28 simultaneous WWIIs. Personally, I wouldn't consider simultaneously engaging in nine wars the size of WWII to be business as usual.
- zdkl 6y agoIs WW2 generally perceived in america as having caused many deaths among american military aged males? I'm sure we can point to D-day and other punctual events as being outstandingly bloody but does this extend to the whole conflict? I'd be particularily interested in comparing the above ratio for Vietnam, or to German or Russian (combat & non-) WW2 deaths.
- KMag 6y agoHaving grown up in the US in the 1980s and 1990s, the American Revolution and WWII both loom large in the mythology of American exceptionalism, so I think the sacrifices of the soldiers weigh psychologically disproportionately. I think most college-educated Americans are aware that the Soviets lost nearly endless waves of soldiers against the Nazis. I also think most Americans are largely indifferent to the numbers of German rank-and-file soldiers killed, as if sympathy for the enemy dead would somehow diminish admiration for the heroes who defeated the Nazis. On a side note, I have a Scottish friend who still swears up and down that Americans weren't involved in D-Day. I tried pointing him at Wikipedia entries for Utah and Omaha beaches, but I get the impression he believes it's just American propaganda that the US had much involvement in WWII before the Nazis were on the retreat.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> I also think most Americans are largely indifferent to the numbers of German rank-and-file soldiers killed No, we were gleeful at killing the enemy, whether German or Japanese. They declared war on us, disrupted our lives, and planned to kill us. Their lack of 4-engine bombers is the only reason New York wasn't bombed. Regarding US involvement, we financed and armed both Britain and Russia, as well as China. And occupied all of the Axis countries. Your Scottish friend is just participating in modern European historical revisionism due to current political correctness and collective shame, exhibited by allowing the self-loathing migrant invasion.
- rimliu 6y agoAnd what happens if you repeat these calculations over different period? There is a "harvesting" theory which claims that COVID causes some deaths to happen sooner. So it is a possiblity that there were many more deaths in April 2020, compared to Aprild 2019, but there will be way fewer in April 2021. Somewhat similar "dry tinder" theory is sometime applied to Sweden: they had fewer excess deaths during the flu season for a last couple of years and got hit hard by COVID claiming lives spared by the flu.
- pcrh 6y ago>pretty much business as usual. Not only is it not actually business as usual, as other commenters remark, but this rate of death is despite the severe measures taken. Without such measures, deaths would have been 10-20 times higher.
- wk_end 6y ago> Without such measures, deaths would have been 10-20 times higher. Is that based on anything? I’m skeptical - many places that took more severe measures did worse than places that took less severe measures (both within the US and internationally), and nowhere ended up with death rates per capita an order of magnitude larger than what we’re seeing in the US.
- withinboredom 6y agoI have a hunch (based on family and friends in the US) that the US is the only country that the population did its best to not take the measures seriously. Here in the Netherlands masks aren’t required in stores, but people still wear them anyway. Same with Sweden and France when I visited there over the summer. (Though France does require it in stores IIRC).
- cr1895 6y ago>Here in the Netherlands masks aren’t required in stores, but people still wear them anyway. I really disagree with your observations based on living in NL and visiting Sweden several times over the last few months. These are two very poor examples of countries where mask-wearing is prioritized and accepted. The Dutch government only a week or two ago "urgently advised" wearing masks indoors, and even with that advice in my own experience a majority of people are not wearing one. Before that, hardly anyone wore a mask indoors. I've traveled to Antwerp a few times for work in the past few months, and the prevalence of masks there compared to NL is striking. And Sweden generally has been quite averse to wearing masks in public...it's not ever been mandated anywhere, not even on transit like in NL. https://www.thelocal.se/20200831/sweden-remains-an-outlier-despite-nordic-u-turn-on-face-masks https://www.thelocal.se/20200831/sweden-remains-an-outlier-d...