7 ms·
I fucking hate the modern Internet. Everybody takes and nobody gives. We've regressed from the 90's/00's. These platforms only care about lock-in. Spotify does
by echelon 6y ago
I fucking hate the modern Internet. Everybody takes and nobody gives. We've regressed from the 90's/00's.
These platforms only care about lock-in. Spotify doesn't really add anything. The only convenience over Winamp is social sharing.
All of the platforms are catered to mass audiences anyway and suck for power users. They only want to extract money and are doing it the easiest way possible. Customers that don't complain about lack of features.
I posit that nobody in any of these orgs deeply cares about music.
- evan_ 6y agoThe other convenience Spotify over Winamp is that you don’t have to find and download MP3s, you can just type something in and 99% of the time just start playing it immediately...
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoNot to mention their recommendations which I find to be quite decent.
- edogg 6y agoNapster was pretty close to that
- ngokevin 6y agoAnd phones don't have Winamp...what is OP expecting people to do, download MP3s on Napster and sync it with iTunes?
- Rebelgecko 6y agoEven though it was taken down from the store, you can still sideload a Winamp apk if you really want to
- samplatt 6y agoThere's also PowerAmp which (iirc?) was a fork from the apk. It's not perfect, but it's better than most players.
- austhrow743 6y agoI think there's very few people who would fit in to the internet speed range of "capable of streaming music consistently enough to prefer that over downloading" and "downloads slowly". Finding and downloading mp3's isn't a problem.
- stnmtn 6y agoIf my friend tells me to check out a song or an album, I type in the first word or two of that song or album into spotify and I'm listening to it instantly, whether I'm on my phone or my computer. Do you really think there's no difference there? If you get a text from a friend saying check out this song and you're out and about on your phone, are you really saying that somehow downloading an mp3 to your phone is as easy as spotify?
- matheusmoreira 6y agoI am absolutely sure that searching and downloading/streaming music would be a standard feature of every music player out there were it not for copyright. Spotify's real innovation is not music streaming. That technology is not new in any way. The real innovation is the fact it somehow obtained the licenses necessary to legally stream the music people wanted to listen to.
- evan_ 6y agoWhich is why the criticism that they “don’t care about music” is so silly- that’s not the thing you make money by caring about. They cared about legal stuff.
- dehrmann 6y agoIt's more than just that. Maintaining your personal catalog of <10,000 songs is halfway doable, but it gets pretty hard after that. Spotify does all that for you and even handles things like making sure "ke$ha" and "kesha" both return the same results.
- hazz99 6y ago> The only convenience over Winamp is social sharing. Spotify also lets you stream any kind of music, anywhere. It's a nifty feature that some people find useful.
- ngokevin 6y agoAnd Netflix has nothing over VLC!
- zxcb1 6y agoIt depends on who you are and your habits.
- samtheprogram 6y agoIf you never watch or listen to content you don’t want to buy outright or pirate, sure, VLC has nothing over Netflix or, say, YouTube. Especially if you prefer ad-hoc discovery! Seriously, arguing over these analogies is like arguing between buying books and a for-profit (albeit digital) library. It says more about the comment that brought up the comparison (in the way that it did, as if they are mutually exclusive) than it does about the two services. Like you said, it depends on your habits, but there’s no point in arguing, or denying, that Netflix or Spotify do not offer anything more than VLC or WinAmp respectively. What no one has mentioned is that VLC and WinAmp offer features that the others lack. Somewhere in those features is an argument against vendor lock-in, but that trade-off of features is exactly what revolutionized how most users consume content by default, so I don’t think it’s a very good one. I recently started buying music again for a few different reasons, but I’ll be damned if I lose the discoverability in Spotify.
- zxcb1 6y agoYes, freedom of choice is what everyone wants.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fossuser 6y agoI have my hopes on Urbit, they’ve been quietly making progress and the potential seems huge. It’s already decent for chat. I think it could be a way out of the server/client model that could actually work.
- acwan93 6y ago> I posit that nobody in any of these orgs deeply cares about music. Or fitness, or messaging, or movies, or TV shows... Every platform nowadays is a way to lock you in. Strava makes exporting data exceptionally difficult and has API rate-limits. I’m sure there’s a technical reason, but still sucks. One of the tech journalists I follow has advocated the need for legislation for data portability to avoid shenanigans like Spotify has. Much like the phone number portability in the mid-2000s or interoperability after Ma-Bell AT&T was broken up, it sometimes takes legislation to enforce an open Internet. I think GDPR was one of the first steps towards that.
- RandallBrown 6y agoI don't know when the last time you checked was, but downloading your data from Strava is very easy. https://support.strava.com/hc/en-us/articles/216918437-Exporting-your-Data-and-Bulk-Export#Bulk https://support.strava.com/hc/en-us/articles/216918437-Expor... I just downloaded all my data and it only took about 5 minutes for them to send me the link. (I have about a year of data.)
- acwan93 6y agoOh nice! I haven’t tried to in a while, and have only seen it recently with services that connect to Strava.
- brownbat 6y agoI had a college radio show when Pandora was starting, and had shockingly responsive conversations with Tim W. about up and coming artists he should include. It was a brief window. Now their catalogue is so full I doubt anyone could add too much value like that. He sent me a tshirt, which was kind, but what I remember more is how he responded to recommendations. He's a musician and it was obvious he cared deeply about music. To that point of unhealthy obsession that drives some of us to work at record stores and host radio shows, and others to commit to building a transformative service that helps everyone discover new artists they might like. You can't help but recognize it if you have it. You might have a different opinion on the economics of it all, or wish the industry could go a different direction. But if you really talk to these people, there's no doubt they do what they do because they love music.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"All of the platforms are catered to mass audiences anyway and suck for power users." They are catered to investors. The "mass audience" is just a selling point. Neither investors nor the web/mobile "entrepreneurs" care whether the "audience" is complaining or not, they just care whether the audience is captured. If the audience cannot "leave", if it is made excessively difficult to do so, if there's no other viable alternatives, that's a positive in the eyes of the investor and hence a first priority of every web/mobile "entrepreneur". <s> Why not support these generous "entrepreneurs". They give away so much "for free". Accept all advertising and tracking. </s>
- longerthoughts 6y ago> I posit that nobody in any of these orgs deeply cares about music. I know people who work for “these orgs” and most (albeit not all) deeply care about music. Some were previously full-time musicians. Many make music as a passion/hobby but never pursued it professionally. Some are ashamed of or uncertain about the impact they’re having on music and the industry. Some seem to genuinely believe they’re helping push music forward. None of them are perfect stewards for music or the music industry, but none are the cold, greedy caricatures you’re imagining. I can only speak for the people I’ve met and they may not be representative, but the bar you set was “nobody” and it’s just not that simple.
- nmfisher 6y agoThat may be true, but every musician/smaller label I come across is saying that Spotify is killing independent music. The economics of streaming mean that the long-tail just isn't commercially viable. People no longer buy music outright, so that leaves practically no way to make money selling music. If you deeply care about music, how can you work for an organization that, according to all musicians, is destroying music?
- Semaphor 6y ago> People no longer buy music outright Bandcamp [0] seems to be doing alright and according to Wikipedia [1] is (barely) in the Alexa top 1000. Not sure how it is for other Genres, but for metal almost every not-big band I find out about is on Bandcamp. [0]: https://bandcamp.com/ https://bandcamp.com/ [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bandcamp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bandcamp
- cageface 6y agoI try to buy a copy of records I really like off Bandcamp but if you look at the supporters list for even fairly popular albums it's pretty short. Do musicians make enough money off sales on Bandcamp to make a difference? I can't imagine anybody could earn a living at those volumes.
- fractionalhare 6y agoThe beauty of this comment is that it's probably serious, but it also perfectly satirizes HN's nostalgia for the 90s internet and software. We started with Spotify pulling a douchey anticompetitive move, and ended up at > Spotify doesn't really add anything. The only convenience over Winamp is social sharing. Somewhere along the way we've gotten lost. The only convenience of Spotify over Winamp is "social sharing"? Am I taking the bait here or do you actually believe this? How can you believe this? What about the convenience of being able to play a massive amount of music without having to download and store it on your device? What about facilitating new music discovery? How did you come up with social sharing of all things as the honorable mention Spotify has over Winamp, when the latter is desktop software that requires you to manage all your music on your own? I can understand if you don't personally value Spotify because you like owning media with no restrictions. But I can't understand being in denial about inarguable, significant conveniences offered by the platform.
- silexia 6y agoThank you, I was shocked by OP saying the only difference between Winamp and Spotify was social sharing...
- hacknat 6y agoAlso, everyone has anxiety and/or depression right now. I’m trying my best to take everything everyone is saying with a grain of salt. Everyone appears to be having a hard time right now.
- Integrity 6y agoSometimes conveniences ruin things. I've heard it said "Having everything feels a lot like having nothing at all." The comparison of how we used to do things, to how we do them now are often just a marketing tactic, because old and new are relative regarding value. E.g., an old violin is better. What's lacking with the new internet is about this and that, or lack of options. So the entirety of the culture is flavored by an oligopoly in their respective market.And Spotify is missing loads of music. Music needs to change its perspective to a this and that view. Is "this" what you want over "that"? How old or new something is, is irrelevant. No musician that I know, and I know lots as a lifelong musician, is enthusiastic about Spotify. Most of us feel we just have no choice. Same with Facebook etc. Most people don't even like it.
- aksjfnkajsnd 6y ago> Spotify doesn't really add anything. The only convenience over Winamp is social sharing. Did Winamp let you stream (almost) any song you wanted?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kubav 6y agoWinamp has way better user experience so if you do not need social features it is huge let down. Spotify app UX is so terrible. It is super hard to open play queue. Play queue is being filled with random stuff and there is no way to clear it. The only use case which works is random play of whatever spotify wants you to listen.
- danielheath 6y agoI loved Winamp for many reasons, but the multi-device sync is really not there. The spotify handoff is rarely seamless but it usually works well enough.
- cpach 6y ago“Play queue is being filled with random stuff and there is no way to clear it.” Uhm, no. Could it be that you’re using the free version of Spotify…?
- dehrmann 6y ago> Play queue is being filled with random stuff and there is no way to clear it. You're probably thinking of autoplay. It's the last option in "settings" on the desktop app.
- throwawaysea 6y agoWinamp had much better skins than Spotify, and great visualizations (which seem to have disappeared as a feature in the modern audio world). But Spotify does make it convenient to have a portable library that doesn't need backing up. I hate the lock in (unable to export playlists), I hate the inflexibility of their apps, and I hate that they can exercise both financial and editorial control over music and podcasts. Things are going in a direction where I'll ultimately miss Winamp and the 'old days of Internet freedom'. But the problem is that right now, Spotify is convenient-enough that we will continue the march away from the free Internet. We will keep marching until we hate Spotify, but there's little to stop us along the way until it is too late.
- tsimionescu 6y agoIt's probably much better if you think of Spotify as an evolution of music radio, not as an evolution of a music library. Compared to traditional music radio, it is more expensive, but vastly more tailored to your own personal tastes (try finding an actual radio station playing prog rock one album at a time...).
- dehrmann 6y ago> Winamp had much better skins than Spotify, and great visualizations I admit I loved both of those things in 1999, but the novelty wore off. Outside of phone cases and laptop stickers, it looks like most people are over skins.
- leto_ii 6y ago> They only want to extract money and are doing it the easiest way possible. What you actually hate, I suspect, is neo-liberal capitalism, not so much the internet itself. As only the latest in a series of public resources to be surreptitiously privatized, the rules of the internet have started being dictated by investor interests. For the record, I don't like neo-liberal capitalism much myself, but I just thought it was important to correctly identify the fundamental problem here.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]