3 ms·
The line is much less arbitrary when you make it “speech that clearly violates criminal law” versus “speech that I disagree with”. When the govt starts talking
by refurb 6y ago
The line is much less arbitrary when you make it “speech that clearly violates criminal law” versus “speech that I disagree with”.
When the govt starts talking about “speech to foments discord” that’s a hell of a slippery slope.
- UncleMeat 6y agoBut "violates criminal law" is a statement about the population's beliefs. We pick what is illegal. It isn't some fundamental thing. In Germany, for example, holocaust denial is literally illegal.
- refurb 6y agoRight, but the criminal law falls outside of purely speech. That's the line drawn at least in the US - you can say whatever you want, but if you start inciting crime, that's a problem. In Germany, the line is drawn much further back. It doesn't matter if what you say incites crime, the speech in and of itself is illegal.