3 ms·
I disagree. Git didn't win--GitHub won. Git was the parasite carried along by the GitHub host.
by bsder 6y ago
I disagree. Git didn't win--GitHub won.
Git was the parasite carried along by the GitHub host.
- dwheeler 6y agoNo, git essentially won. GitHub is the single most common site for OSS projects, but there are many others, and they generally use git as well. GitLab obviously supports git. SourceForge supports git. Savannah supports git. Bitbucket supports git. Microsoft internally uses git, and that happened before they bought GitHub: https://techcrunch.com/2017/05/24/microsoft-now-uses-git-and-gvfs-to-develop-windows/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/05/24/microsoft-now-uses-git-and... There are other version control systems, but git is by far and away the majority player.
- bsder 6y agoMethinks you need a history lesson. Bitbucket was originally Mercurial-only. Savannah was SVN-only forever. SourceForge (geez--people still mention them after they turned into a dumpster fire of malware?) was CVS then SVN and only much later Git (long after SourceForge was relevant anymore). I presume GitLab was Git from the start. > Microsoft internally uses git Long after there was any relevance to the choice.
- dwheeler 6y agoMethinks not. I was around for all that history, and that is exactly my point. Savannah, bitbucket, and SourceForge all added support for git later because they had to. They added support for git because git won, not because it failed. Also, please look at the article I cited about Microsoft. That was not just a simple swap. Microsoft could not use git as-is because of the way they use Version Control in general. Instead of sticking to their existing system, they implemented additional functionality for git so that git would work in their environment. That is a vote of confidence for git, because they believed it was better to add functionality to git.
- aaron695 6y agoYep. I think that's mostly it. Linux backed, followed by GitHub sold the deal. The incumbents were possibly better but were too forked to individually beat that team. It became a standard like English as someone else pointed out.
- dwheeler 6y agoThere's more to it than that. I think mercurial's user interface has its advantages, but when they were facing off each other, git was far faster and quickly added more advanced capabilities. Power users preferred the speed, and they were the ones generally deciding which version control systems to use. But that does not mean that git's user interface is perfect. I think there are many things that could be done to make it much easier to understand and use by non power users.
- aaron695 6y agoI agree Git won the power users. I think perhaps all that's needed is a GUI front end that ignores the structure of Git and just gives non-power users what they want. Like one button. Backup, delete repo, re-pull and re-add my changes. No explanation of what's doing under the hood. Simplify branches for simple repos. Power users can do their thing seperate. And improve GitHub. A WYSIWYG to edit .md files for instance. I think it's not impossible to get Git and GitHub good.