3 ms·
I think you make fine points, but they're not universal. I disagree with pretty much all of them: > Then friends won't visit, it's more of a hassle to schedule
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I think you make fine points, but they're not universal. I disagree with pretty much all of them:
> Then friends won't visit, it's more of a hassle to schedule - however infrequent these visits are they'll be even less frequent.
I would MUCH rather stay in a nearby hotel (and have my guests stay in a hotel). I would feel less like I was imposing.
> You'll go fewer places and do fewer things if everytime you want to go somewhere you have to deal with getting a rideshare van.
I think there's likely some truth to that, but it also means I rearrange my life to plan for this better and also to make those outings more meaningful.
> No backyard cookouts, no sitting on the deck, you'll go to the park less frequently
The analogy I use is the gym: I can do workouts at home, but the mental routine I have for getting up and going to the gym means I actually go much more often. Similarly, if there was a nearby park I liked I'd use it much more frequently. I know I felt that way when I lived in the city vs. where I do now in the burbs (note - the burbs weren't my choice ;)
- romwell 6y ago>I would MUCH rather stay in a nearby hotel (and have my guests stay in a hotel). I would feel less like I was imposing. You must be well-off with well-off friends. My friends would feel pretty bad if I were to pay for their hotel, and it is not an insignificant cost to many (especially since I'm living in the Bay Area). Crashing on a spare couch? No problemo. (Even if the economics of the spare couch work out in the favor of the hotel room. There is a utility in the spare couch beyond letting guests sleep on it, and that understanding takes away all the feelings of imposing, at least financially.) However, all of that ignores the fundamental difference. You're not my guest when you're in a hotel. I can't wake you up for breakfast and make you coffee. We can't watch movies on the couch until either feels sleepy. And so on. You can't rent the experience of sharing your home with someone if you don't have a home to share.
- Groxx 6y ago>>I would MUCH rather stay in a nearby hotel (and have my guests stay in a hotel). I would feel less like I was imposing. >You must be well-off with well-off friends. As always, It Depends™. I have friends allergic to our pets, some have significant trouble sleeping on inflatable beds or couches, etc. Some have kids, so one couch / one bed won't cut it. The only way it's reasonable for them to visit without having pretty major issues after a day or so is when we're all up for setting up a hotel + transportation (or similar)... which ends up meaning it's less often than some other friends.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> You must be well-off with well-off friends. I don't think extravagantly so, but I have worked in software for a couple decades and saved a lot. But I think you're confusing the fundamental question here. Sure, when I was in my twenties I crashed at friends' places, and they at mine, all the time. But the article is specifically about the tradeoff of getting a smaller, cheaper, apartment, vs. getting a larger house in the suburbs with a spare guest room. The idea that it's usually a cheaper option to pay for the occasional hotel than to specifically purchase a larger house with rooms you rarely use. Obviously the "crash on my couch" is a different dynamic entirely.
- pathseeker 6y ago>I don't think extravagantly so, but I have worked in software for a couple decades and saved a lot. Well then you are well-off. Most people can't swing 5 nights in a high CoL city without months and months of saving. Offering to pay for someone to stay in a hotel creates an extremely bad dynamic when the receiver couldn't easily afford that on their own. >he idea that it's usually a cheaper option to pay for the occasional hotel than to specifically purchase a larger house with rooms you rarely use. Yep, but the important distinction is that a hotel room isn't equivalent because it's a very easily measurable monetary burden on the host.
- kelnos 6y ago> I can't wake you up for breakfast and make you coffee. We can't watch movies on the couch until either feels sleepy. And so on. Couldn't agree more. In most cases I'd rather crash on a friend's couch than sleep on a comfier hotel bed if it means we can hang out until we pass out and not have to worry about getting me back to my hotel.
- landryraccoon 6y ago> and have my guests stay in a hotel I'm curious, have you actually paid for friends to get a hotel room while they were visiting you? How did that work? I'm trying to imagine how I'd even offer without making it awkward. I don't think I could avoid making an already uncomfortable wealth disparity even more cringe-worthy. I think if I had to go that route I would at least rent an entire house on an AirBnb so I could stay with my friends - that way they're actually staying with me, rather than in a hotel in the same city.
- kelnos 6y agoYeah, that was my first reaction to that bit. Most of my friends would feel uncomfortable about me paying for a hotel room for them, and that would make me feel uncomfortable. I agree on the larger AirBnB option; I think that's a great way to keep everyone together and (both physically and emotionally) comfortable.
- cyberdrunk 6y ago> Yeah, that was my first reaction to that bit. Most of my friends would feel uncomfortable about me paying for a hotel room for them, and that would make me feel uncomfortable. Also, it means that they can basically never propose to come visit you (as they'd put you in an uncomfortable situation of having to approve/deny the hotel expense) and would only come by when you initiate the idea of a visit.
- kelnos 6y ago> I would MUCH rather stay in a nearby hotel (and have my guests stay in a hotel). I would feel less like I was imposing. I think it depends on your relationship with the friends. There are some friends where I'd be really sad if they didn't stay with me or I didn't stay with them. We cook and drink together, and stay up late watching movies or TV or just talking, to the point where we don't want to worry about having to get one of us to a hotel. One of my oldest friends has a cat that I'm mildly allergic to, but I will always sleep on his couch when I visit, even though the cost of a hotel room is well within my budget, and a hotel bed would probably be more comfortable than the couch. It's just so much more fun to stay with my friend. I get that this isn't for everyone, but that's kinda the point: everyone has different tastes. > The analogy I use is the gym: I can do workouts at home, but the mental routine I have for getting up and going to the gym means I actually go much more often. I've tried at various times to do the gym thing, but I just can never motivate myself. I think it's the overhead that kills it for me, the need to get myself ready to go, transport myself there, get into a routine, change, get myself home, etc. What ends up working for me is going for a 3-5 mile run in my neighborhood. I just change my shirt and pants, throw on running shoes, and go outside. I'm glad you've found a routine that helps keep you on track, but, again: everyone's different.