2 ms·
> I'm just thankful Facebook and Twitter weren't around to police wrong think during the gay and civil rights movements tbh. But during that time, there were m
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
> I'm just thankful Facebook and Twitter weren't around to police wrong think during the gay and civil rights movements tbh.
But during that time, there were mass media. They didn't allow the now-considered-right-thinking viewpoint (in the case of gays) or were not consistent in support of it (civil rights). Those who were pro-gay and pro-civil-rights needed alternate means of communication. The same may be true today.
Fortunately, we have such means - email, phone, text, snail mail. You don't have to talk to people who think like you on Facebook or Twitter. If the mainstream media becomes too censorious, talk somewhere else.
Note well: This does not mean that I am in favor of Facebook censoring, especially if it goes several steps further than just holocaust denial. But if they do, it's not the end of dissent. Dissent just grows underground.
- asah 6y agoPlease pick another example: these movements were never calling for genocide.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoYeah, see, that's kind of the point. You censor a movement calling for genocide (or, more precisely, denying a genocide in the past). But if you're going to do that, do all of them. Censor Turkey denying the Armenian genocide. Censor those who sweep Stalin's crimes under the rug. Censor those who try to minimize the death toll of the Cultural Revolution and the Great Leap forward. Censor those who say that the Europeans' conquest of the Americas was anything other than a genocide. And, if we were 50 years ago, censor the communists calling for global revolution. That's not a call for genocide, exactly, but it's a call for a lot of death, and for destruction of a class of people, which is in the same camp. But the problem is, once you do that, do you stop there? Or do you say, well, the Soviets are behind this "civil rights" agitation, so we have to censor that, too? And this "gay rights" stuff is corrupting the morals of our youth, so we have to censor that? And even if you say, no, violence only, don't censor anything else, somebody else is going to push for it to go further. How do you know that your viewpoint (violence only) is going to win? You don't. So be very careful about calling for censorship, even of things that you are sure are wrong. Soon enough it will be applied to things you're sure are right.