5 ms·
Everything you have written is terrestrial speculation based on the same mistaken assumption - that human intelligence is as smart as it gets. If aliens exist
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
Everything you have written is terrestrial speculation based on the same mistaken assumption - that human intelligence is as smart as it gets.
If aliens exist they will be alien. They will not be a bit weird with our naive ideas of sort-of-better alien tech. They will be something entirely different, and very likely able to do entirely unexpected things.
Imagine a species which has roughly the same intelligence advantage over humans as humans have over cats. Most of what humans spend their time doing today is incomprehensible to cats. Virtually all of math, physics, the Internet, the arts, philosophy is far beyond the imagination of an animal which hasn't evolved past a need to find food, sex, and occasional snuggles.
Now imagine a species which stretches the comparison to human-vs-ant. Not only are humans activities unimaginable, they're invisible. Even though ants live in the middle of them.
Ant perception is tuned to pheromone trails, foraging, and occasional ant wars, and ants don't have much of a concept of freeways, telecommuting, corner supermarkets, house renovation projects, or Amazon Prime - even though they may be surrounded by them.
Not only do ants not understand them, they cannot see them, except for those rare occasions where ants become a nuisance and a human decides to wipe them out.
It's irrational and naive to assume that we are the most evolved of all possible intelligences in a universe which is as big as this one is, and whose operation we really don't understand. We could be well surrounded by alien activities which are far outside our conceptual grasp - except for those occasions when the aliens take a passing interest, with strange and incomprehensible consequences.
- eitland 6y agoTo add to this: it is way less than 100 years since we learned to use fission and fusion. Until the two first bombs were dropped it was either unknown or, to those who realized the potential: considered impossible with the technology available at the time. I wonder what is just out of reach for us today, or what scientists are secretly working on today. Also, one step ahead, like you I also think what we are capable of seeing and understanding might be very limited compared to other beings.
- NikolaeVarius 6y agoThat really isn't a valid comparison. The bombs were built specifically because scientists theorized that it would be possible to generate large bombs with their knowledge of atomic energy. They underestimated the scale of the bombs. Govt's dont pour billions of dollars into impossible technologies.
- shiftpgdn 6y agoHow much have MK Ultra, MK demon, etc cost?
- InfiniteRand 6y agoThere was the Stargate Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stargate_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stargate_Project
- NikolaeVarius 6y agoI think moonshot research projects are a different scenario.
- eitland 6y ago> The bombs were built specifically because scientists theorized that it would be possible to generate large bombs with their knowledge of atomic energy. Below is my attempt to add a little more detail so it doesn't sound unrealistically straightforward: ...because a few scientists theorized that it could be possible to generate large bombs with their knowledge of atomic energy and because politicians became desperate enough to give it a chance.
- cletus 6y agoAh the "you don't know what's possible" argument. The rationale for the Dyson Swarm future it can be built incrementally, requires tech we basically have and can scale massively. The consequence is that it's not remotely subtle. These things have a distinct signature because the only way to get rid of heat in space is to radiate it away and that has a distinct IR signature. Given all this we can reasonably conclude that there isn't a massive set of Dyson swarms within a pretty huge light cone. So the problem of "you don't know what's possible" is that for each new known unknown (eg whether FTL is possible, whether fusion will ever work as a viable power source) and unknown unknown it gets _more_ likely we'll see these things not less. Let's say there are 5 spacefaring civilizations in the MIlky Way other than us. The odds that 0 of them go this route and choose to remain "hidden" is much more possible than if, say, there were 1000 spacefaring civilizations in the Milk Way. In a universe with FTL those numbers (5 and 1000) now use a much bigger volume as their basis. Perhaps the Local Group. Perhaps the entire Universe. Here's the other big problem with "You don't know what's possible": if we can't conceive of some super-advanced technology or higher existence, what are the odds that other civilizations can't either? If we're 1 of 5, we may be the sole dumb kid on the block. But out of 1000? I'd be willing to bet there are others sufficiently like us operating under similar constraints with outcomes we can reason about in aggregate. Let me put this in perspective. Human peak energy usage is estimated at about 10^11 W (Watts). Years ago a Russian physicist postulated the Kardashev scale for energy, which is pretty simple: - K1 (Kardashev-1) civilizations use the power output of a planet) - K2 civilizations use the power output of a star - K3 civilizations use the power output of a galaxy. Obviously these aren't absolute units (eg stars have different power outputs) but it's a useful framework. Carl Sagan came along later and simplified the scale somewhat to: - K1 = 10^16W - K2 = 10^26W - K3 = 10^36W (which implies ~10B stars in the "galaxy") So if we were to advance to being a K2 civilization around our own Sun we would have access to a truly mind-boggling amount of energy. To give just one example, we could essentially sterilize the Milky Way in about 100,000 years trivially without any object going further than the orbit of Mars. So you don't even need to decide if civilizations would on average do this or not. You just have to decide how likely is that _none_ would. 0 out of 5 doesn't defy belief here. 0 out of 1000 gets more incredulous. So back to our alien UFOs, the odds that no one does this, a civilization advances beyond this point, they discover FTL, they use it to come here and they hide their presence from most of us. they remain basically undetected in an era where everyone basically has a high-definition camera in their pocket (as opposed to the 50s and 60s) and somehow reveal themselves when they have technology we couldn't even imagine... simply defies belief.