6 ms·
Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as a computer system
- jgilias 6y agoThere was a DARPA project called F6 for validating a similar concept. Spent a few million USD and ended with nothing much to show. Turns out formation flying is hard. Especially with satellites with limited orbital alignment capabilities, as the small uneven effects on the orbit from various sources (other planets, atmospheric drag, etc) eventually add up and you have to be able to correct the orbit from time to time to keep the formation. Apart from that, communications tech reliable enough for the kind of distributed in-orbit computation was still not there last I checked. I wonder if anything has changed in the meanwhile.
- Zenst 6y agoF6 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractionated_spacecraft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractionated_spacecraft What has changed since then would be scale of alternative launch options as well as progress in satellite/radio tech and a bit smaller or lighter, sure does scale in savings. Perhaps with those factors it may well prove viable to revisit that. That an antenna's and phased arrays, been much progress even in the last ten years and might be that such visions need another ten years, but certainly seems a sound goal overall.
- jgilias 6y agoI completely agree that the goal is a good one. Downlink bandwidth is one of the most restricting bottlenecks limiting what we can achieve with satellites. It's absolutely worthwhile to revisit this idea from time to time. Someone should make a website 'are we async in orbit yet'.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoI wonder if a self-healing mesh network would make more sense... just set up a mesh that readjusts for satellites going in and out of range...
- Rebelgecko 6y agoI heard this secondhand from a colleague who somehow ended up with one of the F6 cubesats sitting on an endtable in his office, but my understanding was that formation flying wasn't really what killed F6. Over the planned mission duration the satellites wouldn't have drifted apart too much, and even without thrusters there's tricks you can use to tweak orbital periods to keep them lined up. Even that is a moot point, since for F6 they didn't need to be lined up, a cluster was acceptable. The main problem came from the 4th F in F6, fractionated. The goal was to create a heterogenous network of satellites, built by a whole litany of manufacturers without even a common bus. That ended up being a solution in search of a problem. It made integration way more complex, which was exacerbated by the number of independent participants. The project spent a lot of time working on shared SDKs that would work across the constellation. In practice, there weren't really enough benefits over homogeneous constellations to make all the extra effort worthwhile. Instead of having 5 satellites with cameras beam their images to another satellite that determines which images are cloudy, it's easier to just have each satellite running identical code so it can figure out for itself which images are cloudy. On top of that, a homogenous network has advantages wrt survivability, manufacturing costs, maintenance, etc
- portillo 6y agoI agree, this was the real reason why the project failed. Moreover, it was not clear at all that fractionation would bring any lifecycle costs savings, neither that any of the alleged extra flexibility (and maneuverability, resiliency, maintenability, and other -ilities) would result in any added value for the missions. Fractionation is very hard,it introduces a lot of complexity in the design and interfaces, and it requires lots of coordination between multiple vendors. Project Ara by Google (a modular cellphone similar to Phoneblocks) also vouched for this idea of fractionation (and in fact was also led by Paul Ermenko) and was also cancelled.
- agency 6y agoRe: Communications tech, the 2nd generation of SpaceX's Starlink satellites are supposed to be able to communicate with each other via laser interlinks [1]. A friend of a friend works on the tech there and described the accuracy required for the lasers as being like shining a laser from LA to New York and hitting a specific window pane on the Empire State Building. [1] https://wccftech.com/spacex-starlink-satellite-laser-test/ https://wccftech.com/spacex-starlink-satellite-laser-test/
- panzagl 6y agoCubeSats are like the Raspberry Pis of engineering departments- fun to play with, but by the time you overcome their limitations (power, antenna size, heat) you've basically proved that small things can do small things.
- Zenst 6y agoHowever, if you got a cluster of them working together as a phased array - then you not only overcome the limitations, but surpass alternative offerings. But is the tech ready for that, maybe not and who knows - inter Cubesat communication may end up being a case of using lasers for that short few meter formation cluster. Certainly some interesting challenges and yet such things are within reach.
- Retric 6y agoYou can’t maintain a cluster of things in orbit without actively expending propellent. At best you can have either a long line of cube sats in the exact same orbit, or so many of them in different orbits that you can always communicate between orbits.
- a1369209993 6y ago> You can't maintain a cluster of things in orbit without actively expending propellent. Well, or physically connecting them with tethers. (Bonus: you no longer need wireless communications between them. Malus: pretty much everything else about this design.)
- datameta 6y agoOne can run astonishingly accurate near-SotA ML models on even the rad hardened space rated systems with scant resources. For example after 8-bit quantization, pruning, and compression a wake-word NN can take just 14KB. An RPi tier SBC can do quite a bit of inferencing!
- d_silin 6y ago
- datameta 6y agoI look forward to the day we have orbital embedded ML. Comms take 3-6 magnitudes more energy than the rest of an embedded system so less comms use leads to a positive feedback loop of more energy and compute available for sensor reads, inferencing, and analysis.
- friseurtermin 6y agoIs communication that expensive energy-wise? Is this just a thing in space given the transport medium or a general rule?
- datameta 6y agoI don't know enough physics to comment on the effect of different media on EM emissions but from what I understand any potential effects would not be significant enough to negate an order of magnitude difference due to the the nature of broadcasting or even beam-forming a stream of data v.s. sending it down a physical channel that is in comparison a point to point use of resources to manipulate bits (ALU ops, SRAM r/w, Flash r/w). Might be able to find the paper I'm referencing. Will post tomorrow.
- datameta 6y agoFigure 2.2: Energy cost of different operations on 32-bit values in a leading 45nm foundry process https://people.csail.mit.edu/jrk/jrkthesis.pdf https://people.csail.mit.edu/jrk/jrkthesis.pdf (Page 21)
- friseurtermin 6y agoThanks!
- d_silin 6y agoWe are building this: https://www.exodusorbitals.com https://www.exodusorbitals.com Feel free to ask questions
- iamgopal 6y agoPossible Application of this ? Can't satellite just be dummy sensor and all computing works happen on the ground ?
- d_silin 6y agoDownlink is the biggest bottleneck at the moment. Your satellite camera or SDR can produce thousand times more data than the amount you can download. You'd definitely benefit from in-space processing.
- jvanderbot 6y agoDownlink will pretty much always be the biggest constraint. You'll always want more data down than you can affordably downlink. And sensors will always produce more data.
- shanxS 6y agoApart from science experiments and taking pictures, how can this platform be used to deliver business value?
- d_silin 6y agoThere is a number of applications in development that will rely on in-space processing. Such as forest fire prediction, business intelligence from space (estimate the crop yields, oil reservoir levels, city planning and so on). Most of them use ML algorithms to extract valuable insights.
- lozaning 6y agoIs bandwidth from outer space so expensive that you save money by moving compute to the edge and only pushing down results to earth instead of the entire data set?
- aj7 6y agoThe problem with intelligent early discard is the potential cost of missing something cleverly disguised, that might be seen by an analyst, but not by an AI program. Equivalently, were AI to advance to the point of dispensing with the analyst layer, it would probably run on physically large machines. Perhaps we should concentrate on very high bandwidth transmission to the ground.
- kleton 6y agoIs proliferation of orbiting trash really something we should strive for?
- rfdave 6y agoSomewhat related, http://server-sky.com/ http://server-sky.com/ proposes putting servers in orbit. Would make a nice adjutant to the mega constellation projects going on