9 ms·
Pro side: I don't see anything wrong with requiring a surety to ensure that people awaiting trial don't flee, in principle. It makes sure people are less likel
by bawolff 6y ago
Pro side: I don't see anything wrong with requiring a surety to ensure that people awaiting trial don't flee, in principle.
It makes sure people are less likely to run away while at the same time doesnt force them to sit in jail while they await trial.
It should be relative to your ability to pay, and the commercial bondsman industry seems messed up, but those are implementation details and not the core of the system.
*as an interesting note, in Canada its illegal to be a commercial bondsmand - https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-46/section-139.html#docCont https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-46/section-139.ht... i think that helps make the bail system be much more sane.
- rallison 6y agoIf the downsides weren't so significant, then sure, the pro side makes sense. But the downsides are incredibly significant - that you have huge numbers of people who spend time in jail or spend money for a bail bond, who are indeed innocent, is a sign of a fundamentally broken system. > It should be relative to your ability to pay Sure, this would help, but I suspect it would still end up often unjustly impacting those who are poorer and innocent. If people don't show up for trial, charge them for that then. But pre trial, while presumed innocent, aside from unique high flight risk scenarios? The bail system is terrible, and fundamentally unfair. Edit: to be clear, making it relative to ability to pay, and eliminating commercial bail bondsmen would be a big step in the right direction. I still think that's rife with issues, but it would be significantly better than what we have now.
- bawolff 6y agoFundamentally the idea of a surety doesn't work for the really poor. If you don't have anything to put up as collateral, you don't have anything to loose by skipping bail. The flip side of that, is if you are really poor you have less resources to use making your escape, so maybe the bail system is less needed. But just because the bail system doesn't work well for poor people doesn't mean its also broken for middle class people.
- alkonaut 6y ago> you don't have anything to put up as collateral, you don't have anything to loose by skipping bail. This right here is the problem. Addressing this would probably solve the bail issue too. The question should perhaps be: is America ready to do what it takes to address poverty?
- justinclift 6y ago> If you don't have anything to put up as collateral, you don't have anything to loose by skipping bail. That doesn't seem correct. Wouldn't that really only be the case for guilty people, whereas innocent people would turn up in order to be proven innocent - assuming (perhaps wrongly) that they'd win?
- Beldin 6y agoI don't think poor people in the US would assume they win. And that is one major factor: when there is little to nothing to gain by staying Wwithin the system, but a lot to lose, why would you stay? Another issue is that showing up isn't free. At the very least, it costs time. Remark that defendants typically aren't compensated, even if acquitted. If you're poor, you might not be able to afford to attend.
- harha 6y agoYou could reduce some of the downsides by reducing the amount required for bail by day and by adding limits for how long someone could be required to stay. Also an automated system to calculate bail and maximum duration (as in not the judge deciding) might reduce some bias, so some categories of potential crimes don’t end up in jail while awaiting trial unless it’s a repeated offense. Another approach could be to account for the pre trial days more favorably for the defendant: x days pre trial count for 2x days if convicted or need to get reimbursed at the higher of minimum rate or more than the loss of income. This approach would require a way to make sure judges don’t collude though.
- bawolff 6y ago> You could reduce some of the downsides by reducing the amount required for bail by day and by adding limits for how long someone could be required to stay Either the amount is sufficient to prevent the accused from hopping on a plane to Bali, or it isn't. If a lesser amount would have sufficied than that should have been the amount in the first place. Bail isn't meant as a punishment, its meant as a way to ensure you don't leave town. If you could just wait it out, everyone who wanted to run would just wait it out, and you would end up bssically creating a system that just hinders "good" people while not serving its purpose of preventing people from skipping out.
- PopeDotNinja 6y agoI don’t like imprisoning people because just they are poor.
- kelnos 6y agoI would rather see 10 guilty people flee before their trial and escape justice, than see one innocent person get stuck in jail pre-trial because they couldn't cough up the cash for a bail bond, causing them to lose their job and ruin their life. Means testing flat-out doesn't work. There are plenty of people who get caught in the system who can afford exactly zero dollars for bail, and I find it damn near impossible that any system set up to make this "fair" would ever allow for the possibility that they need to let a person go with no bail paid at all.
- kepler1 6y ago...I would rather see 10 guilty people flee before their trial and escape justice, than see one innocent person get stuck in jail pre-trial because they couldn't cough up the cash for a bail bond, causing them to lose their job and ruin their life. This is why poor black neighborhoods are crime ridden and victimized. You would have the law abiding citizen of these poor areas subject to 10 criminals roaming the streets for the symbol of 1 person not subject to cash bond. Your own efforts to believe in racial justice by any means undermine the outcome itself.
- mulmen 6y ago> This is why poor black neighborhoods are crime ridden and victimized. Are you claiming this is unique to black neighborhoods? Why would there be a racial component to this issue at all? > Your own efforts to believe in racial justice by any means undermine the outcome itself. You appear to be the first person in this thread to invoke race.
- kepler1 6y ago[I don't think it's right that people are flagging my comment] If you don't see that this problem is particularly unfair and concentrated in poor black neighborhoods, you are truly allowing your idealism blind you to reality. For some reason maybe you don't want to talk about race, despite the entire matter being centered around "Black Lives Matter".
- mulmen 6y agoHow do you reconcile this with the presumption of innocence? Is it ok to make an innocent person pay a burdensome amount until they are exonerated?
- throwaway17_17 6y agoIn a vast majority of US jurisdictions, the presumption of innocence is a ‘right’ that only exists for the defendant’s lawyer to y’all about at trial. Almost all law enforcement interaction and pre-trial court proceeding operate under an inference of ‘named defendant is more likely guilty than not’.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- btashton 6y agoExcept that even studies by the US Department of Justice show that risk of financial loss has one of the lowest impacts on likely to appear in court. This is also not recent discovery, this was heavily researched in the 70s. Ironically just releasing people as soon as possible actually has one of the largest impacts on making sure people show. https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/Digitization/32349NCJRS.pdf https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/Digitization/32349NCJRS.pdf https://www.ncjrs.gov/App/Publications/abstract.aspx?ID=53743 https://www.ncjrs.gov/App/Publications/abstract.aspx?ID=5374...
- meragrin_ 6y agoIs it about risk of financial loss or about setting up a financial incentive for a third-party to bring the person in?
- gowld 6y agoThere's minimal third party incentive.
- gowld 6y agoI can imagine that after fighting to escape a brazenly unfair, discriminatory, hateful, pre-trial detention, I wouldn't be inclined to go roll those dice again for trial. Well, I would because I'm rich and look upper class.
- krsdcbl 6y agoI honestly don't really see the pro side. Assuming the accused is guilty and financially well able to pay for bail, this sounds like a pretty good deal to me to just drop some cash, write it off, and be able to leave and never show up for trial. Assuming the accused is innocent and financially unable to pay for bail, they'll end up in jail without ever having committed a crime. Like so much else in the US, it's showing heavy signs of a plutocraty, where money even decides if you'll be subject to the judiciary system or not. In almost any sane judiciary system I know there will be a pre-trial hearing to determine the likeliness of the suspect fleeing or obfuscating evidence, and only if this risk is arguably given, only then the suspect would be put in investigative custody (and that time served will be either counted towards the sentence, if guilty, or damages repayed to the suspect if proven innocent)
- samatman 6y ago> Assuming the accused is guilty and financially well able to pay for bail, this sounds like a pretty good deal to me to just drop some cash, write it off, and be able to leave and never show up for trial. I don't support cash bail, personally, but it's worth noting that some amount of the bail money can be converted to a bounty for the apprehension of those of the accused who go on to skip trial.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoFrom a non-US person, the whole Bounty system, now that is where things truly hit the Blade-Runner-esque dystopia level.
- throwaway316943 6y agoNot really, it’s not as if it’s an old west wanted dead or alive thing. It’s actually pretty mundane. They even made a crappy reality TV show about it.
- beerandt 6y ago3rd party bounty hunters are a pretty rare thing. Most of the time it's the same bail bondsman who facilitates a suspects release that comes looking, since the bondsman doesn't get their money back from the court until the suspect shows. Which is the whole point. And that bondsman likely required the suspect to list and confirm the name, address, and phone number of every family member, employer, and close contact they have. Probably 95% of cases are the bondsman just calling the suspect's family to get them to encourage compliance. An angry moma is going to be more effective than any manhunt.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoI don't know. I think it is much better that a few folks don't show up to trial than to criminalize being poor. If I remember correctly, we can reduce folks not showing up by simple measures, like calling to remind folks of trial dates and making sure folks have transportation to get to trial. Why the heck would we put low-and-medium risk folks in jail, to be put in a position to lose their job, house, and freaking children, when we can do these other things that don't criminalize poverty while having less disruption of life? If folks are found not guilty after spending weeks or months in jail (while being low to medium risk of fleeing), shouldn't we then shoulder the responsibility of fixing the life we've left in shambles? Especially since there was, indeed, other options we could have taken? We don't: At least in Indiana, even if you are found not guilty, you have administrative costs taken out of the bail amount you got back. And that's if you were lucky enough not to be forced to use a bondsman - then you won't get anything back (Yes, folks are court-ordered to use bondsman). I don't think we should be asking for a surety for low risk at all, and medium risk is iffy - and this is just for felonies. I don't see a good reason to hold anyone for a misdemeanor. I'm not certain that removing bondsman would make the US system more sane, though it does mean that you aren't charging an actual fee to get out, but instead returning (most of) bail if found not guilty.
- 0xBA5ED 6y ago>I think it is much better that a few folks don't show up to trial than to criminalize being poor. >Why the heck would we put low-and-medium risk folks in jail, to be put in a position to lose their job, house, and freaking children, when we can do these other things that don't criminalize poverty while having less disruption of life? Keep in mind, it isn't easy to suddenly and accidentally get thrown in jail. If the violation is minor and non-violent, then by the time it gets to that point, the person will have had many chances to straighten up (more often than not) and simply chose to ignore the warnings.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> it isn't easy to suddenly and accidentally get thrown in jail. No one accidentally gets thrown in jail, its always an intentional act by another person. And it is very easy to suddenly get thrown in jail, particularly if you are poor and/or non-white. > If the violation is minor and non-violent, then by the time it gets to that point, the person will have had many chances to straighten up (more often than not) and simply chose to ignore the warnings. That's...very much not true. It might be true if you are referring to post-conviction incarceration, it is very much not true when talking about pre-trial confinement as a means of ensuring appearance. Plenty of minor and non-violent offenses are arrestable, rather than merely citable, even if the accused has no prior record.
- mtgx 6y ago> It should be relative to your ability to pay No, it shouldn't. It could be based on a TON of other things instead: take the ID, passport, driver's license, legally prevent them from leaving the city, etc etc. Obviously, none of them are perfect, but I don't think they are generally worse than ability to pay. Especially for rich people, ability to pay bail means nothing, so they could very easily leave the country if none of those other interdictions are set anyway. So the bail system it's really just an oppression tool against the poor. Not unlike debtors' prisons, really. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debtors%27_prison https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debtors%27_prison
- kstenerud 6y agoWestern Europe doesn't have bail bonds, and seems to function quite well. People don't run away, because running away from a criminal prosecution means your current life (house, possessions, career, friends, family, etc) is over. People who actually are flight risks (due to the nature of the crime, extensive assets out-of-country, etc) can be held in jail pending trial, but that's pretty rare. OR consider it this way: How much effort goes into making someone disappear into the witness relocation program? Now consider how much bigger and organized the US government is compared to some drug cartel? The amount of preparation and execution required to evade the US government for any length of time is immense, and beyond the means of almost everybody. In Germany for example, you get a court summons, and if convicted, you get a prison summons with about a month to tie up your affairs. None of this medieval hauling people away in chains BS. Bail might have made sense in the Wild West, when you could just run a few states over with your stuff and start over under a new name, but nowadays a fugitive life cuts you off from everything. And if someone is crazy enough to go that far, a bail bond won't make a lick of difference.
- endogui 6y agoI mostly find your argument convincing, but keep in mind that there is no unitary "US government": most charges are under state law. This means that although the national government can know where you are down to the apartment number, you can be (legally) completely unreachable to the state that has ordered you to trial. The solution may be to just lock up the accused more liberally than in Europe, but I'm curious how Europe handles this problem in the Shengen zone.
- kstenerud 6y agoYou just extradite them, same as the American states do when someone flees to a different state. I've yet to hear of someone being "untouchable" in another Shengen country. Are American state criminal laws that incompatible with each other?
- allendoerfer 6y agoSince you are the second poster to spell it wrong: It's Schengen.
- rlpb 6y ago> Pro side: I don't see anything wrong with requiring a surety to ensure that people awaiting trial don't flee, in principle. In the UK you get bail automatically unless you are a flight risk. The burden of proof is on the prosecution. Why should the burden of proof not be reversed in the US? What good does it do to automatically assume that everyone is a flight risk, when we know that most people are not?
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoBecause while you are technically innocent until proven guilty, society treats folks that are arrested as guilty unless proven innocent - and even then, if they were acting properly, they think they wouldn't have been arrested. Example: a background check sometimes produces an arrest record (not a conviction), and that can cost a job. Background check companies don't have to be licensed, and no one keeps track. But you are correct: The burden of proof should be reversed. We know most folks aren't a flight risk and gentle measures - such as having folks check in and calling folks to remind them of court dates - have good results.
- nobody9999 6y ago>Pro side: I don't see anything wrong with requiring a surety to ensure that people awaiting trial don't flee, in principle. And if you can't scrape together $500 or $1000 for bail, how far are you going to get if you try to run away? It seems to me that those who can afford bail are much more likely to flee than those who can't.