3 ms·
This might be one of the easier tech breakups. Chromium is already open-source and buildable without Google infra, so doing the same for the close source code s
by dehrmann 6y ago
This might be one of the easier tech breakups. Chromium is already open-source and buildable without Google infra, so doing the same for the close source code should be a lot easier than migrating a service outside of Google infra. Firefox has shown there's a viable business model. The relationship with Android and Chromebook would be weird, but it might just look like a licensing deal. There's also precedent in antitrust history. The main thing I'd look at in Chrome is how much Google's used it to give itself an unfair advantage. I'd say "some;" the aggressive sign-in, default search provider, oversized influence in the development if HTTP, CSS, and JS. I'd put the synergies somewhere between Amazon/Whole Foods and Google/Doubleclick.
About the "precedent" point: I wonder if the MS antitrust case slowed down the development of the web. The dot com crash and people still being on dialup didn't help, but the web wasn't really a usable platform until 2004, and even then, it became a lot less interesting when smartphones took over.
- zacharycohn 6y agoMozilla/Firefox isn't doing that great: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/08/firefox-maker-mozilla-lays-off-250-workers-says-covid-19-lowered-revenue/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/08/firef...
- dehrmann 6y agoIf you read some of the old HN threads when that happened, there were a few takes on Mozilla. One is that they lost the browser war, so they should cut their losses (like with Thunderbird) and move on. The other was that they underinvested in what their supporters care about (the browser) and were distracted by things like Pocket. Mozilla is also in a different situation than a spun-off Chrome; Chrome would be a market leader with licensing deals.
- granzymes 6y agoOn the other hand, because Chromium is already open-source is there any need to split Chrome from Google? There are already a bunch of other browsers piggybacking on Chromium. The article is a little vague on the antitrust reasoning behind splitting off Chrome. It bases the argument on how getting rid of third-party cookies could be bad for publishers, but at the same time mentions that Chrome's competitors have already done away with them. From an antitrust perspective I think it makes sense to go after the ad tech stack, but this article feels like it is trying to throw everything against the wall and see what sticks.