2 ms·
> Now Android has all the negotiating power. It can create its own browser based on Chromium and charge Google an exorbitant fee for being the default search en
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> Now Android has all the negotiating power. It can create its own browser based on Chromium and charge Google an exorbitant fee for being the default search engine.
Android is code, which anybody can use for free. Making it into a separate entity would cause it to instantly go bankrupt because nobody would have any reason to pay them for anything. Even if they changed the license, everybody would just use the free version from last week and Android Corporation would have no money with which to make improvements, so there would be no improvements for them to charge anything for. Anybody who wanted to try to do this could already fork Android and do it right now; notice the lack of takers.
The reason Samsung et al don't charge Google to be the default browser on their phones already is Google Play Services. So what they really need to separate from the search engine company isn't Android, it's Google Play. Though, of course, if they did that, the search engine company might lose interest in funding Android development.
- hal9000-tng 6y ago> Android is code.. Actually, the situation is exactly the same for Chrome/Chromium: Chrome is code, which anybody can use for free. Making it into a separate entity would cause it to instantly go bankrupt because nobody would have any reason to pay them for anything. Even if they changed the license, everybody would just use the free version from last week and Chrome Corporation would have no money with which to make improvements, so there would be no improvements for them to charge anything for. Anybody who wanted to try to do this could already fork Chrome and do it right now; notice the (non-)lack of takers.
- wmf 6y agoI would assume that Play Store and Play Services would be part of Android Inc. in any breakup and thus Android would be profitable.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoMaybe. Though I suspect one of the big reasons that nobody tries too hard to eat Google Play's lunch is that they're backstopped by Google's resources, so if you actually started to succeed, Google would just pour money into crushing you until you were suitably crushed. If they were separated from unlimited resources, it would no longer be a Sisyphean task to reimplement everything they do, and then others may sense weakness and make the attempt. Though really that could be the best thing to happen. Let Android Corporation fail, we don't need it anyway, meanwhile everybody else reimplements Google Play Services as part of the open source project, and then Google Play evaporates and there are multiple competing stores from Samsung and Valve and Amazon and Debian that anybody can use on any Android device. And Android gets developed in the same way as the Linux kernel.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoPhone vendor app stores exist, ad do 3rd party app stores.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoBut nobody uses them because Google has market power.