3 ms·
Is the higher cost for nuclear related to the high regulation put in place? Are the low costs for solar and wind using subsidies and considering lifetime/replac
by SV_BubbleTime 6y ago
Is the higher cost for nuclear related to the high regulation put in place? Are the low costs for solar and wind using subsidies and considering lifetime/replacement/disposal?
Don’t know. Actually asking.
- epistasis 6y agoSome nuclear proponents say that regulation is the cause, but in my experience they aren't the proponents that have examined actual projects' economic failures in the past decade. And even those who say that regulations are the reason for high prices don't seem to have any specific suggestions of how to change regulations, just a general "regulations are a problem" vibe, with the implicit suggestion of "get rid of all regulations" since no other change is offered. But I would love to encounter somebody who says that regulations are the problem and also has ways to change them to allow more economic construction. Just hasn't ever happened despite tons of discussions with lots is people over the past five years I've been following nuclear closely.
- pydry 6y agoPartly. It's also just very expensive to build a nuclear plant. It's also worth noting that cleanup costs in the case of a nuclear accident are capped by law at $200 million. Any costs above that are shouldered by the taxpayer. Cleanup costs for Fukushima are about ~$500 billion.
- ebalit 6y agoDo you have a source for those $500 billions cleanup costs? I'm interested in what is included in order to reach this figure.
- pydry 6y agohttps://www.scientificamerican.com/article/clearing-the-radioactive-rubble-heap-that-was-fukushima-daiichi-7-years-on/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/clearing-the-radi...
- redis_mlc 6y agoEven using a number like $500 billion or $1 trillion or more ... - TEPCO expects to spend 40 or more years on the cleanup - 250,000 residents were displaced for years - the Japanese army and political structure were stressed by this, and will be for generations - one could go on endlessly. It was preventable by having a qualified facility auditor spend a couple days looking at the backup generators, common with any data center audit.
- ebalit 6y agoI put here the interesting paragraph of this article. The JCER report is also interesting to get the details of what this number includes over a 40 years plan [0]. "Completely cleaning up and taking apart the plant could take a generation or more, and comes with a hefty price tag. In 2016 the government increased its cost estimate to about $75.7 billion, part of the overall Fukushima disaster price tag of $202.5 billion. The Japan Center for Economic Research, a private think tank, said the cleanup costs could mount to some $470 billion to $660 billion, however." 0: https://www.jcer.or.jp/english/accident-cleanup-costs-rising-to-35-80-trillion-yen-in-40-years https://www.jcer.or.jp/english/accident-cleanup-costs-rising...
- mnd999 6y agoAnd it takes a very long time. I’m not convinced at this point we have time to nuclear.
- epistasis 6y agoAnd to address the other half of your question, the lower costs for solar and wind take into account the lifetime of the generation, and it's usually measured by the levelized cost of energy (LCOE) which is roughly the lifetime cost divided by the lifetime energy output. This does not take into account the value of the time that energy is delivered, so LCOE is not directly comparable for renewables and dispatchable generation like natural gas (though a huge percentage of the new solar and wind deploys for the next 5 years are adding storage to convert them into dispatchable resources.) As for the disposal costs, that's a fairy trivial problem. Solar panel recycling has not really started because there's not many dead panels to recycle; lifetimes are tending to be longer than expected. However as there is a larger source of retired solar panels, those attempting to recycle them will get a better feel for the costs of construction of new panels from raw materials versus recycled magerials.
- manfredo 6y agoThe issue with renewables isn't recycling, it's storage. Solar generates electricity in a sine wave. Half the day it's generating no electricity. Wind doesn't follow a sine wave, but has the potential to generate lower levels of power for long stretches of time. Wind is consistent on a yearly basis, but variable on a weekly basis.
- epistasis 6y agoThat's a pretty big shift of the initial question, but it's an important shift! If you look in the "most free" markets for energy in the US, where there is the most possibility for independent companies to come in and provide generation and other energy resources, we are looking at ERCOT in Texas and PJM in the north. In these free markets, we are seeing huuuge amounts of storage resources in the interconnection pipeline over the next few years [1]. So where indecent investors are allowed to participate in energy, we are seeing massive influx of capital to build storage, from people that are profit-seeking. Meaning storage, at least this first chunk of it, is already likely to be economically efficient. That said, when we talk about renewables, wind and solar are largely uncorrelated, and where we have good wind resources we tend to get good wind at night. And when you look at load on grids, such as Texas' independent ERCOT grid, you see a sinusoidal pattern too [2]. And for ERCOT, with a sinusoidal amplitude of about 20GW, by sheer coincidence there are about 17GW of storage projects in the pipeline. And I'm pretty sure that doesn't include the solar projects that have storage directly on them, which is happening with a huge chunk of solar projects. And though Texas has been good at building wind resources, they have left their solar mostly untapped up until now. So as they start to deploy solar, they are going to get a ton of storage deployed with that too. The challenge is not longer the technology or the costs, the future challenges will be entirely about regulation, and whether entrenched interests will use regulatory capture to prevent new entrants that can supply cheaper low carbon energy to consumers and industry. [1] https://rmi.org/clean-energy-is-canceling-gas-plants/ https://rmi.org/clean-energy-is-canceling-gas-plants/ [2] http://www.ercot.com/content/cdr/html/loadForecastVsActualCurrentDay.html http://www.ercot.com/content/cdr/html/loadForecastVsActualCu...