3 ms·
Note: I shall talk of politics in this comment. I am not offering any opinion on the politics of either Biden and Democrats or Trump and Republicans. Regardles
by tzs 6y ago
Note: I shall talk of politics in this comment. I am not offering any opinion on the politics of either Biden and Democrats or Trump and Republicans.
Regardless of the merits of such a ban or the lack thereof, why do it right now?
Maybe I've missed some subtleties in Portland politics, but the impression I've gotten is that the people there and the politicians that win elections there would greatly prefer that Biden beat Trump in the US presidential election that is 23 days from now.
One of the points Trump has been trying to run on is that he supports law and order and the Democrats support crippling law enforcement to aid anarchists and far left extremists who want to destroy everything good about America.
I will not be at all surprised if this ban becomes part of Trump's message at rallies and in ads and helps drive some votes to him.
There is no good way for Biden to counter that. If he comes out in agreement with the ban, it helps Trump's law and order message. If he comes out against the ban to appeal to the law and order voter, without a long explanation of subtle tradeoffs involved, he'll alienate some voters on the left. If he comes out against the ban with a long and subtle explanation, he'll still alienate those voters because who the heck is going to actually read the long and subtle explanation?
We are at the "sound bites are all that matters" stage of the election, and Portland is giving Trump a great sound bite. The damage minimizing option for Biden is to just ignore it, ceding those law and order voters to Trump.
What about facial recognition in Portland is so urgent that they could not wait a month on this?
- t-writescode 6y agoPortland has been under protests and many of the articles written about what’s happening in Portland regularly reference police and federal police brutality in those protests. That is, law enforcement officers doing harm to the general public in those protests. These laws probably spawn out of that. It’s dealing with the manifestations they’re seeing in the protests at that local level. I don’t live in Portland and I don’t read the articles closely. This is an uneducated guess.
- tadfisher 6y agoI live here and would generally agree with your assessment. You bring up a good point about dealing with local issues. This movement is centered around a municipal budget concern, which is diverting funds from the police department to other forms of emergency response and community support programs. That our city is now the poster-child of the Trump campaign is telling.
- watwut 6y agoI don't think dynamic you describe is something that would affect undecided voters much. And honestly, what Portland or democrats actually so has so little impact on what trump says, that they might as well do what they want.
- bigbubba 6y agoBiden could simply do what politicians usually do when taking a stance on a matter is inconvenient for them: simply ignore it. Talk about other things when asked about it. This seems to work well for politicians, so I don't see a dilemma.
- Kednicma 6y agoYour entire argument rests on the premise that somehow governments cannot do multiple things at once. However, part of the responsibility of the government is to always exist to serve and protect the people. That need does not abate merely because the president is a fascist. He already marks himself clearly by positioning himself as diametrically opposite antifascism. No amount of propaganda can disguise that fact. And further, we know from history that appeasement does not work on fascists; we cannot merely sit back and let him have his way now while we plan for a future where he has mysteriously vanished. The mere existence of Portland is offensive to their political ends; it frustrates them that people might want a better society, and vote thusly. Good! Let them be frustrated; we have no obligation to be nice or pleasant to fascists. I will enjoy seeing them cry when we elect a female antifa mayor soon.