8 ms·
Why Renewables Aren't the Reason for California Blackouts: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2020/08/why-renewables-arent-reason-california-blackouts/
by pydry 6y ago
Why Renewables Aren't the Reason for California Blackouts: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2020/08/why-renewables-arent-reason-california-blackouts/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2020/08/why-renew...
LCOE of various energy sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source#Global_studies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source#...
https://neon.energy/Hirth-Ueckerdt-Edenhofer-2015-Integration-Costs-Revisited-Framework-Wind-Solar-Variability.pdf https://neon.energy/Hirth-Ueckerdt-Edenhofer-2015-Integratio... suggests that wind energy has up to 50% higher "real" cost than typical LCOE measurements because of variability, however, this still puts the costs for nuclear (118-192) a lot higher than wind (28-54) and solar (32-42).
- zaroth 6y agoThe National Geographic article attempts to make the point that the problems in CA aren’t fundamentally an issue with renewables. CA’s specific mishandling of their push for a renewable-heavy power supply is the cause, but renewables aren’t inherently the cause. This is technically true in a way, while denying the reality of the situation on the ground in CA.
- pydry 6y agoA lack of forecasting and reliance upon energy imports that are not supported by long term contracts aren't problems that are intrinsically all that hard to fix either. It just requires a bit more competence in running the grid. California has had a history of poor management of its electric grid (remember enron?). A wholesale switch to nuclear is a vastly expensive and not terribly effective fix for poor grid management.
- csours 6y agoI remember that California pointed the finger at FERC and Enron. I remember that Enron played the regulations like a fiddle, shutting down plants do drive up spot prices. I guess I don't know who is responsible for what exactly, and what California could have done better.
- nickpp 6y agoConsidering that Enron is gone and California still has blackouts, I guess the problem lays with the state?!
- ip26 6y agoWasn't half of the problem in CA due to unexpected natural gas plant power-downs? That was hardly renewable's fault.
- 7952 6y agoI don't think the fundamentals of the technology are ever the most important aspect of the debate. What constrains us are human, political and market factors. That is why America has been slow to adopt renewables and why the nuclear industry has declined. That is why the US grid is in such a poor state.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoIs the higher cost for nuclear related to the high regulation put in place? Are the low costs for solar and wind using subsidies and considering lifetime/replacement/disposal? Don’t know. Actually asking.
- epistasis 6y agoSome nuclear proponents say that regulation is the cause, but in my experience they aren't the proponents that have examined actual projects' economic failures in the past decade. And even those who say that regulations are the reason for high prices don't seem to have any specific suggestions of how to change regulations, just a general "regulations are a problem" vibe, with the implicit suggestion of "get rid of all regulations" since no other change is offered. But I would love to encounter somebody who says that regulations are the problem and also has ways to change them to allow more economic construction. Just hasn't ever happened despite tons of discussions with lots is people over the past five years I've been following nuclear closely.
- pydry 6y agoPartly. It's also just very expensive to build a nuclear plant. It's also worth noting that cleanup costs in the case of a nuclear accident are capped by law at $200 million. Any costs above that are shouldered by the taxpayer. Cleanup costs for Fukushima are about ~$500 billion.
- ebalit 6y agoDo you have a source for those $500 billions cleanup costs? I'm interested in what is included in order to reach this figure.
- pydry 6y agohttps://www.scientificamerican.com/article/clearing-the-radioactive-rubble-heap-that-was-fukushima-daiichi-7-years-on/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/clearing-the-radi...
- polote 6y agoYou can't compare nuclear and wind/solar, how are you going to power the lights at night when there is a no wind ?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sudoaza 6y agopower storage
- polote 6y agoso you have to include it in the cost, and...
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoWith energy from wind farms 1000 km away, hydro and biofuels closer by, and nearby storage. At the beginning, you'll probably also have a small amount of "dirty" generation as backup, but which sits idle most of the time.
- polote 6y ago> biofuels "Allocating 10% of arable land to biofuels would allow a net production of something like 4% of the present consumption of oil products." https://jancovici.com/en/energy-transition/renewables/could-we-totally-substitute-oil-by-biofuels/ https://jancovici.com/en/energy-transition/renewables/could-... >hydro "Increasing the hydro production from 10% (present value) of the electricity generated to 80% seems clearly impossible, and even a multiplication by 2 might be out of reach. " https://jancovici.com/en/energy-transition/renewables/hydroelectricity-our-silver-bullet/ https://jancovici.com/en/energy-transition/renewables/hydroe... > nearby storage "If all the electricity production in France was wind generated, storage in batteries would probably be impossible to ensure: to store one week of electricity consumption (which is over1 TWh per day for the whole country), the country should have 7 tons of lead-acid batteries (these batteries can store 30 Wh per kg) per French person (lead-acid batteries are not precisely perfectly “clean” regarding the environmental impact of their manufacturing and their end of life…)." https://jancovici.com/en/energy-transition/renewables/how-many-windmills-to-produce-all-french-electricity/ https://jancovici.com/en/energy-transition/renewables/how-ma... >farms 1000km away "[to support france 100% of production with wind] we should “plant” a surface of that is roughly 5% of the country" https://jancovici.com/en/energy-transition/renewables/how-many-windmills-to-produce-all-french-electricity/ https://jancovici.com/en/energy-transition/renewables/how-ma... if you have dirty generation then you solve the problem half of the time I will stop here because anyway people are not interested about the truth