3 ms·
Lets bring it back to the practice that was initially discussed. * Portland city passes a law, where its now illegal for police to use tear gas (https://www.np
by dragontamer 6y ago
Lets bring it back to the practice that was initially discussed.
* Portland city passes a law, where its now illegal for police to use tear gas (https://www.npr.org/sections/live-updates-protests-for-racial-justice/2020/09/10/911531561/portland-ore-mayor-bans-police-use-of-tear-gas-at-protests https://www.npr.org/sections/live-updates-protests-for-racia...)
* The use of tear gas remains legal in the State, and Federal governments. (This appears to be a local law and/or ordinance).
* Local Sheriff decides the law is stupid, uses tear gas anyway.
The Sheriff hasn't broken any state, or federal law. Only the local law. Literally no one can arrest him in this situation.
- indymike 6y agoSheriffs do have a lot of power, and are not immune from prosecution by federal or state authorities. Some states do have provisions for the arrest of the Sheriff. Here's an example from Indiana: "A warrant for the arrest of the county sheriff shall be served by the coroner or any other person to whom it may be legally directed. The coroner, who shall commit the sheriff to the county jail, has custody of the jail and its prisoners during the imprisonment of the sheriff."
- ghaff 6y ago>Sheriffs do have a lot of power Really depends on the locality. In Massachusetts, counties (and sheriffs are a county position) are mostly vestigial judicial and law enforcement districts and the state even eliminated about half of its counties in the late 1990s. On the other hand, when I lived in Louisiana, parish government (their equivalent of counties) was powerful so a sheriff was an important position.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Literally no one can arrest him in this situation Assuming the law is criminal, and applicable, city police probably can arrest him. It seems quite probable, though, that the city does not have the authority to regulate county or state law enforcement tactics, so the law is simply invalid as applicable to him, which isn't a “we have a sheriff as opposed to some other structure of county law enforcement” problem, but “we are trying to regulate the actions of higher levels of government” problem. EDIT: Actually, looking at your story, it doesn't look like there is any law at all—the Mayor of Portland made a policy change directed at his subordinates, which include the city police but not the Multnomah County Sheriff's Dpeartment. So no one can arrest anyone because there is no criminal law, except insofar a side of force inconsistent with city executive policy is covered by some criminal law applicable to Portland Police.
- dragontamer 6y ago> EDIT: Actually, looking at your story, it doesn't look like there is any law at all—the Mayor of Portland made a policy change directed at his subordinates, Good eye. I didn't notice that. In any case, the use of tear gas at demonstrations seems solidly like a "police tactic" to me. If your area has elected police leaders, then its important to choose a sheriff that you believe in. > so the law is simply invalid as applicable to him, which isn't a “we have a sheriff as opposed to some other structure of county law enforcement” problem, but “we are trying to regulate the actions of higher levels of government” problem. As far as I'm concerned, this is a "most people don't seem to understand how their own government works". The Sheriff's check on power is the election. The locality elects the Sheriff, which is why its usually so difficult to remove the Sheriff (because the Sheriff represents the will of the people). Sheriffs are relatively hard to remove by the very design of the office. It makes their elections very important.
- cronix 6y agoDoes city ordinance trump the county in which it resides when it comes to law enforcement? Does the city of Portland have legal jurisdiction over the county Sheriff?