10 ms·
Why Look at Flying Saucers?
- tgflynn 6y agoTo dismiss all evidence of UAP's out of hand as "illogical" is just as unscientific as to accept them as being proof of ET visitation. It may be that all these claimed observations are the product of some sort of collective psychosis, as this article appears to assume, but that's just one hypothesis among many others. Empirical questions require empirical investigation, not ignoring the question.
- fogihujy 6y agoIt's pretty much the same as with other pop-sci stuff that is being shoveled down the throat of people who still watch regular TV; sensationalized bullshit in most cases. We know there's something out there; it's occasionally seen by people who report it, and who who often somehow fail to bring proper cameras with them. It could be aliens, foreign governments, or more mundane explanations like weather phenomena. We just don't know what it is yet.
- HourglassFR 6y ago> To dismiss all evidence of UAP's out of hand as "illogical" is just as unscientific as to accept them as being proof of ET visitation. I think it's pretty disingenuous to present those two takes as being equally bad. Yes we don't know everything and leaving room for extraordinary things to happen is healthy, but I have yet to see evidences that aliens have cause a UAP. On the other hand we have good empirical evidence that sighting of unusal phenomenas with perfectly mundane explanations can, and do, create testimonies of so called "alien visitations". We even have pretty good psycho-sociological explanations for why this happens. So without even looking at the specific details of a particular UAP sighting, coming at it from the angle of "people probably saw weird stuff and their brains filled the gap" is the right approach in my opinion. That doesn't mean we have to stop here of course, but it is a sensible default position.
- tgflynn 6y ago> I have yet to see evidences that aliens have cause a UAP Neither have I but the title of this article is "why look at flying saucers", not "why believe in ET visitation". > We even have pretty good psycho-sociological explanations for why this happens. What well accepted psychological explanation is there for 4 naval aviators reporting an encounter with an object that appeared to defy our knowledge of aerodynamics in clear weather and broad daylight in the exact location they were vectored to by an Aegis radar system ?
- SiempreViernes 6y agoThey got confused by a mundane object?
- tgflynn 6y agoFour pilots in two different aircraft plus the radar operators all confused in the same way. What are the odds of that ?
- eitland 6y ago> What are the odds of that ? Not good. My best alternative explanations is: top secret research project going out of their way to fool everyone, possibly with the help of a few pilots and radar operators :-)
- prudhvis 6y agoSure. Let's assume that there are top secret research programs. What this tells us is that the research had yeilded such results as * Super High Density energy storage mechanism, that when being used actually cools down instead of heating up * An energy source that isn't based around burning fossil fuels for propulsion, that is highly efficient. * A device that could atleast in theory be using some kind of an inertial cancellation mechanism. Any of this could be a solution to climate change. Why would our own governments lie and put the future of this planet in jeapordy?. Just so they can win the next war but lose a Future?. The idea that this is some kind of a secret research project doesn't add up.
- ansible 6y agoI did used to entertain the idea of aliens visiting this solar system. And then I better understood the stupendous energy requirements for a two-way trip to even the very closest neighboring solar system. And it is just not practical, even for a civilization at the end of the technology development tree. We might see one-way probes, but they are as likely to be a part of hegemonizing swarm, looking to convert all usable matter in the solar system into computronium. Certainly they're not going to just faff around, kidnap a few people and then leave quietly. When aliens visit, everyone will know. Luckily, we haven't seen any evidence of Kardashev type-2 civilizations nearby, so we may be good for a while. Though that's also sort of depressing, as it is weak evidence that life is not too common across the galaxy.
- jordwest 6y ago> even for a civilization at the end of the technology development tree. How do we know what the end of the technology development tree looks like? There are just so many mysteries that remain within our current understanding of science, we can’t say for sure that it’s not easy (for example) to bend space time or some other possibility that makes faster than light travel possible. Quantum entanglement, for example, breaks many of our assumptions about the impossibility of FTL travel. > When aliens visit, everyone will know. Maybe, but perhaps a civilisation that has survived the great filter would look differently at civilisations they stumble upon. Maybe, like we do when searching for microbes on Mars, they would try not to disturb the life they discover. This is all just speculation of course, but I think when looking at this topic it’s all too easy to apply a human centric view on what’s possible and what’s not, and the truth is we just know so very little. Or, we know a lot, but there are so many more mysteries than solved problems.
- dplavery92 6y agoWhile I would also not presume to know how different our understanding of the universe may look in hundreds (or thousands!) of years, I do draw some exception to the following comment: >Quantum entanglement, for example, breaks many of our assumptions about the impossibility of FTL travel. Quantum entanglement can produce correlated measurements between systems, even when the entangled systems are separated by large distances. In a sense, this can be used to measure the state of an entangled system at great displacement "faster" than it would take light to travel from that distant system to the observer. However, the state of the entangled systems is prepared before the systems are separated from one another (at much less than the speed of light.) Any attempt to change the state of one of the entangled systems (at a distance) breaks the entanglement. Entanglement cannot be used to communicate information from one point to another faster than the speed of light. It certainly doesn't allow FTL transfer of matter/energy.
- maxharris 6y agoWhy ignore the Navy's official videos? Why lump that in with obvious nonsense?
- SiempreViernes 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PLyEO0jNt6M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PLyEO0jNt6M
- maxharris 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HInaJxFxWs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HInaJxFxWs
- thoughtsimple 6y agoDavid Fravor is the most credible eyewitness to a UFO that I’ve ever heard. There is no reason that I can come up with why anyone listening to his account should doubt what he saw. The interview is long but the whole thing is worth a listen. I challenge anyone to listen to the whole thing and then deny something odd was happening in the Pacific.
- istorical 6y agoThe problem with using Mick West's possible explanation for these videos is that it doesn't address the other tools that were used to track these UAPs. Let's say we believe with confidence that this debunking is correct and that these videos show a bird or balloon or some explainable phenomena. The next step is to look at the eyewitness testimony and reports from the people involved in this case - several Navy fighter pilots including a commanding officer of a squadron of aircraft onboard the Nimitz - and decide if we think the likely outcome is that they 1) did see radio signatures of these 'birds or balloons' moving at speeds beyond what is possible according to our understanding of physics, 2) were they collectively deluded or mistaken or misled by software bug across multiple technologies (radar including the AEGIS radar of an American aircraft carrier fleet), or 3) were they all lying. I don't think any of the debunking address the possibilities of these witness testimonies, only the video that we do have. Which sort of makes sense in that we only _can_ address the physical evidence that is in front of us as members of the public, but shouldn't we at least acknowledge it seems somewhat unlikely that several members of the Navy with thousands of hours of training onboard both fighter jets and also in the radar rooms of Destroyers all collectively believed they were seeing physically impossible maneuvers by multiple targets, or that these tracking systems are that unreliable, or that they all collectively decided to lie about these videos and make up a story? Dismissing a video as showing a bird or balloon subject to parallax is great, but those explanations fall down if we choose to believe the report that they had radar tracking these objects at impossible velocities. Perhaps the lying is the most logical possibility if this is a planned piece of government disinformation / muddying of the waters around technology or UFO/UAPs for some strategic reason, but let's at least discuss the topic before saying 'it was a bird or balloon, slam dunk, case-closed'.
- rainworld 6y agoSo many words, so much time, so many lives wasted on what is largely a massive, decades-long, ongoing psychological warfare operation conducted by several elements of the US government. Against their own population. Why would they do that? Beats me. Start here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirage_Men https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirage_Men
- cletus 6y agoThe psychological predilection for belief in conspiracy theories is depressing. It's depressing because to me it feels like the other side of the coin for religious devotees. It seems to be seated in a deep need for a higher purpose and meaning. When I was a kid I found all the talk of UFOs interesting. I had a fascination with space (and still do) and wanted to believe in that future. What changed is in more recent years I inadvertently approached the problem from the other direction. By that I mean you look at what mankind's future is likely to be like which can be extrapolated to the future other other spacefaring civilizations and the implications of that on the Fermi Paradox. It's a deep topic but basically the obvious energy future is to use all the Sun's energy output (rather than <1 billionth) and it's essentially just an engineering problem (albeit a massive one) to collect and use that power. And that future is a Dyson swarm. And those aren't the least bit subtle. There are two parts I like about this: 1. It is based on the current understanding of physics. No magic tech or negative mass is required. If FTL is possible (and I include wormholes under FTL) or if breaking thermodynamics is possible we should be seeing a ton more not less of these things; and 2. The beauty of a lot of thought experiments with the Fermi Paradox is we don't need to decide what civilizations will do on average. Instead, if any one civilization doesn't fit that mold the whole argument falls apart. The more civilizations there are the less likely that counterargument becomes. So with regards to UFOs, there are two common explanations among devotees: 1. Aliens and alien technology; or 2. Advanced technology governments are hiding. In a world where the speed of light is a universal speed limit, (1) just becomes preposterous. The idea that someone would spend thousands of years getting here, hiding their presence and cooperating with governments just defies logic. As for advanced technology... in 1947? Really? I just don't believe people are capable of that AND keeping it secret for decades. Of course people will say they haven't kept it secret and disinformation has made us all not believe it. This fascination with UFOs just seems so... pointless.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoEverything you have written is terrestrial speculation based on the same mistaken assumption - that human intelligence is as smart as it gets. If aliens exist they will be alien. They will not be a bit weird with our naive ideas of sort-of-better alien tech. They will be something entirely different, and very likely able to do entirely unexpected things. Imagine a species which has roughly the same intelligence advantage over humans as humans have over cats. Most of what humans spend their time doing today is incomprehensible to cats. Virtually all of math, physics, the Internet, the arts, philosophy is far beyond the imagination of an animal which hasn't evolved past a need to find food, sex, and occasional snuggles. Now imagine a species which stretches the comparison to human-vs-ant. Not only are humans activities unimaginable, they're invisible. Even though ants live in the middle of them. Ant perception is tuned to pheromone trails, foraging, and occasional ant wars, and ants don't have much of a concept of freeways, telecommuting, corner supermarkets, house renovation projects, or Amazon Prime - even though they may be surrounded by them. Not only do ants not understand them, they cannot see them, except for those rare occasions where ants become a nuisance and a human decides to wipe them out. It's irrational and naive to assume that we are the most evolved of all possible intelligences in a universe which is as big as this one is, and whose operation we really don't understand. We could be well surrounded by alien activities which are far outside our conceptual grasp - except for those occasions when the aliens take a passing interest, with strange and incomprehensible consequences.
- jordwest 6y agoIt’s unfortunate that this topic has such stigma around it that many researchers are afraid to study it for fear it’ll delegitimise them or ruin their career. You may be surprised at how many people you know have had experiences of their own, or know someone close who has, but don’t talk about it for fear of judgement. For all the hundreds of thousands of anecdotal reports that exist, and documented cases involving hundreds of witnesses, there is so little research into the phenomenon. Most of it is dismissed as mass hysteria, rather than investigated to determine if that assumption is true. That said, it’s not exactly a phenomenon that can easily be studied - the results are not repeatable. As Carl Sagan said, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. I think we need to stop calling it a conspiracy theory, and instead call it just a theory. Remember there was a time when it was considered a conspiracy to say the the earth revolves around the sun.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y ago> As Carl Sagan said, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. After seeing the declassified Navy videos [0] I'm not sure how much more extraordinary evidence we can get. [0] https://www.cnbc.com/2020/04/28/pentagon-declassifies-ufo-videos-taken-by-navy-pilots.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/04/28/pentagon-declassifies-ufo-vi...
- postalrat 6y agoI don't think the videos really show much. To me the real evidence is the public testimony of the 4 pilots and others.
- jordwest 6y agoAbsolutely, David Fravor’s (the pilot who actually chased the thing) interview with Joe Rogan[1] was one of the most compelling eyewitness accounts I’ve seen, and with that the associated video has a lot more context. If these things really do behave in the way he’s described, ET or not it suggests a fundamental leap in technology - it baffles me that there isn’t more interest. [1] https://youtu.be/Eco2s3-0zsQ https://youtu.be/Eco2s3-0zsQ
- nibbleshift 6y agoSky Hub has developed an observational platform UFOs and UAPs. It's a group of engineers and scientists that are approaching subject skeptically. They are data and evidence focused non-profit organization. You can check it out at https://skyhub.org https://skyhub.org
- im3w1l 6y agoSeems pretty obvious to me what's going on. These "UFOs" must have been caught on camera by spy satellites. The reason they don't tell us about it is because it's miltech experiments. Tales about them doing things way beyond the capabilities of human technology are either (1) someone being mistaken because the visibility is poor or they are on drugs or whatever. (2) Exaggerations for a good story. Or (3) disinfo to scare the Russians.