3 ms·
> Every country on Earth could outlaw the technology and it would still be trivially easy for criminals to use it Trivially easy but probably in practice too m
by helsinkiandrew 6y ago
> Every country on Earth could outlaw the technology and it would still be trivially easy for criminals to use it
Trivially easy but probably in practice too much of a bother. I imagine most traffic isn't between well trained members of international terrorist or crime organisations planning major heists, but people who are friends, family members and acquaintances.
They're already using WhatsApp to talk with other friends about every day things so start planning and revealing criminal behaviour accidentally without taking the trouble to move to another platform.
- m12k 6y agoThe thing is, by building backdoors into the widely used platforms, we gain maybe 10 years of arresting idiot criminals until they learn to use Signal, the same way they learned to use burner phones, but at the same time throw everybody's privacy out the window while opening a huge security hole in our infrastructure. It's just not a good trade-off, not even from a pragmatic, non-idealist perspective.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoA lot of crime is opportunistic. If people feel they are more likely to get caught then much of it will just go away.
- jchw 6y agoThis claim is weird. “A lot” — well wait, how much is a lot? I tried to look, but a couple cursory searches yielded little in the way of attempts to quantify the amount of “opportunistic crime” versus premeditated. And frankly, going by raw quantity might not be good enough. How much damage are they doing relative to premeditated crime? Shoplifting a candy bar versus a murder, you know. I also wonder if this has much to do with this article. If you are conversing about future criminal activity on Facebook or SMS, can you argue it was not premeditated in some fashion? And even if this makes sense... how much loss of our personal freedoms is it worth to eliminate xx% of crime? (And, is it possible that there are better ways, like perhaps looking at the causes rather than trying to curb the effects...)
- foolmeonce 6y agoSo the goal is to make sure crime is left to true professionals who think big, the kind who will bribe cops honestly, if they aren't already in the tier above with the CIA anyway? We can really get the visible crime off the streets, or at least get thrown a bone every once in a while to look like we are policing despite the bulk of crime being done by our network of police state associates.. Who is going to explain how this works to Tony?