4 ms·
> That's not the job of a university. If the university expects to produce graduate students, who use computers to solve research problems, teaching them how t
by vkou 6y ago
> That's not the job of a university.
If the university expects to produce graduate students, who use computers to solve research problems, teaching them how to code well helps.
> A reasonably smart student picks up how to work git in a few evenings with some online tutorial and some open source project. Or just when doing their homework.
The same can be said for writing comprehensible English, yet you will lose marks on your essays for poor writing.
- bonoboTP 6y agoWhat CS university programs make you write essays?
- vkou 6y agoOnes offered by legitimate universities, that require bachelors to take ~12-18 credit hours of liberal arts courses. Those courses typically require you to submit essays, which will be evaluated for both their form, and their function. Given the generally poor grasp of civics, ethics, and ability to relate to other cultures that I have seen, if the job of a university is the creation of educated people (as opposed to vocational training), more liberal arts education can't go that amiss. You're also missing the main thrust of my argument. My university offered - and required - CS majors to take a number of practical, vocational courses, with many programming assignments. But it never actually took the time to train, or grade us on the quality of our solutions to those assignments. This is not how real engineers, chemists, or physicists, or folks studying bioscience get trained.
- bonoboTP 6y ago> Ones offered by legitimate universities, that require bachelors to take ~12-18 credit hours of liberal arts courses. I see. That's rather a peculiarity of the American system, in Europe, higher ed is more specialized and broad, general liberal arts education ends at the high school level. > But it never actually took the time to train, or grade us on the quality of our solutions to those assignments. I've worked as a teaching assistant, and it's often due to a lack of staffing and time. TA's are most of the time also PhD students and they have projects to work on and papers to write and giving detailed feedback on assignments is infeasible beyond a certain number of submissions. The same with exams. They are optimized to be easy to unambiguously grade in the shortest time possible. There's a conflict between two roles of the university: research and teaching. Research is more important for one's advancement, so teaching gets neglected.