6 ms·
The Three Sides of Risk
- stblack 6y agoThe latest on this is “Statistical Consequences of Fat Tails: Real World Preasymptotics, Epistemology, and Applications” by Nassim Taleb. I liked this PDF so much I bought the book. https://arxiv.org/abs/2001.10488 https://arxiv.org/abs/2001.10488
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- asimjalis 6y agoA bit long-winded.
- ghostlap 6y agoNice read! Morgan always has unique insights. I enjoyed his book.
- ram_rar 6y agoTLDR The article talks about 3 types of risk 1. The odds you will get hit. 2. The average consequences of getting hit. 3. The tail-end consequences of getting hit. It claims that tail-end consequences which are low probability , high impact events like coronavirus pandemics are all that matter. One thing, I learnt from insurance industry is that a lot of people underestimate the odds of getting hit. We are inherently reactive creatures and not proactive.
- elyobo 6y agoI'm largely uninsured. * I insure my car, because I'm not a good driver - I don't generally drive though, and would prefer to go without, but my wife wants one even though it would be cheaper to Uber everywhere that we actually travel. * I own an apartment, and building corp levies include insurance on the building (but don't insure contents). This is an insurance I would keep even if it wasn't mandatory; the tail risk is too expensive for me to recover from. * I have health insurance (in Australia, where the public health system is good) only for tax reasons (it would cost me almost as much _not_ to have insurance). Public health system is sufficient that this would not generally be required. I should probably insure more (life, income protection, probably home contents, maybe but probably not actually useful health insurance).
- mrslave 6y agoRecommended 5 minute read unless you, like the author, spent most of your childhood skiing. It's clear writing style and unusual setting made it worthwhile for me. It's not sufficient only to consider the probability of a (binary) outcome. What's the severity? I did some serious camping as a teenager and despite being mere children, we were cognizant of the consequences of not paying attention as several other teenagers had previously died doing some of the same activities.
- cjonas 6y ago(semi-related) High risk activities like backcountry skiing and climbing do "teach" skills that are very transferable to software PM and change governance. Risk tolerance is one of such skills. Too much effort is often put into preventing low cost issues and scolding those who make them. Beyond hurting morale, it reduces efficiency and innovation because everyone is afraid to make even a trivial mistake. What I'm trying to say is... "Move fast and break shit! ...But maybe not that shit over there because it's actually quite critical"
- andi999 6y agoThinking about deepwater horizon, Teflon Tony and their safety culture?
- jm__87 6y agoI work in capital markets. I both design and build systems that automatically quote prices to the market and automatically make trading decisions. The financial consequences of getting either of these things wrong can be quite high, but many of my colleagues (i.e. traders) don't seem to understand the scope of things that could possibly go wrong when you're building software. I have noticed that experienced traders are usually very comfortable with taking some amount of risk (it's their job), but I have also noticed that with some people, that comfort with risk taking can spill over in to other areas where they simply don't have enough background or knowledge to properly assess the risks. So while I think comfort with risk taking is good, it's important to also question your own depth of understanding of the domain you're assessing risk in before dismissing other's concerns.
- cjonas 6y agoThis is also analogous to backcountry skiing/climbing risk management. Many expert climbers have died because they became too comfortable with the risks and make a novice mistake. And "considerable" Avalanche conditions result in far more deaths and "high" or "extreme", because they offer just enough stability to allow skiers to build a false sense of security. My point is just that professionals of these activities have developed frameworks for evaluating risk and I think it's interesting how they might be applied to other disaplines.
- 082349872349872 6y ago(a) the double-digit unemployment in the US was not an inescapable consequence of the virus. We had a lockdown for our first wave, and our news was full of worry that we might reach 4% unemployment[1]. (b) en.wikipedia says that "freshwater economists" are called that because they were associated with the Chicago school[2], on the great lakes. A second connotation, for sailors, is that a freshwater sailor will run risks that a salt water sailor will explicitly incur many costs to avoid, precisely because the tail-end is not as serious within rescue distance of shore. (for more nautical metaphor, compare brown-water navy vs blue-water navy) [1] currently back down to 3,2% https://www.arbeit.swiss/dam/secoalv/de/dokumente/publikationen/amstat/2020/die_lage_auf_dem_arbeitsmarkt_im_september_2020.pdf.download.pdf/PRESSEDOK2009_D.pdf https://www.arbeit.swiss/dam/secoalv/de/dokumente/publikatio... (In the 90s it was briefly even above 5%.) [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saltwater_and_freshwater_economics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saltwater_and_freshwater_econo... Bonus clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9JcNWaMXTc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9JcNWaMXTc To mebi du amalof da belek; da belek fosho na du amalof to. (You may love space; space does not love you.)
- andi999 6y agoThats a great explanation. I always though freshwater sailor was just an insult.
- gumby 6y agoA few years ago, the state of California put out a video about avalanches. They interviewed a bunch of experienced backcountry (out of bounds) skiers and the various tricks you'd learn for avoiding dying in avalanches. Most of them had been caught in avalanches and described a complete loss of ability to do anything. At the end of the video they list all of the interviewees, all of whom had subsequently died. If you think about the amount of mass in the snow 9+ rocks, trees etc) and the churning dynamics you realize all those "techniques" you might learn are mumbo jumbo. We show this video to our students (it's so old it's on a DVD), while teaching them how to avoid likely avalanche zones in the first place. Despite that I still carry an avalanche pole and beacon.
- tankenmate 6y agoHave you ever used an Avalung (or similar)? Or rescued someone who has?
- gumby 6y agoNo and I wonder if you could really manage to use it when pinned by tons of snow.
- fallingfrog 6y agoIt’s worth pointing out that there are some events you can’t buy insurance against. You can buy insurance in case of a burst pipe but not a flood. You can’t buy insurance that will pay out if there’s a nuclear war. You can’t buy insurance that will pay out in case of climate change. The damage is too big, and affects too many people at the same time. Some tail risks are fatal, existential, and the only recourse is not to take the risk at all.
- notduncansmith 6y ago> You can’t buy insurance that will pay out if there’s a nuclear war. While you can’t get this kind of insurance from most brokers, you can certainly make investments that will pay off in the case of a nuclear war (e.g. aerial defense, subterranean shelters, etc). The entire military-industrial complex is built around selling this kind of insurance.
- spacedcowboy 6y agoThe author identifies 3 things - the chances of X happening, the consequences of X happening, and the long-term effects of X happening. Personally I don’t separate (2) and (3). If X involves you breaking your spine, then long term consequences are indicated, to my view... But I’ve been saying for decades that “risk” is not the chances of something happening, which is how most people understand it. Risk is (the chance of something happening) x (the consequences of it happening). Imagine a 2x4 beam, 24’ long, lying on the floor, and I tell you to walk along the top of it without touching the floor. If you do, I’ll give you a sherbet lemon. Now imagine it’s a 2x4, 24’ long between two office buildings, the one you’re in is on fire and this is the only way out. The chances of you falling off the beam are the same (within a margin of error, assuming a non-windy day, etc. etc), but the risk to your life is much much higher in the second case. Risk encompasses consequence, and it always surprises me how few people understand that in meetings when I’m describing a new approach, or criticizing a new service conformation.
- jm__87 6y agoI interpreted the bullet point about "tail-end consequences" as tail risk, i.e. a worst case scenario event with low likelihood of occurring. In the author's story, he mentions they only considered the likely consequences of skiing out of bounds: getting caught and getting in trouble with their coaches. They never considered the worst case scenario of dying in an avalanche.
- spacedcowboy 6y agoI guess what I'm saying is I think it's a distinction without a difference. It's a consequence - subdividing into "likely consequence" and "oh,shit! consequence" seems artificial. All that means is that you haven't properly understood the risk, IMHO :)
- jm__87 6y agoI honestly have no idea what you're talking about. Agree to disagree :) Edit: actually I went back and read your comment again and I misread the second part of your comment to indicate that I didn't understand something. I get what you mean, but I think tail risk can get ignored a bit more when you're quantifying risk, because it is very difficult to quantify.
- gherkinnn 6y agoGreat read, and a story that hit close to home. Speaking of avalanches and covid, they share an interesting property: You don’t know how close you are to a catastrophe until it’s too late. It’s fine until it’s not. And in many cases you’re proper fucked. There’s very little in between. Until that moment, many people see any precautions as unnecessary, boring, patronising, paranoid, and so on. Be that because they are reckless, clueless, or both. And once people do die, everybody is up in arms about the authorities not doing anything, the victims being at fault, why didn’t we do intervene, it would have been so easy. And so on. There has to be a name for auch a thing. So as someone who knows about avalanches, it is frustrating to see careless attitudes towards covid.