3 ms·
1) 192kHz is almost entirely snake oil. It uses 4x the CPU cycles and 4x the storage capacity for no measurable difference when it comes to human hearing. 2) 9
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
1) 192kHz is almost entirely snake oil. It uses 4x the CPU cycles and 4x the storage capacity for no measurable difference when it comes to human hearing.
2) 96kHz vs 48kHz does allow for some small but probably worthwhile improvement in the behavior of the anti-aliasing filters used in the analog->digital converters.
3) I have a theory that has been shot down by some highly respected DSP people but I retain it nevertheless. In Ye Olde Analogue domain, most of the distortion that occurs will be somehow related to harmonics, because of the nature of the analog electrical signal and the components it passes through. In the New Digital Goodness, there's no inherent reason why any of the distortion will be fundamentally harmonic. Consequently, if either type of signal pathway introduces any distortion at all, the analog one will tend to be "musical" because of the harmonic aspects at its core, whereas the digital one will be something else.
I'm not arguing about the amount of distortion etc. Anybody who knows anything about this stuff knows that Ye Olde Analogue pathways were full of distortion, but that either we grew to love it or it was just inherently musical enough that we loved it from the beginning. The sound of that old analog gear you love? Yes, that's right, you love the distortion it adds.
- Gibbon1 6y agoOn your third point. I remember a very good article on control theory which had a hard and often missed point. Which is digital sampling creates far more noise in the phase domain than the amplitude one. For control loops this is important because stability depends on phase. The upshot is you need a higher sampling rate than you would naively think. Bob Pease also had some articles on audio. I think he would agree that open loop analog circuits often produce harmonics that people like. And digital and feedback controlled ones tend to produce harmonics people HATE.
- aidenn0 6y agoStability depends on phase being less than 180°. No way does digital sampling introduce even a tiny fraction of that.
- Gibbon1 6y agoThe thing is feedback control systems have specs that fall apart well before the loop becomes grossly unstable. Phase noise due to sampling pushes you closer to that than you would think. Which explains the need for somewhat higher sampling rates.
- aidenn0 6y agoSampling doesn't really introduce significant phase noise though. A single analog filter will introduce frequency-dependent phase shift and that will dominate any tiny phase noise that might happen from sampling.