2 ms·
The lasting value in the Chinese room thought experiment is making argument explicit. It helps to clarify the problem. Searle makes two conclusions. 1) comput
by nabla9 6y ago
The lasting value in the Chinese room thought experiment is making argument explicit. It helps to clarify the problem. Searle makes two conclusions. 1) computers have no understanding of meaning or semantics and 2) human minds are not computational information processing systems.
Most modern criticism of these two conclusions point out that Seale's argument relies on strong intuition about what understanding and meaning means and he can't clarify them satisfactorily.
Chinese room being conscious is counter-intuitive. Today most philosophers of consciousness are more aware how easy it is to make 'slips in reasoning' when dealing with the counter-intuitiveness of the consciousness arguments.
- rvense 6y agoAh, well, yes, the C-word is pre-scientific term and those are always hard to deal with. But I think "understanding natural language" is one of the easier ones, at least inasmuch as we can resort to referring to the intentions of the speaker, and understanding being the congruence between that and the hearer's impression of it. And it just seems like a category error to say that any natural language processing system has anything like that, since the thing doing the understanding is so radically different to the one doing the speaking.
- nabla9 6y ago> any natural language processing system has anything like that Chinese room that can respond verbally can incorporate more than natural language model. It can have spatiotemporal understanding as well or any other model that can be represented in Turing machine.