I don't see how other sites play a role in this. Only counting posts with 10+ posts does not guarantee that the baseline is the same for the two groups. You se

I don't see how other sites play a role in this. Only counting posts with 10+ posts does not guarantee that the baseline is the same for the two groups. You seem to imply that the number of posts that reach over 10 points means they reach the frontpage and that the number of posts that reach the frontpage is always the same during two time periods of the same length. But I don't see how either of these two assumptions has to be true. The problem with the "19% vs 40%" comparison is that it does not compare the same thing. According to this article: 19% is the increase in total posts 40% is the increase after posts with less then 10 votes have been removed AND posts without the negative keywords have been removed. This comparison is not the right one. Either posts with less then 10 votes need to be subtracted from both groups or from none of them.