The typical argument against pragma once is that it's unclear what should happen if two different hard link paths are used to include a file with the same inode

The typical argument against pragma once is that it's unclear what should happen if two different hard link paths are used to include a file with the same inode (along with similar situations on Windows or with files on network drives). That is to say, in general, there is no consistent and portable "true" absolute path that uniquely identifies file(s) as conceptually having the same underlying storage. In practice, I have never actually seen a problem arise. The most likely real trigger would probably be a mix of including a library through a path that indicates a specific version and including it through a path that uses a "latest stable" link. That is already fragile and asking for trouble, though.