5 ms·
Not to take away from any conservation efforts to reduce or reverse these extinctions, but: is cloning a viable replacement strategy? Is it conceivable that in
by keiferski 6y ago
Not to take away from any conservation efforts to reduce or reverse these extinctions, but: is cloning a viable replacement strategy? Is it conceivable that in 100-200 years, cloning and re-introducing an extinct species will be fairly affordable (on a small scale)?
Judging from this article on Wikipedia, work is underway in this field, although it hasn't been too fruitful yet.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cloning#Cloning_extinct_and_endangered_species https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cloning#Cloning_extinct_and_en...
- pvaldes 6y agoI don't thing that cloning would be our best bet. And would be really expensive making it impractical. Specially with those huge animals. Would need incredibly complex and humongous laboratories just for trying to hold each 3000 Kg newborn. Avoiding contamination and making the embryo cameras sterile for months would be a real headache. We must forget the idea that cloning will save the day someday, be smart and use our narrow and shrinking interval of opportunity to act now.
- Santosh83 6y agoHabitats are very complex interrelationships. Even IF cloning brings them back in future, we won't have their natural habitats and niches. It's like saving the threads but not knowing how to sew them back together into a garment. That's why habitat protection is non-negotiable if we want to save Earth's biodiversity.
- faitswulff 6y agoIt’s not just the habitats that are complex, either. Intelligent mammals like whales and elephants, orcas and dolphins, actually have their own culture as well, and by culture I mean survival specific knowledge passed down between generations. Simply cloning one of these animals and dumping it into the ocean reminds me of seal conservation efforts where seals were rehabilitated and then basically dumped into the ocean and swiftly eaten by orcas. A naïve approach is unlikely to work.
- bamboozled 6y agoWhat is the point, the whales are here today, we are destroying them and their entire habitat, Why would we clone them in 100 years ? We don’t care for the whales we have now.
- keiferski 6y agoAs I said, > Not to take away from any conservation efforts to reduce or reverse these extinctions, Presumably one reason the loss of species is bad because it lessens biodiversity. If extinct species could be re-introduced in a more amenable future, then that would be a good thing, no?
- Gravityloss 6y agoWhat amenable future? I guess a thousand years from now?
- keiferski 6y agoCertainly not that far ahead. Widespread green energy and space travel is probably 200-300 years away. Even then, on a human timeline a thousand years is nothing. We still have buildings that are 3x as old.
- pantalaimon 6y agoOnly if we can avert the collapse of the ecosystem and with it civilization.
- ant6n 6y agoWhat is „green energy and space travel“? Some sort of greenwashing spin on rocketry, one of the most energy intensive ways to travel?
- pilot_project 6y agoAnimals are not automatons. They socialize, depend on each other, and teach each other. They all have means of communicating. Essentially, they have cultures. If you were to introduce cloned animals into the wild after natural ones had died, there would be no other animals of their kind who could teach them how to do various things necessary to their survival, or teach them how to communicate. Moreover, there is no guarantee that any future environment would be more amenable. For most animals, we would have no idea what that meant, no way to measure it.
- idiocratic 6y agoEven if cloning was an option, extinction is just a side effect of habitat erosion. Without habitat, there's no place where those species, even when cloned, could thrive.
- bserge 6y agoIt's about as viable as moving to Mars once we're done destroying Earth. A plan like Swiss cheese - full of holes.
- perfunctory 6y ago> Is it conceivable that in 100-200 years Pushing solutions into the future is exactly why we ended up with this mess in the first place. Similarly, governments right now are competing with each other who declares the most ambitious climate plan to be realised by 2050, instead of doing something right now.