5 ms·
Griefing? Belarus is on the brink of civil war. Doxxing regime supporters can easily end up as a "murder todo list" if things heat up. https://en.wikipedia.o
by BurningFrog 6y ago
Griefing?
Belarus is on the brink of civil war.
Doxxing regime supporters can easily end up as a "murder todo list" if things heat up.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Griefing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Griefing
- random5634 6y agoAnd visa versa - mainstream platforms don't seem like the place too do this
- baybal2 6y ago> Doxxing regime supporters can easily end up as a "murder todo list" if things heat up. Do you give an innuendo that this is somehow wrong?
- metiscus 6y agoYes. Murdering people that you disagree politically with is wrong. Even the actual nazis were allowed to surrender and stand trial. Vigilantism is nearly always a bad thing.
- 188201 6y agoWho can put Nazi on trial? The people in Germany? History said it was the ally. And ally has killed many Nazi before they can put Nazi on trial. If you don't see the power imbalance between the government and the people, then you are very lucky that you had not experienced it. Not trying to justify murdering, but some kind of deterrence for oppressing peaceful, freedom-loving people is not a bad thing. Of course if it become French Revolution style execution after taking power, that is wrong and it must be stopped. For the moment, that is before that state, so anything can be bearable.
- jlokier 6y agoI would advocate that these things are clearly wrong and should be defended against: - Killing a "regime supporter", meaning someone targeted only because of their political beliefs. It is not right that political beliefs should be punished like that. Ideally they shouldn't be punished at all, they should be tolerated but simply lose an election. You can't claim to "protest for democracy" while being happy to facilitate murdering people who vote for the other side! That would be mad hypocrisy. - Killing a police officer whose crime, even if violent, fell significantly short of killing someone themselves. Punishment should fit the crime, not be 10x worse. You can't claim to "protest for justice" while being happy to facilitate extra-judicial killings that aren't even based in justice. - Killing an innocent person who is mis-identified, whether by accident or not so much. See above. The third point, killing an innocent person seems even more likely due to automated facial recognition software like what's running on Facebook, with its biases and a mask to add more noise too, integrated with deepfake image reconstruction technology to produce convincing "unmasked" images, combined with vigilantes often not being too bothered about accuracy and statistics. However wrong or right you think it is, surely everyone agrees it's wrong if it ends up getting the wrong people. But no apparently. I've spoken with people in other situations (at other times) who said, basically, it's ok for "a few innocents" to die if that's what it takes to rid the world of guilty people. And others taking the view that it's ok for "police" to die because police are bad. Both views strike me as boneheaded AF. It is clear AF from the reports that the Belarus authorities think it's ok for some number of innocents to die and suffer for the sake of policing and intimidation. If I were there I would certainly want the authority to "die", by being thoroughly dismantled asap.
- spacemanmatt 6y agoThat's kiiiiiiinda the point
- extropy 6y agoMaybe the guys should have thought about that before they started attacking peaceful protesters. This is just one tool, and there will be killing with or without it.
- vorpalhex 6y agoI'm sure a bit of murdering will totally cool things down and peacefully resolve things, with no innocent deaths or casualties. As we all know, vigilantes never make mistakes.
- ddingus 6y agoDoesn't this go right back to thinking things through before attacking people people? Right or wrong, when people are abused repeatedly, and or they cease to believe in governance, they will act out and it won't all be nice. The root cause here is an authoritarian regime failing to justify their authority. People acting out is a symptom.
- jlokier 6y ago> People acting out is a symptom. Yes, but the discussion here is about whether Apple should facilitate or hinder particular kinds of act by people. That's not a symptom for Apple, that's a dilemma for Apple, and there is no truly neutral option.
- ddingus 6y agoYes, and I spoke to that in the thread. This comment was in reference to violent and or just not so nice political action. Regarding apple... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24741156 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24741156
- andrepd 6y agoViolence is sometimes the only way forward, though. It should be the way of last resort, but a way nevertheless. That's why we have democracy: so we can remove the people in power by ballot instead of by guillotine. When the former avenue is blocked, violence is all that remains...
- fsflover 6y agoKnowing who breaks the law and applies violence to civil protesters will allow to have a fair trial later.