6 ms·
Please stop worshipping this company. It's not a force for good. They've kicked us out of open computing by locking down the only computer a lot of folks own (
by echelon 6y ago
Please stop worshipping this company. It's not a force for good.
They've kicked us out of open computing by locking down the only computer a lot of folks own (iPhone). And now look what kind of shit they can pull because they own the entire stack! This shouldn't be possible!
We really have to push against this and hope the DOJ forces all phone providers to allow "side-loading" (what a bizarre term!)
The iPhone is a computer, not some gaming console. It has to be free for freedom. You should be able to install straight off the web.
And before you downvote me, please look again how much Apple gives a damn about democracy in the world. And look what it's doing because of its power. Double plus ungood.
It's an American device. It should act like it!
- RealStickman_ 6y ago> It's an American device. It should act like it! I don't think what the USA is doing is something that should be followed. See anything privacy endangering in the US. That's a really random nitpick though and I get what you meant.
- ketamine__ 6y agoTim Cook is not a good person. Source: The people he engages with as he attempts to increase Apple's market cap. https://vid.alarabiya.net/images/2018/04/07/6f86bd65-aefa-4ada-a251-1905b9000a44/6f86bd65-aefa-4ada-a251-1905b9000a44.jpg https://vid.alarabiya.net/images/2018/04/07/6f86bd65-aefa-4a...
- aero-glide 6y agoIs that MBS? Never seen him without the headdress
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- y04nn 6y agoContext of this photo: https://appleinsider.com/articles/18/04/08/saudi-prince-meets-tim-cook-at-apple-park-to-talk-app-development-education https://appleinsider.com/articles/18/04/08/saudi-prince-meet...
- skohan 6y agoIt's a shame that anti-trust enforcement has been so effectively neutered in the US. This is exactly the type of thing it's designed to protect us from. But I think with the current high bar for anti-trust, it can be argued that Apple is "hurting consumers" through the lock-down of their platform. It's fine that Apple should offer a safe, curated experience of using their devices through the App Store. I'm even fine with the App Store having some OS-level integrations which would not be available to 3rd parties. But the App Store should have to compete on its own merits for how it delivers value to the customer - it should not be the only option by fiat. Maybe at the beginning, but not when smartphones are the dominant computing platform and the main way people use software on a daily basis. The 30% cut which Apple requires is simply not justified for how much value Apple offers to businesses which drive revenue through the App Store. Again, maybe at the beginning, but the App Store no longer offers any meaningful benefit in terms of discoverability. Losing almost 1/3 of revenue out of the gate can make the difference between viability and not for a lot of companies at the margins, meaning this policy costs the user access to all those products which might be able to exist were it not for the "apple tax". Even under the current legal framework, I just don't see how it's justified.
- eru 6y ago> Even under the current legal framework, I just don't see how it's justified. In general, prices don't need a legal justification. That's a big part of free enterprise. > This is exactly the type of thing it's designed to protect us from. What makes you so optimistic? In practice, complicated laws with lots of reach usually work in favour of the party that can afford more and better lawyers. (Or, sometimes, the party that is winning the PR battle for the hearts and minds of public opinion.)
- skohan 6y ago> In general, prices don't need a legal justification. That's a big part of free enterprise. Well it would need a legal justification if the alternative is that Apple would be penalized under anti-trust regulation for using its market share to hurt consumers for its own benefit. Even "free enterprise" operates within a legal framework. > In practice, complicated laws with lots of reach usually work in favour of the party that can afford more and better lawyers. I mean this is an incredibly defeatist and cynical view. Don't get me wrong, I'm not overly optimistic that things will change based on the way laws have been applied in the last few decades, but the fact that people see laws as primarily a tool for the powerful - and don't even have an expectation for legal enforcement to operate on behalf of the consumer - seems to me to be a large part of the reason the US is looking more and more like a failed state.
- laumars 6y agoIsn’t a games console also a computer? > It's an American device. It should act like it! I’m guessing you’re speaking about the “freedom” meme but there’s nothing uniquely American about freedom. If anything, capitalism tends to trump “freedom” and any pressures to equal the balance (like government oversight) almost always gets heavily condemned. So from that regard, iPhones (and Apple in general) are very much American entities. Not that I have anything against iPhones (I have one myself) but this is “just business”, as they say.
- dividedbyzero 6y agoYes, don't worship any company or organisation, not Apple, not SpaceX, not Bell Labs, not the United States of America, none at all. Even if they do the right things now, future leadership may decide to do the opposite and lie about it, values may change, goals shift. Try to treat them as groups of strangers that change every few years, not as individuals with a personality that you somehow feel like you really really know. Still, free-as-in-freedom iPhones? Hell no! I give them money because they are not free-as-in-freedom, but provide a walled garden and defend it for me. I don't think I could do this myself; I know lots and lots of people absolutely certainly couldn't in the same way that I couldn't perform open-heart surgery. On iOS right now it's really, really hard to inadvertently give one's data, money or identity to any random app, and even for people who are not in the cohort that somehow always accumulates browser toolbars, the security measures by device/OS and browser vendors are the only thing that keeps them safe. This is an absolutely huge thing. If they break that, it'll wipe out their mobile products. I do wholeheartedly agree that they lock down too much and too hard. I get that it shouldn't be easy to side-load software, but making it utterly impossible is a bit too advanced-user-hostile. And this particular action of theirs is wayyy over any line one could draw, and I absolutely think their brand should suffer big time for this. But taking things to the other extreme – free as in freedom – I really don't see how that could end well. Give the big app vendors easy, convenient ways to bypass all restrictions and they'll make use of it, if only to make development cheaper, and then the small vendors and eventually the shady vendors will follow suit, and we're essentially back at the Windows 95 security model with some permission nag screens that no one really cares about anyway, and then everyone gets scammed and flocks to whatever vendor still has a properly secured walled garden. If there is a way to open things up completely while keeping the platform safe and usable for absolute laypeople, I haven't read or heard of it. Right now, I vastly prefer a locked-down but completely usable platform to some abstract notion of freedom.
- 411111111111111 6y agoNobody wants to remove all security policies etc from iOS. I'm not sure what gave you that idea in this thread. Requiring permissions from users to access data is good, and an actually well curated app store is just as useful. That doesn't mean that it shouldn't be possible to install through different avenues as well (still requiring the users permission). Yes you would get a lot of shitty software if you started installing everything you stumble upon, but the apple store quality would probably increased significantly, because they could deny significantly more apps, as they'd have an alternative approach to get to users that really want it
- cwhiz 6y agoIf you don’t like Apple... don’t buy their stuff? It’s that easy. Just go buy a phone running the market leading OS, Android.
- 1_player 6y agoNot so easy, there are arguments that the company behind the other OS is not a force of good either.
- mpol 6y agoThe market for smartphones is broken, period. You can choose for Apple, which is all about power politics like this news article is demonstrating, they are not here for you. Or you can choose for Android, which is one big privacy invading monster, they are not here for you either. It is a duopoly, which should (and probably does) fall under the same rules as a monopoly: the governments should fix this, the market cannot fix this. It is not possible for other parties to break this market open. Other parties are relegated to niche markets without any power. Using a smartphone from a niche party will give you a very reduced experience and is for most people not a viable option.
- fetbaffe 6y agoI can’t escape Apple even I would change to Android according to this decision done by Apple against Telegram.
- danielscrubs 6y agoTwo companies fighting for monopoly, one side saying the other side is worse instead of fixing the system, middle class getting squeezed. Sounds pretty American to me.
- esolyt 6y agoIsn't it sad? Running your own software on a computer you own has become this weird thing and there needs to be a specific term for it (side-loading).
- SergeAx 6y agoThe owner of the computer is an individual with root access to it. iPhone users doesn't own their computers, please stop calling them so.