3 ms·
We browsers are specifically excepted from the App Store rules on content. That’s basically because browser vendors don’t have a direct relationship with web si
by simonh 6y ago
We browsers are specifically excepted from the App Store rules on content. That’s basically because browser vendors don’t have a direct relationship with web site publishers, the way that a service provider like Facebook or Telegram has a relationship with their users that post content. That relationship creates a chain of responsibility.
- snoshy 6y agoThat may be, but it does not refute the accusation that this is a double standard.
- simonh 6y agoWell, yes it does. If you have signed up users with accounts, and you own the infrastructure for disseminating the content they produce, youre responsible for their posts and presence on your platform, and the content you are disseminating. None of that applies to web browsers, or IRC clients, or RSS feed clients, or podcast apps, or plenty of other client apps on the App Store.
- PureParadigm 6y agoIt's a double standard in that web browsers are not considered responsible for the content they display while chat apps are considered responsible. These are two different standards being applied just because of a technicality about whose servers the data is hosted on (whether app owner = server owner). Would Apple be okay with allowing a third-party front-end to the Telegram servers? Safari can be that if you use the web app version of Telegram.
- simonh 6y agoMessaging and content apps that are decoupled from distributed back end infrastructure are ok - IRC, Mastodon, email and there are many others. It’s a clear and consistent principle.
- robertlagrant 6y agoMaybe we need a chat protocol that does the same decoupling, then.
- iddqd 6y agoDo you think Apple would approve a client app to such a chat network?
- Sargos 6y agoIf web browsers weren't grandfathered in then they would definitely not be allowed on the App Store and the web probably wouldn't exist today.
- Const-me 6y agoDo they allow e-mail clients there?
- simonh 6y agoThey already do in the form of email clients, IRC clients, mastodon clients, etc, etc.
- yunruse 6y agoJust off the top of my head, Apple allows for apps supporting IRC, RSS and Mastodon protocols. The latter came about in 2016, when these topics were just as relevant as they are now. Adding another protocol doesn’t seem difficult.