3 ms·
>actually Orwellian phenomena This isn't an Orwellian phenomenon. This is just the typical bad reading of Orwell that Americans have tried to squeeze out of th
by Barrin92 6y ago
>actually Orwellian phenomena
This isn't an Orwellian phenomenon. This is just the typical bad reading of Orwell that Americans have tried to squeeze out of the book because of their free speech fetish.
The central key issue of the book isn't a big scary guy with a mustache stealing your newspaper, it's reality inversion, it's the inability of everyone in society to distinguish between what is real and what is fiction, which is the basis for, not the consequence of totalitarianism. It's the moment when someone blatantly tells a lie, and everyone eats it up, when the world starts to feel unreal and like a bad movie.
The real Orwellian phenomenon is not some kind of scary gatekeeper separating truth from fiction, which is actually a productive use of authority and necessary in any civilisation that doesn't want to turn into a clowncar. What's Orwellian is people going to Facebook, reading blatant lies and untruths, and being unable to distinguish that from what is real. And that is actually caused by the disappearance of gatekeepers, who play a vital role in maintaining liberal institutions.
- npunt 6y agoYeah freedom in America tends to favor 'freedom to' rather than 'freedom from'. Cutting these disinformation sources off gives us freedom from some amount of manipulation. Meanwhile, if we're more concerned with the freedom to say anything anywhere, whatever limits imposed will be perceived by default in a negative light. There's merit in examining from both perspectives for any given issue. However, if our objective is a better signal-to-noise ratio of truth in the context of slamming every human's stray thoughts, emotions, and urges into each other in realtime, the 'freedom from' perspective is probably a better approach right now.
- sthnblllII 6y agoSo you just want the thoughts emotions and urges of a tiny number of news editors slammed into my mind in real time. Ever wonder how the US was mobilized to war in 2003? Ever wonder why nothing happened to stop mass surveillance after the Snowden leaks despite massive public outrage? You make me sick.
- sthnblllII 6y agoFrom your most recent blog: > any individual's reputation, perspectives, and history are difficult to ascertain, and therefore their words must be taken at face value. Coupled with an almost complete lack of standards for participation in the community Let me translate that out of new-speak: "On the internet no one cares about my credentials (or is afraid of my power) so I must defend my positions on their own merits which I can't do, so we should ban people from the internet who express opinions I don't like." Would Hitler disagree?
- dang 6y agoI've asked you to stop posting ideological flamewar comments to HN
- zalkota 6y agoWho says that this information is bad untrue?
- sthnblllII 6y agoI am not threatened by obvious lies told by nut jobs. I do feel threatened by the lies (often by omission) told by the New York Times, the Washington post, CNN, Fox and every other gatekeeper often in coordination with intelligence agencies about the middle east, domestic corruption, labor issues etc. Hyping disinformation from anonymous internet troll campaigns while ignoring the truly Orwellian lies being told in every news cycle just means you love big brother.
- ajxs 6y ago> The real Orwellian phenomenon is not some kind of scary gatekeeper separating truth from fiction, which is actually a productive use of authority and necessary in any civilisation that doesn't want to turn into a clowncar... From this sentence, I assume that Stalinist Russia's approach to the subject of 'truth' would constitute a 'productive use of authority'? Do you think that the reporting in the early 2000s mainstream media regarding Saddam Hussein's supposed stockpile of chemical weapons constitutes a good example of the establishment media being good stewards of the truth? This propagation of blatantly false information by the establishment led all the way up to the invasion of Iraq. A war that is these days generally seen as a regime change for the benefit of interested parties, established under false pretenses. Or is all of this just 'not true communism' to you? Do you support the ways that governments, intelligence agencies and the media have been proven to have colluded to invert our reality? Or would you support some other, idealised government doing it? I have no idea what world your head lives in.