3 ms·
Squaring it is pretty easy, I think. Recommendation engines are neither inherently good or harmful -- think of them as an amplifier. In normal times, they wor
by crazygringo 6y ago
Squaring it is pretty easy, I think.
Recommendation engines are neither inherently good or harmful -- think of them as an amplifier.
In normal times, they work pretty well -- it gives you more of the stuff you like, which usually isn't harmful. Just entertaining/fluff/interesting/whatever.
But closer to an election, they can be gamed and weaponized for harm -- Russia can activate botnets, fake accounts, etc. and lies spread like wildfire.
So it's not about whether the recommendation engine is good or bad -- it works. The point is that close to an election, bad actors weaponize it 1,000x more or more often than they do the rest of the time, so they're turning it off. When it's not being weaponized so much, they can keep it on.
It's like paying for a DDoS protection layer at times when you know your site is likely to be attacked, but not using it the rest of the time.
- meheleventyone 6y agoIt seems hilariously naive to think that the only time people will be weaponising it is during an election and that there aren’t elections happening regularly all over the world so that if your point holds true such things should basically always be turned off.
- jayd16 6y agoThey didn't say that though. They're saying the consequences are worse before an election. At other times the pros outweigh the cons. Not sure I agree but its a pretty reasonable argument, I think.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y ago> When it's not being weaponized so much, they can keep it on. Clearly you understand the recommendation engine is being weaponised at all times. So why are you also trying to defend it? As others have pointed out, Twitters motivation is entirely composed of two motivating factors: financial and cover-your-arse.
- williamdclt 6y ago> But closer to an election, they can be gamed and weaponized for harm But there's elections all the time. There's many different elections in the US alone, any many many more throughout the world. And elections are just one thing, what about influence over opinions for bills/law/reforms? Wars? Public opinion about basically any subject, from economics to gender/race/class tensions? If you accept that social media is weaponised for this election, it seems naive to not accept it is being weaponised absolutely all the time