6 ms·
> Advertisers shouldn't know what I like, they should only know that a certain device with a certain ID likes X,Y topics. This is well-meaning but unfortunatel
by samatman 6y ago
> Advertisers shouldn't know what I like, they should only know that a certain device with a certain ID likes X,Y topics.
This is well-meaning but unfortunately it's also naive.
That kind of information, in aggregate, is trivial to de-anonymize at scale.
I'd like to see secondary markets for PID banned outright, personally. If you want that, go on the dark web and risk criminal sanctions. I'm sure there are some positive effects which would get thrown out with the enormous moral hazard, but I'd have to be convinced that it isn't worth it: as it stands, keeping personal user data should be a cost center for most businesses, something which exposes them to liability with no means to monetize other than providing whatever service they nominally exist for.
- Enginerrrd 6y ago>I'd like to see secondary markets for PID banned outright, personally. I totally agree with this, but I think it'd be terribly hard to implement in practice. How would you eliminate the rise of a single large body that partners with everyone during data consent forms? Sort of like a VISA for personal data. The result is the same, or arguably worse, but wouldn't be banned under your scheme.
- samatman 6y agoRegulatory capture, which is the broad umbrella I'd put that under, is a problem with any attempt at regulation, I agree. We can imagine a better regime, which could say "if you attempt to cheat or skirt around on this, we're going to hammer you harder than if you just break the rules", but how to actually get it is pretty murky. Easy to aim for that, and land in a situation where shadowy individuals wield great and capricious power.