3 ms·
These sorts of comparisons are extremely difficult to make. They depend very strongly on what exactly you’re looking at, how you’re measuring inflation, etc. Yo
by rayiner 6y ago
These sorts of comparisons are extremely difficult to make. They depend very strongly on what exactly you’re looking at, how you’re measuring inflation, etc. You can easily make charts that show total worker compensation is closely tracking productivity growth: https://www.americanactionforum.org/research/does-compensation-lag-behind-productivity/ https://www.americanactionforum.org/research/does-compensati...
(Unlike Common Dreams, this article shows their work and discloses their exact methodology and data sources.)
There’s a couple of big picture issues to consider:
1) Why focus on just wages, rather than just benefits? If productivity doubles, but the cost of providing healthcare triples, should employers cover the increased healthcare costs and also double wages? It’s not Microsoft’s fault that it costs $5,000 to get an MRI. From the perspective of how much is transferred from the employer to the employee, a dollar spent on wages isn’t any different than a dollar spent on healthcare.
Failing to distinguish the two things obscured the real problems. It makes you think something is a structural economic problem when in reality it’s cost disease in a particular industry. Wages aren’t keeping up with the cost of housing in New York and San Francisco. But nationwide, the median mortgage payment as a percentage of the median income has scarcely changed since the 1970s. Are wages the problem or are local laws around housing the problem?
2) There is kind of a metaphysical question about who should get the benefits of investment in technology. If you replace 100 workers with technology + very expensive capital equipment, productivity will increase by a factor of 10. (That’s how labor productivity is measured.) Does that mean wages should go up by a factor of 10?
- ptmcc 6y agoMany (most) minimum wage jobs do not provide any meaningful benefits, so it's tangential to the minimum wage in most cases. There's no doubt some fuzzy math involved to extrapolate inflation over the course of 50+ years, but I don't think that invalidates the fact that minimum wage has objectively not kept up with inflation even remotely. The federal minimum wage has been stuck at $7.25 since 2009, and a handful of states are only just now breaching $15/hr. At this rate by the time a federal increase happens we'll already be another 20 years behind. Worse yet is that labor data shows that more and more adults are working in minimum wage jobs, so the talking point of "it's just summer jobs for teenagers" and "it's entry level work to move on from" is very out of touch with reality these days. There are millions of people trying to survive on these wage levels and without benefits and it is not working.
- rayiner 6y agoInsofar as the article is talking about minimum wage workers specifically, it makes even less sense. Has the productivity of minimum wage workers gone up at the same rate as for all workers? The chart is comparing apples and oranges.
- bhupy 6y ago> The federal minimum wage has been stuck at $7.25 since 2009, and a handful of states are only just now breaching $15/hr. At this rate by the time a federal increase happens we'll already be another 20 years behind. But even more localities have higher minimum wages. Because the "minimum necessary" is extremely cost-of-living specific, it's decentralized. Despite Washington having a State minimum wage of $13.50, Seattle's minimum wage is $16.39/hr. Despite New York having a State minimum wage of $11.80, New York City's minimum wage is $15/hr Despite Illinois having a State minimum wage of $11, Chicago's minimum wage is $14/hr. Despite California having a State minimum wage of $13, San Francisco and Berkeley's minimum wages are $16.07/hr. Emeryville's minimum wage is $16.84/hr. San Jose, Santa Clara, Cupertino, Sunnyvale, Fremont, Belmont, Alameda, El Cerrito, Los Altos, Milpitas, Redwood City, Palo Alto, Richmond, Malibu, Los Angeles, Santa Monica, and Santa Rosa all have minimum wages at or higher than $15/hr. You can view it by state and by city here -> https://www.epi.org/minimum-wage-tracker/ https://www.epi.org/minimum-wage-tracker/
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> Worse yet is that labor data shows that more and more adults are working in minimum wage jobs, so the talking point of "it's just summer jobs for teenagers" and "it's entry level work to move on from" is very out of touch with reality these days. There are millions of people trying to survive on these wage levels and without benefits and it is not working. Then is it really true that productivity has increased? Millionaires and billionaires are not eating the food of millions of people or occupying hundreds of thousands of apartments and vehicles.
- zaroth 6y ago> Many (most) minimum wage jobs do not provide any meaningful benefits, so it's tangential to the minimum wage in most cases. I think you might be forgetting that most benefits at that wage level come from the government not the employer. When you count how those benefits have increased since 1968 then minimum wage has never been higher. This is most particularly true for Medicaid Expandion states since the ACA, but even non-expansion states with the health care tax credits and cost sharing reductions which are worth $10k-$20k per year to a low-income family of four. This adds about $4/hour to the effective wage of a dual-income family which TFA is just ignoring. The increasing value and accessibility of SNAP benefits is probably another $1/hour.