5 ms·
> Japan went from insular agrarianism to a world power to collapse to continued scientific development through to the 21st century. As did much of the Far East.
by rsynnott 6y ago
> Japan went from insular agrarianism to a world power to collapse to continued scientific development through to the 21st century. As did much of the Far East. Why not the Middle east?
There are lots of theories, of course, but one I find interesting is that East Asia, in addition to never being colonized to the same extent as most places, emerged with national boundaries largely intact. The Middle East was under foreign control for, well, basically forever (Romans -> Ottomans -> mandates) and ended up with some pretty weird national boundaries. This encouraged a lot of strife.
There's also the oil theory; countries with huge natural resources seem to often struggle to develop normally.
- dragontamer 6y ago> (Romans -> Ottomans -> mandates) Hittites -> Assyrians -> Babylonians -> Macedonia (aka Alexander the Great) -> Egyptian -> Romans -> Byzantine -> Mongols -> Ottomans That area has been locked in war and conquest for pretty much all of human history.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoWell, it is in the "middle."
- Anthony-G 6y agoShouldn’t Persian (Achaemenid) follow the Babylonians and precede the Macedonian empire? In 334 B.C, he utterly beat the armies of Persia – Steve Harris
- dragontamer 6y agoI'm working off of my High School history class from 16 years ago. I wouldn't be surprised if I forgot something (or got something out of order). I did play some Age of Empires, Civilization, and a few other history games that helped solidify my memory though.
- ncmncm 6y agoAnd the Neo-Assyrians. It's easy to lose track, but they get credit for arcade-supported aqueducts, while Romulus and Remus were still in diapers, to water the Hanging Gardens of ... Nineveh. But they were known at the time mostly for impaling their enemies.
- m0zg 6y ago> countries with huge natural resources Can confirm. That's why Russia is sliding down scientifically. People gravitate to where money and prestige is, and when you have money squirting from the ground, that demands (and receives) disproportionate attention. Another side effect of this is that it suffocates technology and innovation by both depriving it of investment, and by shaping the tax structure that excludes the possibility of survival for most non natural resource businesses unless they cheat on their taxes. It's a complex problem without a clear solution. Only Norway has been able to manage it well so far.
- thisiscorrect 6y agoIs this claiming that ethnic diversity within a country's borders causes strife, and in turn hinders scientific development?
- michaelt 6y agoThe theory rsynnott is referring to is what you'll find if you google "colonial borders" For example, some people have pointed out when European colonialists set borders, they were more concerned with natural resources and the opinions of competing colonial powers than with what the locals thought of the borders. Some people go further, thinking in at least some instances colonial governments intentionally created the situations for internal strife, as doing so could make regions easier to control. Set the borders so that area is 75% Religion A, 25% Religion B then you can appoint powerful local deputies from Religion B. Your powerful deputies will never support a popular revolution, as it'd make them lose all their power. Later the colonial power leaves, but the borders stay in the same place - along with a generous helping of resentment and fear between the groups - and the stage is set for internal strife, political blocs formed along ethnic lines, and so on. And if European colonists produced messed up borders, why couldn't Ottoman colonists have caused the same effects? That doesn't mean ethnic diversity causes the problem - but there are several elements that set the scene for problems, and ethnic voting blocs are an easily measured component, though not sufficient on their own.
- rsynnott 6y agoThe Ottoman situation was arguably even messier, because the Ottomans had one set of provinces, and then the Mandatory authorities had a somewhat different one.
- weswpg 6y agoMaybe national identity is the issue, rather than ethnic identity. In Japan's case, they had continuity of government and a professional bureaucracy.
- rsynnott 6y agoNational identity. Colonialism tended to produce totally novel countries, and often who was put in charge was largely random. It’s not just a colonialism thing either; in Europe wars often resulted in territorial change; the territory was then the cause of the next war.