14 ms·
Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan
- credit_guy 6y agoInstead of switching to hydrogen, one could make synthetic fuel out of seawater and use that and end up with net zero carbon emissions. The US Navy has just this thing in mind [1], [2]. They think they can end up with a cost of $2/gallon. [1] https://usea.org/sites/default/files/event-/Willauer_7_24_2019.pdf https://usea.org/sites/default/files/event-/Willauer_7_24_20... [2] https://www.nrl.navy.mil/news/releases/nrl-seawater-carbon-capture-process-receives-us-patent https://www.nrl.navy.mil/news/releases/nrl-seawater-carbon-c... [2]
- Hypx 6y agoYour process still requires an electrolysis step. It's basically claiming that they can extract CO2 alongside the hydrogen, allowing for either the Sabatier or Fischer-Tropsch process to make hydrocarbons in a relatively cost effective way. For it to work, it will require the ability to make hydrogen at extremely low cost. So in practice, it is likely to just be part of the hydrogen economy.
- wazoox 6y agoMy unpopular opinion is that H2 is an overall very poor solution to our current problems. It replies poorly to the electricity storage problem, because the production chain efficiency is really low, as low as 15-20% : electrolysis has a ~45% efficiency, then compressing the H2 to 700 bars consumes 30% of the stored energy, then you must add distribution and transport (and mostly can't use the huge, existing gas transportation infrastructure). While batteries have an efficiency over 90%, ditto (already existing) HT network. Also H2 isn't great as a dense power storage for vehicles either; the H2 plane is but a pipe dream, because it requires entirely new ways to store energy aboard, therefore probably requires entirely new planes with new architectures (like flying wings), huge new airports infrastructures... All in all, methane would be a saner, simpler target : you can create methane from water, CO2 and electricity; we already have all the infrastructure to transport, store and distribute methane; and using methane in vehicles of any kind is a no-brainer and requires no breakthrough or radical change. I don't believe a word of all the H2 hype.
- usrusr 6y ago> then compressing the H2 to 700 bars consumes 30% of the stored energy, then you must add distribution and transport (and mostly can't use the huge, existing gas transportation infrastructure). I recall reading somewhere that (in some/many countries) existing gas infrastructure is already specified to tolerate a meaningful (if small) fraction of H2 in the mix and that this fraction isn't currently maxed out, implying that it could be used as a sink for a quite sizable amount of new H2 production capacity as is. Background: historically the network was designed to tolerate a much higher H2 fraction because the initial gas source was a conversion process from coal that happened to yield a H2 fraction considerably higher than what is currently distributed. So as long as conventional gas use continues you'd have zero storage problem for new H2 production until the existing tolerance limit is maxed out. Only switching to anything close to 100% H2 would be a storage/distribution problem. Bonus implication: retooling existing infrastructure back to tolerate that old, higher H2 fraction would be considerably (orders of magnitude) easier than building a network for pure H2. I still share your main view, that there tends to be too much hype for H2. E.g. be wary of people who use an imminent "H2 future" as an argument to abandon all other projects. But that doesn't negate the value of real-life H2 projects at all: chances are we won't satisfy easy H2 use cases any time soon and the things that would make difficult/impossible H2 use cases difficult/impossible shouldn't be used as arguments against production until the easy use cases appear in reach to getting saturated.
- wazoox 6y agoI don't know for other countries, but in France Enedis (in charge of the distribution network) indicated that the network can support no more than 6% of H2. IIRC higher proportions of H2 would actively deteriorate tubes and stuff (I don't know the details, but apparently it can even react with certain materials and make them brittle for instance).
- rjsw 6y agoIt reacts with fairly common materials [1], steel is the main one. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_embrittlement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_embrittlement
- nickik 6y agoIn personal transportation, hydrogen is clearly dead. Even against current gen batteries, it can't win. Against next generation batteries that will be on the road far sooner then viable hydrogen car it doesn't even have chance to compete. The same goes for virtually all commercial land transportation. Maybe if you have some super long distance transport routes into remote areas, but that is likely less then 1% of the market. Its my believe as well that battery electric flight because of its operational efficiency will start to push chemical flight up market and eventually only intercontinental flights will be chemical. There is a clear path to this with current battery developments that are in the pipeline. I don't know enough about ships to judge what their requirements are. Maybe there hydrogen or other green manufactured fuels like methanol or dimethyl ether could have a future. However all of this said, hydrogen survives mostly because of massive global governments how somehow fixed on it as a solution. I don't know why this is the case, when there are tons of other promising technologies that could fix a lot of things get barely no attention at all. Hydrogen as a 'battery' for grid level extra energy for energy has many competitors who are mostly ignored. Maybe because oil company have been pushing it as 'the future' for a long time, but that is getting into conspiracy territory. What really baffles me is that we have government all over the world talking about hydrogen pushing trail programs paying money to oil industry and car makers to set up pilots and so on, at the same time we have companies like Tesla showing a viable way to get to reasonably cheap TWh factories and many other battery startups who barley get any government support at all. There are big research funds for things like Battery 500, or DoD/NASA work on Sulfer batteries. There are commercial players monitoring that and working with them, but they don't get money to set up huge production of these technologies. So lets continue to do fuel cell and hydrogen at the research level. But all those huge junks of money that they want to use to force down prices are much better invested into battery next generation battery technology, specifically setting up huge factories to build such. Because they replace carbon now, and will continue to do so for the next 30 years. Land transport and short distance flight, and many ships are clearly ready to be replaced with battery electric transportation, no need for some price hydrogen miracle that will be now-where near ready at mass scale by 2030 to do the same.
- funcDropShadow 6y agoBatteries are heavy. That is still a big problem for personal transportation in cars, planes, trains, buses and whatever. But personal transportation is not the source of all CO2 generated. There are homes, in most parts of the northern hemisphere they have to be heated. Replacing all those heating systems before there normal end of life, is a huge additional amount of CO2 to blow into the air. Running the same heaters, ovens, cars with a CO2 neutral produced methane seems to be way more cost- and CO2-efficient, at least in the medium term.
- aurizon 6y agoThe path to hydrogen has 3 components. 1 Increasing the efficiency of production. The 45% efficiency quoted by wazoox is low, IMHO, and may have been caused by driving the electrolysis cells at high currents, where they depart from reversibility. Lab cells that operate in a reversible manner get close to 100% - sadly at a low rate of production. Work needs to be done to get this higher at large rates of production. That said, inductrial production of hydrogen is often done by high temperature dispoportionation reactions, where the hydrogen is extracted. These are often done in large refineries where excess byproduct process heat is involved and many other products are made. Cold loops are used to get the hydrogen and it can also be extracted by metallic diffusion of hydrogen through thin membranes of palladium and sillver. Sadly, these both use energy only available as wasted process heat in hydrocarbon refineries - which are expected to decline in time and eventually become unavailable as the carbon economy declines over the next ~~100 years. 2 Storage costs. wazoox is correct. Compression to 2000+ PSI wastes a large part of the energy via the irreversibility of the reverse Carnot cycle. An IC engine gets power running a carnot cycle forward. 30% lost is quite believable. As liquid hydrogen in high efficiency low loss super-insulated tanks. These tanks lose hydrogen as heat gets in and boils it off - as long as you use the boiled off hydrogen as fuel cells fuel, this does not matter. You also need to add heat to feed gas to the cells, usually heat from the air works as long as it is designed to avoid frost blocking the atmospheric side.Hydride storage is another. Hydrogen forms clathrates - a crystal of organic material with hydrogen trapped atomically. It takes energy to make and energy to recover the hydrogen - 15-20% lost?? 3 The fuel cells. As in electrolysis, labs cells can be close to 100%. Hard driven cells are a lot less. Work needs to be done to get above~~95%. The warming of the earth is the gorilla in the room that holds the earth in its grip. This must be solved. Altentate means to make energy, solar, wind, tide, nuclear can do this - we must do this or the earth as we know it may well vanish, with huge loss of all species of plants and animals - one of which is man!
- nickik 6y agoWhen you say scaling and then mention 'silver and palladium' in the same text I can not take you seriously. No large industrial process to solve a global scaling problem can use even 1g of such metals. There is a reason tons and tons of money in battery research is spent on removing every single metal that is even remotely expensive. Cobalt is being cut out. Gravity is on the getting cut soon. Once those are achieved the nickel will be replaced with sulfur. Once we have sulfur-silicon batteries the material cost of the battery will be incredibly low and will TWh factories the marginal production cost per battery will also be incredibly low. Why should we spend lots of time and resources on a technology that has so many issues, when we already have a working much better solution, with much better prospect of being much better over time. In fact, in those technologies there is already a cost-curve happening right now that makes it cheaper every year and there is no reason why it should stop now.
- nedsma 6y agoThe EU is like Netflix but for energy projects. They always have allocate massive budget portions for such projects, especially for renewable ones. - Wind power - more wind turbines will be shut down than new built in Germany in 2021. They don't store energy, people living near wind parks hate them, and the government need to buy up power from the wind energy companies. - Biodiesel/ethanol fuel production - can't be made profitable without heavy state subventions, takes land that's used for food agriculture, in tropical states responsible for biohabitat loss. - Small hydro projects - probably one of the worst green energy initiatives, they destroy often all life in small rivers and creeks. - Solar energy - low efficiency, takes up land for farming, recycling issues. - Hydrogen power - we'll probably see excess wind power being used for hydrogen production, but still not really a viable alternative compared to lithium batteries. The EU can't make it cheaply, they're kind of relying on gigantic solar farms in Africa to make it in large quantities. Good thing they're keeping on shutting down of coal power plants.
- blablabla123 6y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but literally every source of energy is heavily subsidised. All future options that are realizable right now are mediocre but so are all existing options. > They don't store energy, people living near wind parks hate them You can literally apply this to every other form of energy. Who wants to live near an oil refinery, a coal mining area, a gas pipeline or a nuclear power plant? The current energy supply chains exist since decades and therefore appear so polished.
- jjoonathan 6y agoI thought they were shutting down nuclear and replacing it with new coal/gas? Or is that just Germany?
- ju-st 6y agoGermany is shutting down nuclear and coal. Gas is currently not competitive because it's too expensive and the government reduced renewable expansion targets. You will even have to pay taxes for self produced and self consumed solar power.
- lucioperca 6y agoThere might be a far cheaper way of producing hydrogen by igniting oil fires underground; https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24649235 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24649235
- NickM 6y agoI mean, that's a cool idea, but if the goal is to reach long-term sustainability then that still kinda seems like a dead end, no? Even in the best case scenario where nothing goes wrong and we're not emitting CO2, eventually we'll run out of oil, and then we're back to square one, only now we're stuck in a local maxima having already invested a bunch of resources into H2 tech, infrastructure, vehicles, etc.
- lucioperca 6y agoWell you do not emit CO2 as this will stay below (if done correctly) and will probably be bound permanently by the rock layers the gas diffuses into (https://uk.reuters.com/article/us-climate-rocks-sequestration-idUKTRE52552W20090306 https://uk.reuters.com/article/us-climate-rocks-sequestratio...).
- OvidStavrica 6y agoThis seems like a nonstarter until they can ensure that a hydrogen-based economy does not adversely impact the earth's ozone layer. They may build it only to shut it down as the world waits decades to recover from something potentially worse than the CFC debacle.