4 ms·
Remote work is possible, but it’s not for everyone. Some people are good at it; they adapt well and remain productive. But... as Marissa Meier found out, some
by mc32 6y ago
Remote work is possible, but it’s not for everyone. Some people are good at it; they adapt well and remain productive. But... as Marissa Meier found out, some people are utterly bad at it, or some take advantage of the privilege of self management and milk the system. So they will have to measure and gauge to see the balance of benefits and detriments of permanent change.
- make3 6y agowhat's the Marissa Meier thing?
- dudul 6y agoIs there any evidence showing that Meier's drastic move actually improved Yahoo's results? Also, do you think someone dishonest enough to take advantage of a remote position to spend their time working on their own startup would be a great asset on-site? I'm not saying remote work is for everyone, far from it, but there is a difference between comparing someone that is not as productive when WFH, and someone who milks the practice illegally.
- mc32 6y ago>” Is there any evidence showing that Meier's drastic move actually improved Yahoo's results?” I don’t think we have public insight into any internal results. We do know that there was evidence that a significant number of people logged in seldom or sporadically for years according to accounts of VPN and other logs. So the skating and slacking was inordinately sufficient for her to pull the plug on that option.
- cmiles74 6y agoThe quality of management will be the same regardless of if the employee is working from the office or at home. The person who was allowed to "milk the system" in the office, surely, will be allowed to do the same when they are working from home. It seems unreasonable to me an employee's manager would change their behavior based on where the employee happened to be working. I don't believe Marissa Meier demonstrated that managers significantly improved when their employees were required to work full time in the office. I think that would be the interesting measure here: do managers really perform better when their direct reports are in the office?
- mc32 6y agoSimply put. Some people need “structure” (that can be in the form of peer pressure, accountability, visibility, etc). Without it they flounder. At work if someone is not mainly on their job, people will eventually come to know them as slackers. Working from home allows quite a few slackers to fly under the radar. It has parallels in learning. Some people are self paced self learners and can learn remotely. Some need the pace and management by going to a physical classroom with an instructor.
- cmiles74 6y agoMy question is why would they perform better at the office? In your example their performance is the same and they become labeled as "slackers" by their co-worker and management. If we allow these people to perform poorly in the office, shouldn't we also allow them to perform poorly when they work remotely? If a manager is not providing adequate structure at the office, it seems unlikely that this would change regardless of where the employee is sitting. Those that need structure and do not get enough of it will flounder no matter their work location. I disagree that it is more difficult to detect those employees who are less productive when the employee is working from home. On the contrary, I suspect their lack of productivity would be even more glaring and obvious then in the office.
- sumedh 6y ago> My question is why would they perform better at the office? If you spend the whole day watching Youtube in office, your boss/colleagues will notice that and ask questions, no one is going to do that when you are at home.
- mc32 6y agoPeer pressure. There are more eyes at work. Wannabe slackers see other slackers getting cut and want to avoid that fate by doing the minimum that allows them to avoid that result which is greater than the minimum to avoid that while working from home.
- shock 6y ago> or some take advantage of the privilege of self management and milk the system. People milk the system in the office too. It's human nature to expend as little energy as possible for maximum rewards.
- mc32 6y agoOf course. That’s understood. We know at max, your best workers are productive doing things 40 to 50%. Slackers at the office much less. Slackers at home even worse.
- vsareto 6y agoCompanies have been milking workers as well. It's not surprising it comes back to them.
- mc32 6y ago?? That’s a total non-sequitur and has no connection to the other. Slackers will slack against themselves (hire a responsible home contractor vs one who slacks off and one who shows up whenever and does things half arsed). So it’s not about revenge or getting something back (that might be a motivation for some malcontents, but most slackers aren’t malcontents.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vsareto 6y agoI'm just saying: a demotivated or lied-to worker resembles slackers pretty closely. I think it's less about personal flaws than we think.
- mc32 6y agoI don’t think so. Demotivated people are troubled by the situation. They do not seek the situation that put them there. They want to be productive, but the system undermines them. Slackers just don’t give a care either way. They just wanna slack. They make a million excuses. It’s really not the same in any way.