3 ms·
> The ability for the government to censor transactions to terrorists, rogue states and oppressive governments is a good thing. Disagree, due to the fact that
by sneak 6y ago
> The ability for the government to censor transactions to terrorists, rogue states and oppressive governments is a good thing.
Disagree, due to the fact that the government being able to censor transactions of the government's choosing means that the government is able to censor transactions of the government's choosing. That's not a good thing.
> I want my currency to be subject to "government coercion" when the courts say so.
I would agree with this if and only if the protections of the law were equally applied, and all people had equal access to due process. Presently, both of those things are entirely untrue in most large, developed countries, despite being aspirational/stated goals.
The legal system can and does entirely fail people on a regular basis, and should not have the ultimate veto power over every type of private property, as has been the case historically.
> I for one do want the government to be able too regulate, control and trace transactions.
Many of us feel that freedom of association and freedom of trade with those associations are inherent natural rights, and such regulation or control over them is an illegitimate infringement upon them, regardless of however many democratically-elected representatives say they're not.
Ultimately the state's authority to do such things ("regulate, control") is based on the application of violence, or the threat of same. Violence cannot solve math problems, ergo, cryptocurrencies are a fundamental threat to the authority and existence of the state.
Honestly, I'm completely surprised that they've allowed them to get as big as they have without banning them outright.
- arcticbull 6y ago> Violence cannot solve math problems, ergo, cryptocurrencies are a fundamental threat to the authority and existence of the state. This is the biggest, most obvious misconception about cryptocurrencies. Violence can solve any math problem. With a rubber hose, your coins are theirs. In prison, crypto won't help you. [1] [1] https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/news/bitcoin-robbery-torture-cryptocurrency-netherlands-a8807986.html https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/ne...
- sneak 6y agoMultisignature transactions are a thing. This isn't your grandfather's symmetric key crypto.
- arcticbull 6y agoIs there a hose shortage? Seriously, you're underestimating a motivated government's ability to use violence to either prevent transactions (by taking some of the multisig parties out) or to coerce a transaction (by applying multiple hoses to multiple people). Say they capture your family. Would you not make a transaction to save your family? If you didn't they'd just take you out. Heck, a motivated government might just take you out after anyways! See how your "coins" are no longer your biggest problem under an authoritarian regime? In the face of the KGB, you wouldn't be saying "but your violence can't solve this math problem" for very long. Not without that tongue. How many fingernails does a man need anyways? Trust me, that math problem's getting solved. With hoses. Real fast. This is one of those conceptual exercises that falls right over.
- sneak 6y agoIt seems that you and I are talking at cross purposes. Modern technology makes new circumstances where it can be made impossible for a single person, or even all of the people in one or more major jurisdictions, to be able to effect a transaction, acting alone or in concert. Hardware security systems also permit such things, in more limited circumstances. The state's capacity for violence is finite, and is scoped by their legal and physical jurisdictions. There is no state, as yet, that can wield unlimited violence throughout the same scope as the uncensored internet.
- arcticbull 6y agoI guess I just don't see it. One man, can tell the KGB, to extract fingernails until the money moves or is no longer capable of moving. > There is no state, as yet, that can wield unlimited violence throughout the same scope as the uncensored internet. So a sufficiently motivated state censors the internet. EZPZ. Half the world's already doing it. Your problem isn't the money, your problem is a tyrannical government. It can and will do whatever it takes, and by virtue of being a large group of people vs. you and your, well, fingernails, no amount of math is going to resolve this situation in your favor. The only thing you can actually do to improve your situation is topple the government. And once you do that, you don't need crypto, do you?