4 ms·
Counter-points, since it's worth sharing the whole picture. (1) The ability for the government to censor transactions to terrorists, rogue states and oppressiv
by arcticbull 6y ago
Counter-points, since it's worth sharing the whole picture.
(1) The ability for the government to censor transactions to terrorists, rogue states and oppressive governments is a good thing. Evidenced not least by the fact Bitcoin was likely created by an international narcotics and arms trafficking racist bond villain who at one point tried to keep Rhodesian farmland in the hands of the whites and nearly started a cocaine plantation in Somalia [0, 3]
(2a) Inflation isn't some magical evil conspiracy, money is an intentionally lossy store of value. Inflation incentivizes investment and allocation of capital towards the most productive enterprises. This is intentional. Inflation doesn't affect people who own assets, including real estate and equities, so long as wages keep pace with inflation. They have.
(2b) Deflation is bad, as it decreases the velocity of money and economic productivity. Why would you spend money today when it would be worth more tomorrow? Hundreds of BTC are lost every few days due to the user-hostile nature of cryptocurrencies.
(2c) Deflation also concentrates wealth with existing holders, hurting the next generation of market participants, and entrenching the current BTC wealth distribution. This is worse than any banana republic. Unless you're one of the whales, you're a peasant fighting scraps, and your kids will practically be serfs.
(3) I want my currency to be subject to "government coercion" when the courts say so. If you don't trust your government or the courts, the "coercion" of the government is literally the least of your problems.
(4) I for one do want the government to be able too regulate, control and trace transactions. Which is something they can easily and explicitly do with a shared public ledger.
(5a) Massive waste, each proof-of-waste BTC transaction produces 100g of e-waste and consumes as much electricity as it takes to drive a Tesla from SF to NY. [1] All to operate a network that you could replace with a single DynamoDB table and likely one man on a stationary bike powering it.
(5b) At market rates for electricity alone a crypto transaction costs about $80, which is socialized across the block reward. When this stops, people will have to pay the whole cost of a transaction, which in turn they will not do, which will shut down miners, which will kill the security aspects of the network.
[0] https://www.wired.com/story/was-bitcoin-created-by-this-international-drug-dealer-maybe/ https://www.wired.com/story/was-bitcoin-created-by-this-inte...
[1] https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Le_Roux https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Le_Roux
- sneak 6y ago> The ability for the government to censor transactions to terrorists, rogue states and oppressive governments is a good thing. Disagree, due to the fact that the government being able to censor transactions of the government's choosing means that the government is able to censor transactions of the government's choosing. That's not a good thing. > I want my currency to be subject to "government coercion" when the courts say so. I would agree with this if and only if the protections of the law were equally applied, and all people had equal access to due process. Presently, both of those things are entirely untrue in most large, developed countries, despite being aspirational/stated goals. The legal system can and does entirely fail people on a regular basis, and should not have the ultimate veto power over every type of private property, as has been the case historically. > I for one do want the government to be able too regulate, control and trace transactions. Many of us feel that freedom of association and freedom of trade with those associations are inherent natural rights, and such regulation or control over them is an illegitimate infringement upon them, regardless of however many democratically-elected representatives say they're not. Ultimately the state's authority to do such things ("regulate, control") is based on the application of violence, or the threat of same. Violence cannot solve math problems, ergo, cryptocurrencies are a fundamental threat to the authority and existence of the state. Honestly, I'm completely surprised that they've allowed them to get as big as they have without banning them outright.
- arcticbull 6y ago> Violence cannot solve math problems, ergo, cryptocurrencies are a fundamental threat to the authority and existence of the state. This is the biggest, most obvious misconception about cryptocurrencies. Violence can solve any math problem. With a rubber hose, your coins are theirs. In prison, crypto won't help you. [1] [1] https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/news/bitcoin-robbery-torture-cryptocurrency-netherlands-a8807986.html https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/ne...
- sneak 6y agoMultisignature transactions are a thing. This isn't your grandfather's symmetric key crypto.