5 ms·
The hidden taxation of inflation is a feature. It creates an incentive for people to invest, instead of, like dragons, uselessly sitting on a pile of money.
by vkou 6y ago
The hidden taxation of inflation is a feature. It creates an incentive for people to invest, instead of, like dragons, uselessly sitting on a pile of money.
- qertoip 6y agoThe opposite is true: inflation takes away the hard earned value that could otherwise be invested.
- smorephism 6y agoYes, that's the idea: the price of sitting on a dragon's hoard of cash that's not doing anything is that its value decreases over time, so you are incentivized to actually do something with it.
- megous 6y agoYour economics are weird. Making a stupid analogy doesn't help it. There are no dragons, just individual people making decisions about how much to save and for what purpose, and when to spend it, based on their individual circumstances. Holding on to savings is neither positive nor negative, and should be a personal decision based on individual's circumstances (that's where the most detailed information are available about what's good for the individual), not something forced/influenced from the top by blunt whole market manipulation via forced depreciation of value of money, by some committee. All you've achieved by forced depreciation is forcing people to make needless risks, just to keep value of their savings, while they're trying to save up for something (like starting a business, or buying a flat, or safety of mind). Whole class of brokers, and traders, and lenders, who pray on this situation benefit, of course.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 6y agoNo, lol, the opposite is not true. At an inflation rate of 2% per annum, if your wages keep pace with in inflation as they historically have, it's not stealing anything from anyone. You take the money as you receive it, and you invest it. It's a forcing function. You can invest it in something as simple as a savings account if you believe that's the right approach. Even in a savings account it's collateralizing loans. The only place your actual cash is at real risk from inflation is under your mattress. That's the point.
- andrewjl 6y agoThe real yield for USD Treasury is currently negative across all maturities, this means that your cash has a negative real return in a savings account at a bank. [1] [1] https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/interest-rates/Pages/TextView.aspx?data=realyield https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/i...
- nybble41 6y ago> …if your wages keep pace with in inflation as they historically have… If we're speaking historically, under inflation the prices of consumer goods have tended to rise faster than wages. Under deflation the opposite has been true. Of course lately we have massive improvements in technology to thank for boosting productivity in almost every field, which somewhat masks the negative effects of the inflation. If it weren't for that there probably wouldn't be much of an economy left by this point. Cash has no utility on its own. It's just a placeholder. Take some out of circulation and the purchasing power of the remaining cash will automatically adjust to match the value of everything available for trade. Stuffing cash in your mattress hurts no one. Inexpertly dumping it into the market to avoid inflation, on the other hand, might well bring down the average rate of return. The natural rate of inflation or deflation is a key economic indicator which reflects the expected average rate of return. Only ventures with expected returns above this rate (the deflation rate) are economically productive. Messing with the money supply distorts this signal and, though excess inflation, encourages investment in less ventures which divert resources away from the more productive ones. Of course artificial deflation is no better; the ideal is not forced deflation but rather a currency whose supply is not subject to manipulation.
- sthnblllII 6y agoConsumers spend almost every dollar as soon as they get it. The ones hoarding capital are the banks. The fed can never seem to get interest rates low enough to get the banks to loan to businesses. So why do big banks get to keep the money the fed prints instead of the government, thereby lowering taxes and increasing consumer spending? Because then banks wouldn't get unlimited cheap capital and wouldnt be able to continue the leveraged buyout of American industry. Entrepreneurs would control the economy like they used to instead of financiers, and we cant have that now can we?
- notahacker 6y ago> The ones hoarding capital are the banks...get to keep the money the fed prints instead of the government Banks lend more dollars than they borrow from the Fed (or depositors). They don't 'get to keep' money they borrow from the Fed, they repay it at the base interest rate.
- sthnblllII 6y agoThey spend it before the inflationary effect occurs, so yes, it is a transfer of wealth from holders of dollars to banks. The hoarding obviously isn't in cash, just look at their financial reports to know what they do with the money, and it largely isn't lending to businesses for expanding production. Since deregulation, much of the new money has gone to buying stocks. Not exactly helping the economy. As long as the stock market appreciates faster than the prime rate, it makes sense to borrow money from the fed to buy stocks. Especially if the fed is buying stocks too, keeping the market in perpetual inflation driven growth.
- gamblor956 6y agoBanks are not allowed to hoard capital, and financially speaking, keeping cash in reserve means they're not making money from it. Indeed, the regulations require the opposite of what you suggest: banks are are required to maintain a certain level of capital reserves to avoid collapse even though they would prefer to spend all of it on investments or making loans.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]